Learning Fair Decisions with Factor Models: Applications to Annuity Pricing
Fei Huang, Junhao Shen, Yanrong Yang, Ran Zhao · 2024
Read Learning Fair Decisions with Factor Models: Applications to Annuity Pricing by Fei Huang, Junhao Shen, Yanrong Yang, Ran Zhao (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04663.txt.
Introduction
Fei Huang, Junhao Shen, Yanrong Yang, and Ran Zhao build fairness into the factor models used to price annuities. Fairness-aware learning matters most in high-stakes choices like insurance underwriting. There, biased outputs carry grave costs in money and in social terms. Factor models are standard for risk gauges and pricing. But their forecasts can bring in or swell bias against protected groups.
Their Fair Decision Model adds fairness rules aimed at a test they call decision error parity. That means error rates that are balanced across groups. They use the frame to price annuities based on mortality modeling. In a study of Australian mortality data, the model cut the gap in decision errors a lot next to base models. It also lifted forecast accuracy at the same time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fei Huang, Junhao Shen, Yanrong Yang, Ran Zhao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04663
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Learning Fair Decisions with Factor Models: Applications to Annuity Pricing Fei Huang, Junhao Shen, Yanrong Yang, Ran Zhao Abstract Fairness-aware statistical learning is essential for mitigating discrimination against protected attributes such as gender, race, and ethnicity in data-driven decision-making. This is particularly critical in high-stakes applications like insurance underwriting and annuity pricing, where biased business decisions can have significant financial and social consequences. Factor models are commonly used in these domains for risk assessment and pricing; however, their predictive outputs may inadvertently introduce or amplify bias. To address this, we propose a Fair Decision Model that incorporates fairness regularization to mitigate outcome disparities. Specifically, the model is designed to ensure that expected decision errors are balanced across demographic groups—a criterion we refer to as Decision Error Parity. We apply this framework to annuity pricing based on mortality modeling. An empirical analysis using Australian mortality data demonstrates that the Fair Decision Model can significantly reduce decision error disparity while also improving predictive accuracy compared to benchmark models, including both traditional and fair factor models. Keywords : Factor Model; Fair Decisions; Insurance Pricing; Mortality Forecasting 1 Introduction The widespread adoption of data-driven decision-making has brought increased scrutiny to fairness in algorithmic models, particularly in high-stakes applications such as credit scoring, criminal justice, hiring, and insurance pricing. In these domains, biased models can entrench or exacerbate existing disparities, making fairness a central concern in machine learning and statistics ( Barocas et al., 2023 ; Mehrabi et al., 2021 ; Mitchell et al., 2021 ; Frees & Huang, 2023 ; Charpentier, 2024 ) . Mortality forecasting plays a foundational role in actuarial science, demography, and social policy, and it is central to the pricing of life-contingent financial products such as annuities. A wide range of models has been proposed to capture age-specific and temporal trends. These include the benchmark Lee–Carter model ( Lee & Carter, 1992 ) , Renshaw–Haberman (RH) model ( Renshaw & Haberman, 2006 ) , the Cairns–Blake–Dowd (CBD) model for older ages ( Cairns et al., 2006 ) , age-period-cohort (APC) models ( Currie et al., 2004 ) , functional data models ( Hyndman & Ullah, 2007 ) , and extensions like the Plat model ( Plat, 2009 ) that are popular in pension risk modeling. Although there is a growing body of literature on fairness and discrimination in insurance –particularly in general insurance contexts ( Xin & Huang, 2024 ; Lindholm et al., 2022 ; Côté et al., 2024 ; Araiza Iturria et al., 2024 ) –relatively limited attention has been paid to fairness in life-contingent applications, such as mortality forecasting and annuity pricing. This gap is especially significant given the long-term financial implications of such products. In many jurisdictions, gender—a legally protected attribute—is explicitly and legitimately used in mortality models and the pricing of life-contingent insurance products due to its strong predictive signal for longevity. While most of the fairness literature assumes that protected attributes are not allowed as a rating factor (direct discrimination is not allowed), insurance practice often permits or even requires their inclusion for some lines of business. For example, gender is a commonly used rating factor for insurance in many jurisdictions. This raises a critical yet underexplored question: how can we ensure fairness in decision-making when protected attributes are used explicitly as rating factors (direct discrimination is allowed)? Standard fairness frameworks are not directly applicable in such settings, as they usually focus on how to mitigate indirect discrimination when direct discrimination is prohibited, for example, see Lindholm et al. (2022) ; Xin & Huang (2024) . An innovative contribution of this paper is to address this gap by developing fairness-aware factor models that account for protected attributes when it is allowed to be used as a rating factor in a regression problem. We demonstrate through an annuity pricing example that even when gender is a legitimate rating factor in decision-making and modeling, significant disparities in the accuracy of prediction and decision outcomes can persist, and our proposed methodology is designed to detect and correct these imbalances. Factor models are a classical and powerful framework for uncovering latent structures in high-dimensional data. They capture systematic variation using a small number of latent components and are widely used in domains such as asset pricing, macroeconomic forecasting, and mortality modeling. In the context of mortality forecasting, factor models—such as the Lee-Carter model ( Lee & Carter, 1992 ) and its variants—have been extensively applied to analyze long-term demographic trends across countries. The Lee-Carter model, in particular, remains a benchmark in mortality forecasting and is used by the U.S. Bureau of the Census for long-run life expectancy projections ( Hollmann et al., 1999 ) . Beyond the United States, it has been successfully applied in many countries including those in the G7 ( Tuljapurkar et al., 2000 ) as well as Sweden and Australia ( Lundström & Qvist, 2004 ; Booth et al., 2001 ; Booth et al., 2002 ; Booth & Tickle, 2003 ; Booth et al., 2004 ) . However, standard factor models are agnostic to fairness considerations. When applied to data containing distinct demographic groups—such as males and females—they may yield imbalanced reconstruction or prediction errors across groups, due to differences in how well the model captures gender-specific mortality patterns. For example, even when group sizes are equal, the average prediction error for one gender may be substantially higher, which can propagate into downstream decisions such as annuity pricing. These disparities are often invisible in aggregate model performance metrics, yet they raise important concerns in fairness-aware modeling. Group fairness in machine learning is commonly defined using statistical criteria such as independence (also known as demographic parity), separation (equalized odds), and sufficiency (well-calibration) ( Barocas et al., 2023 ; Hardt et al., 2016 ; Dwork et al., 2012 ; Mehrabi et al., 2021 ) . These principles have inspired a wide array of algorithmic interventions—spanning pre-processing, in-processing, and post-processing approaches—to mitigate bias in supervised learning ( Zemel et al., 2013 ; Agarwal et al., 2018 ) . A number of algorithmic techniques have been proposed to introduce fairness constraints into model estimation. For example, methods based on constrained optimization, Pareto optimality, and gradient-based learning have been applied to problems such as subspace learning and dimensionality reduction ( Samadi et al., 2018 ; Morgenstern et al., 2019 ; Olfat & Aswani, 2019 ; Kamani et al., 2022 ; Vu et al., 2022 ; Babu & Stoica, 2023 ; Zalcberg & Wiesel, 2021 ; Kleindessner et al., 2023 ) . These approaches often aim to minimize disparities in model loss across demographic groups, even at the cost of slightly higher overall error. While promising, many existing fairness-aware methods operate in the predictive machine learning setting without direct links to decision-making applications. In contrast, our work is grounded in the concrete context of insurance pricing, where fairness must be considered not only at the model level but also in the downstream economic decisions informed by model outputs (e.g., annuity pricing). While the fairness notions considered in this paper can be viewed as adaptations of the independence (or demographic parity) criterion to a regression setting, our approach departs from the conventional literature that typically applies this criterion to price outcomes—an approach