Asymptotic methods for confined fluids

E. Di Bernardo, J. M. Brader · 2024

Read Asymptotic methods for confined fluids by E. Di Bernardo, J. M. Brader (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05027.txt.

Introduction

Emmanuel di Bernardo and Joseph Brader develop asymptotic methods for fluids held in tight confinement in this 2024 physics paper. When only a few particles fit, the right frame fixes the particle count, the canonical ensemble. Practical math, though, is far easier when the count can vary, the grand canonical frame, even if it adds fake effects. Their method converts results from the easy frame to the correct one.

They build the conversion with the method of asymptotics, writing it as a contour integral in a complex plane. That form exposes how Yang-Lee zeros shape the series and its convergence. From it they derive series for the partition function and for the density of a single particle. Tests use a one dimensional model of hard rods that can be solved exactly. The authors offer the method as a bridge between handy computation and correct small system physics.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Di Bernardo, J. M. Brader
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05027

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Asymptotic methods for confined fluids E. Di Bernardo, J. M. Brader Abstract The thermodynamics and microstructure of confined fluids with small particle number are best described using the canonical ensemble. However, practical calculations can usually only be performed in the grand-canonical ensemble, which can introduce unphysical artifacts. We employ the method of asymptotics to transform grand-canonical observables to the canonical ensemble, where the former can be conveniently obtained using the classical density functional theory of inhomogeneous fluids. By formulating the ensemble transformation as a contour integral in the complex fugacity plane we reveal the influence of the Yang-Lee zeros in determining the form and convergence properties of the asymptotic series. The theory is employed to develop expansions for the canonical partition function and the canonical one-body density. Numerical investigations are then performed using an exactly soluble one-dimensional model system of hard-rods. I Introduction Statistical mechanical studies of classical equilibrium fluids are typically performed using the grand-canonical ensemble, where the average particle number in the system is controlled by the chemical potential of a particle reservoir. While this presents several technical advantages for calculation, there exist many situations in which particle number fluctuations induce unphysical errors and a canonical treatment would be preferable. When can we expect differences between the grand-canonical and canonical ensembles to be relevant? The most obvious case is when the particle number is small, such that the system is far from the thermodynamic limit Hill 1962 ; Hill 2013 . Small systems are naturally associated with localization of the particles and thus a spatially inhomogeneous one-body density distribution. In the simplest case, small groups of particles can be localized by the application of a confining external potential field, for example hard-spheres in a cavity or harmonic confining potential González et al. 1997 ; González et al. 1998 . Alternatively, the localization may be a consequence of a mutual attraction between the particles, which binds them together in a finite size cluster Stradner et al. 2004 . If the bulk system exhibits an equilibrium phase transition, e.g. from a gas to a liquid, then the situation becomes more complicated and one has to consider more carefully how many particles constitute a ‘small number’. If the thermodynamic parameters are close to those of the bulk critical point, then even a confined fluid with many particles can exhibit finite-size effects due to the development of long-ranged correlations. Localized systems with small particle number have a microstructure and thermodynamics which differs significantly from those of an infinite bulk system; interfacial effects become dominant. The most commonly employed and well studied framework for determining the equilibrium properties of inhomogeneous classical fluids is the Density Functional Theory (DFT) Evans 1979 ; Evans 1992 . This approach has proved enormously useful in the study of inhomogeneous fluids but exhibits grand-canonical artifacts in situations for which the particles are strongly localized González et al. 1997 ; González et al. 1998 ; de las Heras and Schmidt 2014 ; Reinhardt and Brader 2012 . Although DFT has been formally recast in the canonical ensemble White et al. 2000 ; White and Velasco 2000 , the complexity of implementation has hindered its application to concrete problems. In the rare cases for which grand-canonical quantities are known exactly a matrix inversion scheme may be employed to obtain exact canonical information de las Heras and Schmidt 2014 . However, when the grand-canonical input is only approximately known, as is usually the case for models of interest, the method becomes unstable as errors in the grand-canonical input quantities become amplified. An alternative, albeit approximate, route to obtaining canonical quantities was investigated by Salaceuse et al. Salacuse et al. 1996 , who expanded the canonical structure factor as a power series in N^{-1} , aiming to account for leading-order finite-size effects in simulation data. This approach, which builds upon early work of Lebowitz and Percus Lebowitz and Percus 1961 , was subsequently extended to inhomogeneous systems by González et al. to approximate the canonical one-body density profile González et al. 1997 ; González et al. 1998 . A second-order truncation of their expansion was shown to yield very good results for the density profile of hard-spheres in a hard spherical cavity. The key to the success of these methods lies in the rapid convergence of the partial sums of the series, since calculation of the higher-order coefficients soon becomes computationally demanding. In this paper the transformation of observables from the grand-canonical to the canonical ensemble is formulated as a contour integral in the complex fugacity plane. From this starting point we use the method of steepest descents Dingle 1973 ; Olver 1974 ; Bender and Orszag 1978 to develop asymptotic expansions for both the canonical partition function and canonical one-body density profile, although extension to higher-order correlation functions would not pose any additional difficulties. Typical applications of steepest descents in the mathematical literature concern the approximate evaluation of intractable integrals for large values of a control parameter. Although the steps involved in constructing valid asymptotic series surely require much thought and subtlety, one at least knows the integrand as a closed-form analytic expression over the entire integration domain. When seeking to apply asymptotics to transform between ensembles we do not have this luxury. Grand-canonical observables can usually only be calculated (numerically) for positive real values of the fugacity, whereas the contour integral for transforming to the canonical ensemble demands grand-canonical input calculated over the full complex fugacity plane. This limited knowledge of the integrand hinders determination of the optimal steepest descents contour. Careful consideration and ingenuity are thus required to find a contour capable of generating correctly the leading-order terms in the series, with the hope that fast convergence makes calculation of higher-order terms unneccessary. Although the asymptotic method is approximate it can sometimes offer deeper insight into the essential elements of a physical problem than would be available from a complicated exact solution. In the present case we find that the asymptotic expansion of canonical quantities is intimately connected with the presence of singular points of the grand partition function in the complex fugacity plane: the famous Yang-Lee zeros. These nontrivial singularities play an important role in determining the optimal steepest-descents integration contour and therefore affect the convergence properties of the asymptotic series. Viewing the problem of ensemble transformation through the lens of asymptotics not only suggests new lines of attack but also sheds light on earlier studies in which the status of the approximations employed was not entirely clear. For example, asymptotics reveals the Yang-Lee related pitfalls which would surely be encountered when attempting to apply the expansion of González et al. to realistic model fluids exhibiting a phase transition. The approach developed here thus brings together in an intuitive way the fields of classical DFT, ensemble transformation and the Yang-Lee theory of phase transitions. II Density functional theory The primary method for obtaining grand-canonical information about confined or localized systems is the classical density functional theory (DFT). The central object in DFT is the grand potential functional Evans 1979 ; Evans 1992 \displaystyle\Omega[\rho]=\mathcal{F}[\rho]-\int\!d{\mathbf{r}}\big(\mu-V_{\text{ext}}({\mathbf{r}})\big)\rho({\mathbf{r}}), (1) where \mu is the chemical potential and V_{\text{ext}}({\mathbf{r}}) is the external potential. The Helmholtz free energy, \mathcal{F} , appearing on the right hand-side of

Read the complete text