Level Up or Game Over: Exploring How Dark Patterns Shape Mobile Games Conference: International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia; December 1–4, 2024; Stockholm, Sweden International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia (MUM ’24), December 1–4, 2024, Stockholm, Sweden DOI: 10.

Sam Niknejad, Thomas Mildner, Nima Zargham, Susanne Putze, Rainer Malaka · 2024

Read Level Up or Game Over: Exploring How Dark Patterns Shape Mobile Games Conference: International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia; December 1–4, 2024; Stockholm, Sweden International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia (MUM ’24), December 1–4, 2024, Stockholm, Sweden DOI: 10. by Sam Niknejad, Thomas Mildner, Nima Zargham, Susanne Putze, Rainer Malaka (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05039.txt.

Introduction

Niknejad and co-authors studied manipulative design tricks in mobile games, in a paper published in 2024. Such dark patterns nudge players to spend time or money against their own interests. They work through time pressure, money traps, social guilt, and psychological hooks. The team analyzed user-generated data covering 1,496 games. They sorted games into those seen as dark and those seen as healthy, then compared how heavily each group deploys the tricks.

Dark patterns proved widespread in the problem games, as expected. They also turned up often in games most people would call benign. That spread is the finding with teeth. It suggests the tricks are a norm of the business model, not a fringe habit. The authors add hard numbers to an ethical debate. Their data can support design rules that protect players, especially children.

Catalog record

CREATORSam Niknejad, Thomas Mildner, Nima Zargham, Susanne Putze, Rainer Malaka
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Level Up or Game Over: Exploring How Dark Patterns Shape Mobile Games Conference: International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia; December 1–4, 2024; Stockholm, Sweden International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia (MUM ’24), December 1–4, 2024, Stockholm, Sweden DOI: 10.1145/3701571.3701604 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1283-8/24/12 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing HCI design and evaluation methods CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing theory, concepts and paradigms Sam Niknejad, Thomas Mildner, Nima Zargham, Susanne Putze, Rainer Malaka Abstract . This study explores the prevalence of dark patterns in mobile games that exploit players through temporal, monetary, social, and psychological means. Recognizing the ethical concerns and potential harm surrounding these manipulative strategies, we analyze user-generated data of 1496 games to identify relationships between the deployment of dark patterns within “dark” and “healthy” games. Our findings reveal that dark patterns are not only widespread in games typically seen as problematic but are also present in games that may be perceived as benign. This research contributes needed quantitative support to the broader understanding of dark patterns in games. With an emphasis on ethical design, our study highlights current problems of revenue models that can be particularly harmful to vulnerable populations. To this end, we discuss the relevance of community-based approaches to surface harmful design and the necessity for collaboration among players/users and practitioners to promote healthier gaming experiences. HCI Human-Computer Interaction Figure 1 . AI generated image showing a mobile device on which a fighting scene between a heroine and a monster takes place to represent the a fight against dark patterns. The image was generated using DALL-E 3 . 1. Introduction The gaming industry is a steadily growing market with number of players steadily increasing ( Statista 2019 ) and more purchases recorded over the past years ( Statista 2020 ) . Today, the industry flourishes as e-sports and streaming services offer new opportunities for additional revenue, e.g., through advertisement ( Gawrysiak et al. 2020 ) , further amplifying its growth. This is reflected by moves in the industry from selling full game titles to alternative payment models. As one example, free-to-play models have become more widespread, especially in mobile apps, providing players with essential gaming experiences that can be enhanced through in-app purchases ( Davidovici-Nora 2013 ; Cai et al. 2019 ) . Aside from certain benefits for the industry and its consumers, an ongoing discourse covers the potential negative implications of excessive gaming on players’ well-being and health ( Király et al. 2023 ) . In 2015, a cross-national study in European countries with a particular focus on internet gaming disorder revealed that 3\% of adolescents who regularly engage in gaming are affected, with a further 8.4\% being at risk ( Müller et al. 2015 ) . Generally, problems in self-control can be linked to unhealthy behavior ( Cudo et al. 2020 ) . From an HCI and design perspective, recent efforts to capture and describe unethical designs -- specifically ‘‘dark patterns’’ 1 1 1 We are aware of a recent choice by the ACM Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Council to categorise the term “dark pattern” as problematic ( ACM 2023 ) . However, we opted to use the term to stay in line with related work describing unethical and harmful UI practices. We acknowledge that the term could be misinterpreted with a connotation that “dark” could refer to “bad” or “evil’ intentions. However, we argue that the term makes a reference to hidden or obfuscated consequences for users ( Brignull 2010 ) , where intentions play a secondary role. – provide some pointers directed at practices that negatively affect user experience by tricking users into unwanted behaviour and restricting available choices ( Brignull 2010 ; Gray et al. 2018 ) . Dark patterns have been shown to influence users into making undesirable choices ( Gray et al. 2024 ) with instances described in e-commerce ( Mathur et al. 2019 ) , social media ( Mildner et al. 2023b ; Schaffner et al. 2022 ) , and mobile applications ( Di Geronimo et al. 2020 ; Gray et al. 2018 ) . A critical issue of these unethical practices lies in the inability of users to effectively recognise and avoid their effects, as indicated in several studies (e.g., ( Luguri and Strahilevitz 2021 ; Mildner et al. 2023a ; Bongard-Blanchy et al. 2021 ; Di Geronimo et al. 2020 ) ). Figure 2 . This figure presents a mock-up example based on Zagal et al.’s ( Zagal et al. 2013 ) “playing by appointment” dark pattern in the form of quests that require users to play the game on a daily basis. The displayed graphic is the original work of one of this paper’s authors and does not violate any licensing. This figure demonstrates a mock example of a playing-by-appointment dark pattern by Zagal et al. that offers players daily achievements but requires regular logins and activities. The latter forces players to play the game daily in order to get the most out of it and not get a disadvantage. While dark patterns have been explored and studied in various domains ( Mathur et al. 2021 ; Gray et al. 2023 ; Chang et al. 2024 ) , there remains a research gap, particularly in gaming contexts. In this scope, Zagal et al. ( Zagal et al. 2013 ) conceptualised domain-specific dark patterns typical to game-related interactions. In their work, the authors provide definitions for seven types within three categories: temporal, monetary, and social capital-based. Figure 2 includes an example of their temporal “playing by appointment” dark pattern, which forces players to return to a game daily in order to complete quests. Recently, Hadan et al. ( Hadan et al. 2024 ) investigated dark patterns in games by building on Zagal et al.’s definitions following a qualitative approach, similar to other work on the topic (e.g. ( Gray et al. 2018 ) , ( Mildner et al. 2023b ) , ( Gunawan et al. 2021 ) ). Although these works are needed to understand underlying mechanisms and users’ perceptions of dark patterns, quantitative approaches help understand the range in which certain dark patterns occur. Mathur et al.’s ( Mathur et al. 2019 ) large-scale analysis of online shopping sites spearheaded these kinds of efforts. However, similar studies are relatively scarce. Following up on Zagal et al.’s discussion, which emphasises a misalignment between creators’ interests and players’ welfare, we aim to extend the exploration of dark patterns in games by presenting the results of a quantitative study utilising user-generated data. To this end, we explore a large set of user reviews based on the website www.darkpatterns.games ( DarkPattern.games 2024 ) , considering 1.496 mobile iOS and Android games. The website adapts Zagal et al.’s ( Zagal et al. 2013 ) dark pattern categories and includes a fourth, thus differentiating between temporal, monetary, social, and psychological types of dark patterns. In line with Zagal et al’s ( Zagal et al. 2013 ) work, temporal dark patterns refer to strategies prolonging or shortening certain interaction sequences against players’ expectations. They manifest, for instance, as “grinding” or “playing by appointment”. Monetary dark patterns concern instances which trick players into spending more money

Read the complete text