Asteroseismic Structure Inversions of Main-Sequence Solar-like Oscillators with Convective Cores
Lynn Buchele, Earl P. Bellinger, Saskia Hekker, Sarbani Basu · 2024
Read Asteroseismic Structure Inversions of Main-Sequence Solar-like Oscillators with Convective Cores by Lynn Buchele, Earl P. Bellinger, Saskia Hekker, Sarbani Basu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05094.txt.
Introduction
Lynn Buchele, Earl P. Bellinger, Saskia Hekker, and Sarbani Basu use the vibrations of sun-like stars to test whether computer models match their true interiors. Standard models fit to a star cannot fully reproduce its observed tones, which hints that the model's inner structure is off. The team's method, called structure inversion, works backward from the tones to probe the sound speed inside the star.
Earlier work covered twelve stars with radiative cores; this study extends the test to 43 stars with convective cores seen by the Kepler mission. For about half, models matched the inner structure within the measurement error. The rest split between models with sound speed too high and too low. Using the star with the largest mismatch, the team tried changes in mixing and element settling physics, but none closed the gap. The paper shows where stellar models still fail and by how much.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lynn Buchele, Earl P. Bellinger, Saskia Hekker, Sarbani Basu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05094
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Asteroseismic Structure Inversions of Main-Sequence Solar-like Oscillators with Convective Cores Lynn Buchele, Earl P. Bellinger, Saskia Hekker, Sarbani Basu Abstract Asteroseismic inferences of main-sequence solar-like oscillators often rely on best-fit models. However, these models cannot fully reproduce the observed mode frequencies, suggesting that the internal structure of the model does not fully match that of the star. Asteroseismic structure inversions provide a way to test the interior of our stellar models. Recently, structure inversion techniques were used to study 12 stars with radiative cores. In this work, we extend that analysis to 43 main-sequence stars with convective cores observed by Kepler to look for differences in the sound speed profiles in the inner 30% of the star by radius. For around half of our stars, the structure inversions show that our models reproduce the internal structure of the star, where the inversions are sensitive, within the observational uncertainties. For the stars where our inversions reveal significant differences, we find cases where our model sound speed is too high and cases where our model sound speed is too low. We use the star with the most significant differences to explore several changes to the physics of our model in an attempt to resolve the inferred differences. These changes include using a different overshoot prescription and including the effects of diffusion, gravitational settling, and radiative levitation. We find that the resulting changes to the model structure are too small to resolve the differences shown in our inversions. I Introduction Among the stars observed by Kepler , high-precision oscillation mode frequencies have been determined for around 100 main-sequence solar-like oscillators [ 25 , 54 ] . This sample has been used to study a variety of physical processes including chemical transport [ 61 , 26 , 84 , 58 , 57 ] , convection in stellar cores [ 1 , 86 , 60 ] , rotation [ 14 ] , and magnetic fields [ 76 , 75 , 48 ] . This work often involves finding a best-fit model for each star using a stellar evolution code. Best-fit models are generally found by matching the observed frequencies of a star or by fitting parameters derived from those frequencies, such as the frequency separation ratios [ 74 ] or glitch signatures due to helium ionization [ 83 ] , while matching the position of the star on the HR diagram. In general, however, these models are unable to fully reproduce the observed parameters, suggesting that there are still some deficits in our understanding of stellar interiors. Fortunately, the large number of precise oscillation modes observed in these stars makes it possible to take the analysis further using structure inversions. This technique, developed for geology [ 3 ] and used extensively in helioseismology [ 7 , 19 , for a review see, for example,] , uses the inherent sensitivity of each oscillation mode to infer differences between the interior structure of a star and a given best-fit model (see e.g. Gough & Thompson 38 , Gough 36 , Pijpers 68 , Bellinger et al. 10 , Buldgen et al. 16 ). These inferred differences can be used to test how well the interior structure of our models matches that of observed stars, as well as provide information on what changes may be necessary to improve our models. In Figure 1 , we show the existing sample of main-sequence solar-like oscillators studied using asteroseismic structure inversions. Buchele et al. [15] , henceforth B24, presented results for 12 stars with radiative cores, including the solar analogues 16 Cyg A and B which were also studied by Bellinger et al. [11] and Buldgen et al. [17] . Structure inversions have also been used to study a main-sequence star with a small convective core [ 12 ] and two stars evolved enough to exhibit mixed modes [ 50 ] . All three of these stars are in the sample presented here, where we extend the work of B24 to cover main-sequence solar-like oscillators with convective cores observed by Kepler . Our primary goals of this work are to determine which stars have observational data suitable for inversions and to examine how well models created using common modeling choices reproduce the structure of observed stars. Figure 1: Hertzsprung–Russell diagram for main-sequence solar-like oscillators with inversion results available. Stars have been categorized based on their inversion results in this work and in B24, represented by the color of the symbol. Stars with other inversion results available are indicated with larger open symbols. The uncertainties of the luminosity values are smaller than the points. Stellar evolutionary tracks of several masses are shown for reference. II Forward Modeling As structure inversions infer differences between a star and a model, the first step is to find a suitably close reference model, typically the best-fit model from a grid-based modeling or optimization procedure. The process of finding such a model is called forward modeling. To find our reference models, we used a grid-based method similar to that used by B24. We constructed a grid of 24,530 tracks using the stellar evolution code MESA [ 63 , 64 , 65 , 66 , 67 , 47 ] . The details of the grid that are unchanged between this work and B24 are provided in Appendix A.1 . There are two important changes which we discuss here. It is well known that including diffusion and gravitational settling of elements without also including the effects of radiative levitation produces models with unrealistic surface abundances in this mass range [ 56 , 26 , e.g.] . However, including radiative levitation significantly increases the computation time of models, such that it would be difficult to compute the number of models necessary to cover the parameters space of the observations. We chose to compromise and evolve our tracks without including diffusion, settling, or radiative levitation. Additionally, since we are dealing with stars with convective cores, we use the exponential overshooting [ 31 , 40 ] scheme implemented in MESA where the overshoot region is treated as fully mixed without changing the thermal gradient. This is described in detail in Paxton et al. [63] . The parameters varied in this grid are mass, initial helium abundance, initial metallicity, mixing length parameter, and overshooting parameter. To cover the parameter space efficiently, we varied each parameter using a Sobol sequence [ 9 , 80 , see Appendix B of] within the ranges listed in Table 1 . For each model in the grid, we calculated the adiabatic frequencies using GYRE [ 82 ] . We then scanned the grid to find the model parameters that best fit the frequencies, effective temperature, and metallicity by minimizing: \displaystyle\chi^{2}_{\rm{fit}}=\frac{\left(T_{\rm{eff,obs}}-T_{\rm{eff,mod}}\right)^{2}}{\sigma^{2}_{T_{\rm{eff}}}} (1) \displaystyle+\frac{\left(\rm{[Fe/H]}_{\rm{obs}}-\rm{[Fe/H]}_{\rm{mod}}\right)^{2}}{\sigma^{2}_{\rm{[Fe/H]}}} (2) \displaystyle+\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i}^{N}\frac{\left(\nu_{i,\rm{obs}}-\nu_{i,\rm{mod}}\right)^{2}}{\sigma^{2}_{\nu,i}}, (3) where N is the number of observed frequencies, \nu_{i} is the frequency that corresponds to the i th pair of radial order ( n ) and spherical degree ( l ) where the model’s frequencies have been corrected for surface effects using the two-term correction from Ball & Gizon [5] , \sigma denotes the uncertainty of the observed parameter, and the subscripts ‘obs’ and ‘mod’ denote the observations and the model, respectively. Our definition of \chi^{2}_{\rm{fit}} treats all the frequencies as a single