Classical-quantum scattering
Daniel Carney, Akira Matsumura · 2024
Read Classical-quantum scattering by Daniel Carney, Akira Matsumura (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04839.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Carney and Akira Matsumura analyzed a mixed classical-quantum theory in a 2024 physics paper. The frame couples quantum fields to classical, random fields, and it has been floated as a model of quantum matter under classical gravity. Whether such a hybrid can even give sound scattering odds was in doubt.
The pair show that scattering odds can be defined and computed in a way that respects relativity and keeps total probability whole, at least at the first level of detail. Their test case passes quantum matter through a classical Yukawa field. In the slow limit the setup maps to gravity, and the plainest such theory makes definite forecasts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Carney, Akira Matsumura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 99 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04839
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Classical-quantum scattering Daniel Carney, Akira Matsumura Abstract We analyze the framework recently proposed by Oppenheim et al. to model relativistic quantum fields coupled to relativistic, classical, stochastic fields (in particular, as a model of quantum matter coupled to “classical gravity”). Perhaps surprisingly, we find that we can define and calculate scattering probabilities which are Lorentz-covariant and conserve total probability, at least at tree level. As a concrete example, we analyze 2 → 2 2\to 2 scattering of quantum matter mediated by a classical Yukawa field. Mapping this to a gravitational coupling in the non-relativistic limit, and assuming that we can treat large objects as point masses, we find that the simplest possible “classical-quantum” gravity theory constructed this way gives predictions for 2 → 2 2\to 2 gravitational scattering which are inconsistent with simple observations of, e.g., spacecraft undergoing slingshot maneuvers. We comment on lessons learned for attempts to couple quantum matter to “non-quantum” gravity, or more generally, for attempts to couple relativistic quantum and classical systems. I Introduction and motivation When the curvature of spacetime is small compared to the Planck scale R/M_{\rm pl}^{2}\ll 1 , gravity can be quantized perturbatively as an effective quantum field theory, with action S=M_{\rm pl}^{2}\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\left(R+\mathcal{L}_{\rm matter}+\frac{c_{1}}{M_{\rm pl}^{2}}R^{2}+\frac{c_{2}}{M_{\rm pl}^{2}}R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}+\cdots\right) (1) where the dots represent an infinite series in powers of curvature in Planck units [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . The theory is non-renormalizable: when R/M_{\rm pl}^{2}\gtrsim 1 , this infinite series of terms becomes dominant over the Einstein-Hilbert term R . Because the coefficients c_{i} are unknown, the theory is non-predictive in this regime. However, in a laboratory experiment involving solid objects, R/M_{\rm pl}^{2}\approx 10^{-91} , so only the Einstein-Hilbert term contributes meaningfully. Thus, this effective quantum field theory treatment of the weak gravitational field is extremely well-defined in settings other than near a singularity, such as the deep interior of a black hole or the very early universe. While quantizing gravity this way is theoretically self-consistent at ordinary scales, it is interesting to consider the possibility that gravity is not actually quantized this way in nature. Investigating this notion is particularly motivated by the possibility of experimental tests that could distinguish standard quantized gravity from alternative models [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Recently, a number of models in which the gravitational field is “classical” have been constructed to make this suggestion more concrete [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Generally, these models have been in the non-relativistic regime, and “classical” means that the Newtonian interaction cannot generate entanglement between two massive systems. This would be in stark contrast to standard quantized gravity as in Eq. ( 1 ), which definitely predicts entanglement generation through virtual graviton exchange, or equivalently, through the Newtonian two-body operator obtained when integrating out the gravitons in the low-velocity limit [ 21 ] . Very recently, Oppenheim and collaborators have suggested an interesting relativistic generalization of these “classical” gravity models [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 ] . They refer to their general setting as “classical-quantum” (CQ) gravity and we will follow this terminology. In their CQ model, the gravitational field is a bone fide classical field. It undergoes stochastic time evolution and is coupled to quantum matter in a way made precise below. It is very interesting to determine if this kind of CQ framework is mathematically self-consistent, and if it can be used to formulate a physically viable model of gravity. Our purpose in this paper is to make some steps towards answering these questions. The general CQ framework is independent of gravity and we choose to specialize to the simpler case of a Yukawa model, where a classical Yukawa field \phi couples to some quantized matter, which avoids any complications coming from gauge symmetry. On the other hand, for non-relativistic questions, a Yukawa interaction in the massless limit generates a 1/r potential, so it can be used to analyze the Newtonian limit of gravity by identifying the coupling constants appropriately. As a straightforward observable, we attempt to formulate scattering theory for quantum matter coupled through this CQ Yukawa interaction. This proves to be instructive in many ways. For one thing, it raises some basic concerns about the purely diffusive evolution law assumed for the classical field [ 23 , 25 ] , which makes it hard to even formulate the scattering problem because the theory does not have a stable ground state. 1 1 1 Penington [ 27 ] has estimated that, in the context of gravity, the stochastic generation of gravitational waves from this diffusive evolution is quantitatively inconsistent with non-observation of a stochastic gravitational wave background in LIGO [ 28 ] . Nevertheless, allowing for some choices and approximations which we make clear, we formulate the 2\to 2 scattering problem for two massive bodies. The CQ framework has two free functions, called D_{0} and D_{2} , and we analyze only the simplest case where these are assumed to be constants. We find that noise effects in the resulting CQ model produce large deviations in the scattering distributions of even non-relativistic particles. Once the gravitational parameters are inserted, the CQ model predicts effects which are in direct conflict with observations. We discuss the generality of this conclusion in Sec. V . Beyond the specifics of these gravity models, it is of substantial interest to understand if classical systems can be coupled to quantum ones in some way compatible with special relativity, let alone general relativity [ 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] . One might hope that the quantitative difficulties found here come more from specific choices in the construction rather than the overall idea of a relativistic framework for coupling classical systems to quantum ones. Conversely, this construction appears perhaps more robust than one might have anticipated. For example, it appears capable of producing Lorentz-covariant scattering probabilities, at least at leading order in a perturbative expansion. We end with a few comments on this, with the goal of deriving some general lessons for possible relativistic classical-quantum evolution laws. II Classical-quantum framework To motivate the general idea of coupling quantum systems to classical ones, and to highlight some of the features that arise in the model of Oppenheim et al. , consider a quantum computer operating under quantum error correction. This fundamentally consists of quantum systems (qubits) which are periodically being measured (to determine the error syndromes). These measurements are done by a classical apparatus: some readout system which ultimately takes qubit states and records measurement outcomes as classical data. This classical data is then used to determine the appropriate feedback unitary that needs to be applied to the qubits. This feedback unitary is also implemented by an effectively classical system, like a control laser or microwave drive. Thus, the qubits and classical control system together constitute a dynamically coupled quantum-classical system. This picture has already been used to construct models of non-relativistic matter coupled through “semi-classical” gravitational interactions [ 16 ] . See. Fig. 1 . These models have the property that they induce noise on the quantum