Computational Advantage in Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks: Myth or Reality?

Muhammad Kashif 1 2 , Alberto Marchisio 1 2 · 2024

Read Computational Advantage in Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks: Myth or Reality? by Muhammad Kashif 1 2 , Alberto Marchisio 1 2 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04991.txt.

Introduction

Muhammad Kashif and co-authors ask whether adding quantum layers to neural networks buys real computing advantage or just hype. Their 2024 paper benchmarks classical networks on a multi-class task, tuning each to its best accuracy-per-cost point as a fair baseline. Hybrid quantum models, simulated on classical hardware as is standard today, then face the same growth in problem size.

As features rose from 10 to 110, the hybrids' computing cost grew 53 percent against 88 percent for classical models, despite simulation overhead. Their parameter count also grew more slowly. The authors read this as evidence that quantum layers scale more gently with problem complexity. They position hybrids as a promising route for hard tasks, while the field awaits real quantum hardware to cash the check.

Catalog record

CREATORMuhammad Kashif 1 2 , Alberto Marchisio 1 2
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04991

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Computational Advantage in Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks: Myth or Reality? Muhammad Kashif 1 2 , Alberto Marchisio 1 2 Abstract Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks (HQNNs), under the umbrella of Quantum Machine Learning (QML), have garnered significant attention due to their potential to enhance computational performance by integrating quantum layers within traditional neural network (NN) architectures. Despite numerous state-of-the-art applications, a fundamental question remains: Does the inclusion of quantum layers offer any computational advantage over purely classical models? If yes/no, how and why? In this paper, we analyze how classical and hybrid models adapt their architectural complexity in response to increasing problem complexity. To this end, we select a multiclass classification problem and perform comprehensive benchmarking of classical models for increasing problem complexity, identifying those that optimize both accuracy and computational efficiency to establish a robust baseline for comparison. These baseline models are then systematically compared with HQNNs by evaluating the rate of increase in floating-point operations (FLOPs) and number of parameters, providing insights into how architectural complexity scales with problem complexity in both classical and hybrid networks. We utilize classical machines to simulate the quantum layers in HQNNs, a common practice in Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. Our analysis reveals that, as problem complexity increases, the architectural complexity of HQNNs, and consequently their FLOPs consumption, despite the simulation overhead associated with quantum layer’s simulation on classical hardware, scales more efficiently ( 53.1 % 53.1\% increase in FLOPs from 10 10 features (low problem complexity) to 110 110 features (high problem complexity)), compared to classical networks ( 88.1 % 88.1\% ). Moreover, as the problem complexity increases, classical networks consistently exhibit a need for a larger number of parameters to accommodate the increasing problem complexity. Additionally, the rate of increase in number of parameters is also slower in HQNNs ( 81.4 % 81.4\% ) than classical NNs ( 88.5 % 88.5\% ). These findings suggest that HQNNs provide a more scalable and resource-efficient solution, positioning them as a promising alternative for tackling complex computational problems. , Muhammad Shafique 1 2 Emails: {muhammadkashif, alberto.marchisio, muhammad.shafique}@nyu.edu I Introduction Quantum Machine Learning (QML) is an emerging research area that integrates quantum computing with machine learning (ML) techniques, aiming to enhance computational power and efficiency in processing complex datasets [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) are a core component of QML, employing quantum circuits/layers to mimic the structure and function of classical neural networks (NNs) [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Hybrid Quantum Neural Networks (HQNNs) advance this concept by combining quantum and classical NN, leveraging the strengths of both quantum and classical computation [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . HQNNs are particularly advantageous in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era, where they can capitalize on quantum capabilities for specific sub-tasks while relying on classical resources to manage error-prone operations [ 11 , 12 ] . In a typical HQNN architecture, one or more hidden layers of a classical NN are replaced by a trainable quantum layer [ 13 , 14 ] , as shown in Fig. 1 . A growing body of state-of-the-art research employs HQNNs across a wide range of applications [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . Despite the notable computational speedups demonstrated by quantum computing in various domains [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] , no prior study has systematically investigated whether the integration of quantum components in NNs offers any advantages in learning performance or computational efficiency [ 28 ] . Additionally, demonstrating quantum advantage for QML is challenging due to several reasons, as critically discussed in [ 29 ] . Fig. 1 : Illustration of (a) classical NN, (b) HQNN with only quantum hidden layer and (c) HQNN with classical and quantum hidden layers. I-A Open Research Questions Comparing classical and quantum models is not straight-forward due to their fundamentally different computational paradigms. In the NISQ era, where quantum computers are limited by noise and scale, most research relies on simulating quantum algorithms using classical hardware 1 1 1 List of quantum simulators (Accessed 15-11-2024): https://www.quantiki.org/wiki/list-qc-simulators [ 28 ] , which is computationally intensive due to the exponential scaling of quantum states [ 30 ] . By examining the increase in architectural complexity (required to address growing problem complexity) and the corresponding increase in computational demands of QML models simulated on classical machines, potential quantum advantages over classical models can be evaluated. The argument is that, if QML models exhibit superior performance despite the overhead associated with simulating quantum circuits on classical hardware, this suggests that the observed superiority/advantage is likely inherent to the quantum nature of the algorithms and could become more significant with the deployment of universal fault-tolerant quantum computers. This approach provides valuable insights into the scalability and impact of quantum computing, offering a pragmatic pathway to evaluate its future role in solving complex problems beyond classical capabilities. To this end, recently, there have been some efforts on benchmarking QML algorithms, primarily focusing on analyzing which algorithms perform better in specific scenarios [ 28 , 31 ] . However, the question of whether incorporating the quantum component in NNs framework provides any advantage remains unexplored and is an open and important research problem. In this paper, we raise several key questions to investigate this gap: • Q1: What metrics will be appropriate to evaluate and compare the computational complexity of classical and hybrid networks? • Q2: Does the quantum part in HQNNs add anything qualitatively different or important? • Q3: If the quantum part gives any advantage in HQNNs, and can we demonstrate if it actually is computational advantage? I-B Our Contributions We attempt to answer the above questions through a rigorous empirical analysis. Our main contributions are: Fig. 2 : An overview of our contributions. • We propose a systematic methodology for comparing the computational complexity of hybrid and classical networks. For this purpose we generate a synthetic dataset in such a way that we can increase the complexity of the problem by increasing the number of features. Our novel investigation unleash how both classical and hybrid networks adapt to the complexity of the problem. ( Section III ) • We perform grid search to identify the classical models that meet a predefined accuracy threshold across varying levels of problem complexity to serve as benchmarks. We then identify the most efficient hybrid network architectures (models that achieve the predefined accuracy threshold) through a similar grid search process. ( Section III-B and III-C ) • A key finding from our analysis is that as the problem complexity increases, classical NNs require more sophisticated and resource-intensive architectures to reach a certain accuracy, resulting in higher FLOPs consumption . In contrast, HQNNs demonstrate superior scalability and efficiency . A well-designed hybrid architecture, particularly with a more expressive quantum layer , remains largely unaffected by the increasing complexity of the problem. An architecture that effectively solves a simpler problem can often be adapted, to solve a more complex problem. ( Section IV ) • Another important finding of our analysis is that classical models consistently require a greater number of parameters

Read the complete text