The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs 2015 The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs – 21
Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth · 2024
Read The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs 2015 The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs – 21 by Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05054.txt.
Introduction
Alfie Robinson, James Owen, and Richard Booth model how young planet forming discs lose their dust in a 2024 paper. Discs keep most of their glow for millions of years, then clear quickly from the inside out. Light driven evaporation explains that pattern, but it predicts many discs with large empty centers that are rarely seen.
The authors test whether radiation pressure can blow enough dust away to match observations. Their simulations include dust growth, break up, and light transfer. In most cases, dust loss fell five to ten times short of what is needed, because grains larger than a micrometer stayed behind. Only discs with low dust mass and strong high energy light met the observed limits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 109 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05054
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs 2015 The effect of radiation pressure on the dispersal of photoevaporating discs – 21 Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth Abstract Observed IR excesses indicate that protoplanetary discs evolve slowly for the majority of their lifetime before losing their near- and mid-IR excesses on short timescales. Photoevaporation models can explain this “two-timescale” nature of disc evolution through the removal of inner regions of discs after a few million years. However, they also predict the existence of a population of non-accreting discs with large cavities. Such discs are scarce within the observed population, suggesting the models are incomplete. We explore whether radiation-pressure-driven outflows are able to remove enough dust to fit observations. We simulate these outflows using cuDisc , including dust dynamics, growth/fragmentation, radiative transfer and a parameterisation of internal photoevaporation. We find that, in most cases, dust mass-loss rates are around 5-10 times too small to meet observational constraints. Particles are launched from the disc inner rim, however grains larger than around a micron do not escape in the outflow, meaning mass-loss rates are too low for the initial dust masses at gap-opening. Only systems that have smooth photoevaporation profiles with gas mass-loss rates > ∼ >\sim 5 × 10 − 9 5\text{\times}{10}^{-9} M ⊙ M_{\odot} yr -1 and disc dust masses < ∼ <\sim 1 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} at the time of gap opening can meet observational constraints; in the current models these manifest as EUV winds driven by atypically large high-energy photon fluxes. We also find that the height of the disc’s photosphere is controlled by small grains in the outflow as opposed to shadowing from a hot inner rim; the effect of this can be seen in synthetic scattered light observations. 1 Introduction From the infrared (IR) excesses associated with young stars in nearby star forming regions, protoplanetary discs are known to live for around a few million years before dispersing on much shorter timescales, becoming debris discs without a large, optically thick near-IR excess ( Strom et al. 1989 ; Sung et al. 2009 ; Wyatt et al. 2015 ; Hardy et al. 2015 ) . Although not yet fully understood, the initial primordial phase of disc evolution is currently thought to be governed by two physical processes; viscous evolution driven by turbulence ( Pringle 1981 ; Balbus & Hawley 1991 ) , and magneto-hydrodynamical (MHD) winds that carry mass and angular momentum away from the disc system ( Blandford & Payne 1982 ; Pudritz & Norman 1983 ; Bai & Stone 2013 ) . Recent work suggests that MHD winds are the more important process given that non-ideal MHD effects lead to large swathes of the disc being too weakly ionised to support the MRI ( Gammie 1996 ; Perez-Becker & Chiang 2011 ) , and there is currently a large amount of study going into the effect of MHD winds on disc evolution ( Tabone et al. 2022 ; Somigliana et al. 2023 ; Weder et al. 2023 ; Coleman et al. 2024 ) . The secondary, ephemeral phase of disc evolution has generally been understood to be a consequence of photoevaporation of the disc due to stellar irradiation, however MHD winds under certain conditions can also lead to dispersal on fast timescales. Photoevaporation occurs when high energy photons from the central star heat up gas in the upper layers of the disc to energies at which it is able to escape the gravitational potential of the system ( Hollenbach et al. 1994 ) . A simple “two-timescale” picture of disc evolution and dispersal emerges from comparing the temporal evolution of wind mass-loss rates and the mass accretion rate given by viscous/MHD wind processes, first suggested by Clarke et al. 2001 . In this picture, after a few millions of years of primordial evolution, the temporally decaying accretion rate falls below the wind mass-loss rate. This allows the wind to open a gap in the disc at the wind launch radius, as it removes gas on shorter timescales than those required to replace it via the accretion flow from the outer disc. This splits the disc into an inner and outer component. Without the replenishment of material from the outer disc, the inner disc drains rapidly onto the central star in \sim 10 5 years. The outer portion of the disc is then removed from the inside-out by the photoevaporative wind. For MHD winds, it has been shown that this two-timescale behaviour can also be found if the magnetisation of the disc increases with time ( Armitage et al. 2013 ; Bai 2016 ) . In the photoevaporative case, the loss of the disc’s inner regions moves it into the class of discs referred to as ‘transition’ discs; those whose spectral energy distributions (SEDs) lack a hot, near-IR component, indicating an inner hole in the disc material ( Strom et al. 1989 ; Owen & Clarke 2012 ; Ercolano & Pascucci 2017 , see e.g.) . Whilst transition discs are a diverse population best explained by a variety of processes including gap-opening by nascent planets ( Artymowicz & Lubow 1996 ; van der Marel et al. 2018 ) , grain growth ( Dullemond et al. 2001 ) , and dead-zone trapping ( Regály et al. 2012 ) , a small fraction of transition discs are not observed to be accreting and may be best explained through photoevaporation ( Cieza et al. 2010 ; van der Marel et al. 2016 ) . Along with direct observations of disc photoevaporation occuring ( Ercolano & Owen 2016 ; Weber et al. 2020 ; Rab et al. 2022 ) , the loss of the inner disc in the photoevaporation scenario makes it favourable for explaining the observed two-phase nature of disc evolution. Photoevaporative flows can be driven by a range of photon energies; extreme ultraviolet (EUV) ( Hollenbach et al. 1994 ; Font et al. 2004 ; Alexander et al. 2006b ) , far ultraviolet (FUV) ( Richling & Yorke 2000 ; Gorti & Hollenbach 2009 ) , and X-rays ( Owen et al. 2011b ; Picogna et al. 2019 ; Ercolano et al. 2023 ) . Each of these energy regimes exhibit different wind mass-loss profiles amongst other wind properties, but all still produce the same qualitative two-timescale picture described earlier. This is because in all regimes the wind mass-loss rate does not decrease with disc mass as rapidly as the accretion rate; a situation which always leads to gap-opening. However, Owen et al. 2011b found that models of internal photoevaporation lead to a tension between the simulations, which predict a population of non-accreting discs with large inner cavities and still a substantial mid-IR excess (dubbed “relic” discs), and the observations, which exhibit a scarcity of such systems ( Hardy et al. 2015 ) . Photoevaporation simulations naturally produce the relic disc population due to the fact that the stellar radiation intercepted by the disc decreases with radius whilst the outer disc still retains a large proportion of its initial mass, leading to long timescales associated with the dispersal of the outer disc. The paucity of such systems in the observed population