Predicting the Curie temperature in substitutionally disordered alloys using a first-principles based model

Marian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling · 2024

Read Predicting the Curie temperature in substitutionally disordered alloys using a first-principles based model by Marian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04920.txt.

Introduction

The temperature where an alloy stops being magnetic can be predicted from first principles. That holds even when its atoms are shuffled at random, show Marian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, and Björn Alling in a 2024 arXiv paper. Their model compares the energy of the ordered magnetic state with the disordered hot one. It then adds the entropy of the mess.

It held up across iron alloys, Heusler compounds, a nitride, and a cobalt alloy, with little hand tuning. The authors also ran it on an iron technetium mix nobody has made, as a guide for experimenters. The point is a tool that travels across chemistries.

Catalog record

CREATORMarian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04920

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Predicting the Curie temperature in substitutionally disordered alloys using a first-principles based model Marian Arale Brännvall, Rickard Armiento, Björn Alling Abstract When exploring new magnetic materials, the effect of alloying plays a crucial role for numerous properties. By altering the alloy composition, it is possible to tailor, e.g., the Curie temperature ( T C T_{\text{C}} ). In this work, T C T_{\text{C}} of various alloys is investigated using a previously developed technique [ Brännvall et al. Phys. Rev. Mat. (2024) ] designed for robust predictions of T C T_{\text{C}} across diverse chemistries and structures. The technique is based on density functional theory calculations and utilizes the energy difference between the magnetic ground state and the magnetically disordered paramagnetic state. It also accounts for the magnetic entropy in the paramagnetic state and the number of nearest magnetic neighbors. The experimentally known systems, Fe 1-x Co x , Fe 1-x Cr x , Fe 1-x V x , NiMnSb-based Heusler alloys, Ti 1-x Cr x N, and Co 1-x Al x are investigated. The experimentally unexplored system Fe 1-x Tc x is also tested to demonstrate the usefulness of the developed method in guiding future experimental efforts. This work demonstrates the broad applicability of the developed method across various systems, requiring less hands-on adjustments compared to other theoretical approaches. Preprint: AIP/123-QED I Introduction Materials with a spontaneous macroscopic magnetization lose it at the Curie temperature ( T_{\text{C}} ) due to a transition from a ferro- or ferrimagnetically ordered state to a disordered paramagnetic state. In the search for technologically applicable magnets, knowledge of this temperature is crucial. For magnetic alloys, the effect of different compositions is of high interest as it enables tailoring T_{\text{C}} of a magnetic material. Conducting reliable predictions of T_{\text{C}} in general and with respect to the composition of an alloy in particular, is therefore of great importance. In alloy systems, changes in composition can modify both the number and strength of magnetic exchange interactions, and the magnetic ordering itself. For example, increasing the concentration of a nonmagnetic element reduces the number of magnetic neighbors, weakening the overall magnetic coupling and lowering T_{\text{C}} . Conversely, alloying with elements that possess strong magnetic moments—such as transition metals with partially filled d or f orbitals—can enhance the magnetic interactions within an alloy. These elements contribute to stronger exchange interactions, which stabilize magnetic order at higher temperatures, resulting in an increased Curie temperature [ 1 ] . The Curie temperature can be measured by means of experiments and derived using theoretical calculations. The experimental approach quickly becomes too time-consuming and costly to apply when exploring a wide range of new magnetic materials. In theoretical calculations, one may, for example, construct a Heisenberg Hamiltonian and derive the exchange interactions between magnetic moments using the method developed by Liechtenstein et al. [ 2 ] , subsequently determining T_{\text{C}} using Monte Carlo simulations or a mean-field approximation [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . This method is, however, often impractical for large-scale investigations of systems with different structures and chemistries, as it requires extensive human manual input. Hence, studies employing this method often focus on only one or a few similar systems [ 7 , 8 , 3 , 9 , 5 , 6 , 10 ] . To accelerate theoretical predictions of the Curie temperature, machine learning (ML) methods have been introduced in multiple studies [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . This approach is highly compatible with a high-throughput search of magnetic materials. However, attempts at developing general ML models for predicting the Curie temperature have faced challenges in capturing a consistently physical and continuous variation of T_{\text{C}} as a function of composition [ 11 , 12 ] . As mentioned previously, when the composition of an alloy changes, so does the number and type of nearest magnetic neighbors, leading to variations in exchange interactions and the stability of the magnetic ground state. Understanding and incorporating the effects of these factors is crucial for predicting how alloying will influence the magnetic properties of materials. To tackle these systems it therefore appears particularly important to employ physics-based predictive models. In a previous work [ 20 ] , we created a physics-based model, utilizing output from density functional theory (DFT) calculations, and found it to greatly improve the predictions of the substitutionally disordered alloy Fe 1-x Co x compared to ML models. The model uses the energy difference between the paramagnetic state and the magnetic ground state, the magnetic entropy, and the number of nearest magnetic neighbors. The paramagnetic state is simulated using a supercell implementation of the disordered local moments (DLM) method [ 21 , 22 ] , and the magnetic ground state is determined by a ground-state search method introduced in the work by Ehn et al. [ 23 ] . Details of the DLM simulations and ground-state search are described in Sec. II.3 . In the current work, we explore the applicability of this model further by applying it to estimate T_{\text{C}} of the disordered alloys Fe 1-x Co x , Fe 1-x Cr x , Fe 1-x V x , Ni x Cu 1-x MnSb, Ni x MnSb, Ti 1-x Cr x N, and Co 1-x Al x . The results are compared to the experimental T_{\text{C}} . Additionally, the model is applied to Fe 1-x Tc x to assess its predictive accuracy in a system where experimental data is scarce due to the radioactive nature of technetium. This allows for theoretical insights that may be useful to guide future experimental validation efforts. We also address and analyze some limitations of our model, discussing their underlying causes. This current investigation shows that the method from Ref. [ 20 ] can be applied across a wide range of systems, unlike other theoretical methods that often require hands-on adjustments for each specific case. Overall, it offers a reliable approach for predicting and tailoring the Curie temperature by adjusting the alloy composition. II Method II.1 Model Description In Ref. [ 20 ] , four models were developed to predict the Curie temperature of magnetic materials based on output from DFT calculations. The most elaborate model has the form, T_{\text{C}}=A\frac{\Delta E}{S^{\text{mag}}}\Bigg(1-\frac{B}{NN^{C}}\Bigg)+D\>\text{K}, (1) where the parameters A , B , C , and D are fitted to the 32 known ferro- and ferrimagnetic materials presented in Ref. [ 20 ] giving A=0.85 . B=0.69 , C=0.14 , and D=124 ; \Delta E=E_{\text{DLM}}-E_{\text{GS}} is the energy difference between the DLM state and the magnetic ground state found after the ground-state search (described more in Section II.3 ); NN is the number of nearest magnetic neighbors of the magnetic atoms, defined as atoms with magnetic moments larger than 0.75 \mu_{B} in the magnetic ground state; S^{\text{mag}} is the magnetic entropy of the DLM state given as, S^{\text{mag}}=k_{\text{B}}\Bigg[\sum_{i=1}^{N_{\text{mag}}}\ln{(m_i + 1)}\Bigg]/N_{\text{mag}}, (2) where k_{\text{B}} is the Boltzmann constant, N_{\text{mag}} is the number of magnetic atoms with constrained magnetic moments, and m_{i} is the magnetic moment magnitude of the i th constrained magnetic moment. None of the alloys investigated in the present work are included among the 32 systems used to obtain the fitting parameters

Read the complete text