Follow the money: a startup-based measure of AI exposure across occupations, industries and regions

Enrico Maria Fenoaltea, Dario Mazzilli, Aurelio Patelli, Angelica Sbardella, Andrea Tacchella, Andrea Zaccaria, Marco Trombetti, Luciano Pietronero · 2024

Read Follow the money: a startup-based measure of AI exposure across occupations, industries and regions by Enrico Maria Fenoaltea, Dario Mazzilli, Aurelio Patelli, Angelica Sbardella, Andrea Tacchella, Andrea Zaccaria, Marco Trombetti, Luciano Pietronero (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04924.txt.

Introduction

Enrico Maria Fenoaltea and co-authors grade AI reach into jobs by trail of startup cash in a 2024 paper. Old grades score which jobs AI could do in theory. They say less on which jobs AI firms chase in fact. The team built an index from job task lists and the goods of startups in a famed fund program. That lens shows what the market builds, not just what labs can build.

High-skill jobs face wide swings in the new grade. Routine desk tasks, such as data work and office care, score high. High-stakes roles such as judges and surgeons score low, held back more by social bars than by tech bars. The authors say AI spread will be slow and shaped by want as much as by skill. The index gives policy teams a live gauge of that spread.

Catalog record

CREATOREnrico Maria Fenoaltea, Dario Mazzilli, Aurelio Patelli, Angelica Sbardella, Andrea Tacchella, Andrea Zaccaria, Marco Trombetti, Luciano Pietronero
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04924

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Follow the money: a startup-based measure of AI exposure across occupations, industries and regions Enrico Maria Fenoaltea, Dario Mazzilli, Aurelio Patelli, Angelica Sbardella, Andrea Tacchella, Andrea Zaccaria, Marco Trombetti, Luciano Pietronero Abstract The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into the workplace is advancing rapidly, necessitating robust metrics to evaluate its tangible impact on the labour market. Existing measures of AI occupational exposure largely focus on AI’s theoretical potential to substitute or complement human labour on the basis of technical feasibility, providing limited insight into actual adoption and offering inadequate guidance for policymakers. To address this gap, we introduce the AI Startup Exposure (AISE) index—a novel metric based on occupational descriptions from O*NET and AI applications developed by startups funded by the Y Combinator accelerator. Our findings indicate that while high-skilled professions are theoretically highly exposed according to conventional metrics, they are heterogeneously targeted by startups. Roles involving routine organizational tasks—such as data analysis and office management—display significant exposure, while occupations involving tasks that are less amenable to AI automation due to ethical or high-stakes, more than feasibility, considerations — such as judges or surgeons— present lower AISE scores. Moreover, geographically, AI exposure is concentrated in knowledge-intensive metropolitan areas like San Francisco and Seattle, while service-oriented sectors exhibit greater exposure compared to agriculture and construction. By focusing on venture-backed AI applications, our approach offers a nuanced perspective on how AI is reshaping the labour market. It challenges the conventional assumption that high-skilled jobs uniformly face high AI risks, highlighting instead the role of today’s AI players’ societal desirability-driven and market-oriented choices as critical determinants of AI exposure. Contrary to fears of widespread job displacement, our findings suggest that AI adoption will be gradual and shaped by social factors as much as by the technical feasibility of AI applications. This framework provides a dynamic, forward-looking tool for policymakers and stakeholders to monitor AI’s evolving impact and navigate the changing labour landscape. Introduction The public and scholarly debate on the employment effects of the new wave of AI developments, especially since the deployment of generative AI, is highly polarized and presents contrasting views on their potential risks and benefits. While some fear a jobless future ( Marken 2023 ) , others foresee job creation and complementarity between human and automated tasks, potentially leading to a productivity boost due to AI ( Georgieff & Hyee 2021 ) . Beyond the differing views, there is consensus among academics and policymakers that the current wave of artificial intelligence fundamentally differs from previous technological shifts ( Staneva & Elliott 2023 ) , distinguished by its unprecedented ability to mimic human reasoning and creativity across a wide range of applications. This unique capability to perform complex, non-routine tasks – exemplified by large language models like OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Anthropic’s Claude – coupled with its rapid pace of adoption and improvement ( Jung & Desikan 2024 ) positions AI as potentially one of the “most significant general-purpose technology of our era” ( Brynjolfsson & Mcafee 2017 ) , with far-reaching implications for the economy at large, and heterogeneous effects across jobs, sectors, and countries ( Acemoglu 2021 ; Georgieff & Hyee 2021 ) . As AI applications continue to emerge, extensive research has already focused on its impact on the labour market. There is growing evidence that AI is reshaping labour demand ( Acemoglu & Restrepo 2020a ; Acemoglu et al. 2022 ; Albanesi et al. 2023 ; Fleming 2019 ) , yet the overall employment effects remain unclear due to the large uncertainty on how these rapidly evolving technical developments will be adopted and deployed ( Acemoglu et al. 2022 ; Acemoglu 2021 ; Autor 2022 ) . Empirical findings vary widely, from low disruption ( Brynjolfsson & Mitchell 2017 ; Brynjolfsson et al. 2018 ; Gmyrek et al. 2023 ) to high displacement potential ( Eloundou et al. 2024 ) . Some studies show AI having complementary effects ( Gmyrek et al. 2023 ; Ellingrud et al. 2023 ) and driving productivity gains, particularly in high-skilled occupations ( Brynjolfsson 2023 ; Noy & Zhang 2023 ; Peng et al. 2023 ) , while others remain inconclusive about whether AI leads to complementarity or substitution ( Felten et al. 2019 ; Felten et al. 2021 ) . Concerns have emerged about AI adoption outpacing the labour market’s ability to adapt ( Brynjolfsson et al. 2018 ) , the quality of new jobs created ( Autor 2022 ; Green et al. 2023 ) , and AI uneven impact across sectors and regions ( Frank et al. 2019 ) . Acemoglu et al. 2023 and Autor et al. 2022 argue that AI’s emphasis on automation, rather than augmenting human tasks, risks further stagnating productivity, wages, and labour demand, while deepening income inequality. To mitigate these risks, they advocate for a human complementarity approach supported by an appropriate set of government policies ( Autor et al. 2022 ; Autor 2024 ; Acemoglu et al. 2023 ) . Additionally, the diminished worker voice due to AI powered monitoring and surveillance, the dominance of private actors in the AI race, and the absence of clear legislative frameworks have sparked broader concerns about AI societal impact ( Acemoglu 2021 ; Autor 2022 ; Staccioli et al. 2024 ) . While the debate on AI labour market and societal impact lacks consensus, the literature broadly agrees that, unlike previous ICT-based technological changes, AI exposure is highest among high-skilled, white-collar workers ( Eloundou et al. 2024 ; Felten et al. 2019 ; Webb 2019 ) . AI in fact primarily targets clerical work but affects both routine and non-routine cognitive tasks, whereas manual, operational, and technical tasks are comparatively less exposed. One of the primary methodological and conceptual challenges for understanding the impact of AI on labour markets is the empirical identification of occupational AI exposure. Building on the task framework pioneered by Autor et al. 2003 , several recent approaches estimate the average AI exposure of occupations based on the overlap between AI capabilities and occupational tasks or abilities ( Brynjolfsson et al. 2018 ; Eloundou et al. 2024 ; Frey & Osborne 2017 ; Felten et al. 2019 ; Felten et al. 2021 ; Felten et al. 2023 ; Martínez-Plumed et al. 2020 ; Tolan et al. 2021 ) . Among these, the AI Occupational Exposure (AIOE) index proposed by Felten et al. Felten et al. 2019 ; Felten et al. 2021 is becoming a standard in the literature and serves as a benchmark for our analysis – see the Methods section for more details on its construction. More recently, AI-assisted approaches have emerged, using Large Language Models (LLMs) to assess occupational exposure, as demonstrated by Gmyrek et al. 2023 , who estimate task-level scores of occupational exposure to AI using ChatGPT-4, and Eloundou et al. 2024 , who combine expert opinions with ChatGPT-4 classifications to quantify the impact of Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPTs) on the US labour market. Finally, Webb 2020 ; Meindl et al. 2021 ; Sousa & Sytsma 2023 have proposed patent-based methods, employing NLP techniques to analyze AI patent texts’ similarity directly to occupational descriptions. In these works, AI exposure is generally determined by three main steps: (i) selection of

Read the complete text