Tuning towards the edge of a dark abyss: Implications of a tuning paradigm on the hierarchy between the weak and dark matter scales

Christopher D. Carone, Noah L. Donald · 2024

Read Tuning towards the edge of a dark abyss: Implications of a tuning paradigm on the hierarchy between the weak and dark matter scales by Christopher D. Carone, Noah L. Donald (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04609.txt.

Introduction

Christopher Carone and Noah Donald explore whether a tuning trick can explain why the weak force scale sits so far above a dark sector scale, in this 2024 arXiv paper. A recent idea holds that pushing a theory's settings to the edge of where its energy stays positive can create huge gaps between scales. The authors ask whether the same trick can grow the familiar weak scale out of a much lighter hidden sector.

They build a model that does exactly that, as a proof of principle. The same dark sector also holds a workable dark matter candidate, tying two puzzles together. The paper is theoretical, offering a route that other model builders can test and extend.

Catalog record

CREATORChristopher D. Carone, Noah L. Donald
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04609

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tuning towards the edge of a dark abyss: Implications of a tuning paradigm on the hierarchy between the weak and dark matter scales Christopher D. Carone, Noah L. Donald Abstract It has recently been suggested that tuning towards the boundary of the positivity domain of the scalar potential may explain the separation between the electroweak scale and the unification scale in a grand unified theory. Here we explore the possibility that the same type of tuning might account for the generation of the electroweak scale from a much lighter dynamically generated scale in a dark sector. We present a model that realizes this idea and provides a proof of principle that the same dark sector can include a viable dark matter candidate. I Introduction Over the past 30 years, there have been a vast number of proposals for physics beyond the standard model (BSM) that have been motivated by naturalness. Quantum corrections to the Higgs boson squared mass are quadratically divergent; the bare mass in the Lagrangian must be tuned if the electroweak scale is to remain far below the Planck scale or any other high physical scale that may exist in nature. The minimal supersymmetric standard model and its many variations are the best known class of theories that address this problem Martin:1997ns . Little Higgs models Perelstein:2005ka and various higher-derivative extensions of the standard model Grinstein:2007mp ; Carone:2008iw have also been put forward with the same goal in mind. At present, there is no experimental evidence in favor of any BSM model with new particles or interactions designed to cancel the quadratic divergences of the standard model PDGNavas . While the scale at which such cancelations occur can be raised beyond the increasingly stringent lower bounds from collider experiments, the potential link between this scale and the scale of electroweak symmetry breaking is gradually lost. For this reason, the non-observation of BSM physics at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) makes models of this type less compelling and motivates the consideration of alternative scenarios. One possibility is that the tuning of Lagrangian parameters is something that simply occurs in nature. Rather than focusing on eliminating the tuning, it may be productive as a first step to consider what kinds of tunings may be favored or characterized by simple principles. This may ultimately help with understanding the origin of the tuning, whether it is related to dynamics, anthropic selection or some other mechanism. A recent proposal regarding tuning “to the edge of the abyss” Georgi:2024rxw is motivated in this way and is the topic of further study in the present work. The edge of the abyss in Ref. Georgi:2024rxw refers to the boundary of the positivity domain of the potential, that is, the parameter values for which the potential is on the verge of turning over and becoming unbounded from below. Near this boundary, there are directions in which the potential is nearly flat. Introduction of a cubic term with a dimensionful coupling defined by a scale, say M_{0} , can tilt the potential leading to a vacuum expectation value (vev) v that is much larger than M_{0} : v\gg M_{0} . The generation of a large energy scale from a small one goes against the usual assumptions of effective field theory; Ref. Georgi:2024rxw showed that this separation is consistently maintained when loop corrections are included in the potential, and suggested that the hierarchy between the electroweak scale and the scale of grand unification might arise by such a tuning. Other approaches to the naturalness problem that challenge the expectations of effective field theory have appeared in the literature previously. For example, Froggatt and Nielsen have argued that the top quark and Higgs masses may be understood from the principle that there are exactly degenerate vacua at the weak and Planck scales, a critical point where there can be a coexistence of phases Froggatt:1995rt . More recently, there have been proposals that explain the smallness of the Higgs boson mass via self-organized criticality criticality , a dynamical mechanism that drives a system towards a critical point Bak:1987xua , in this case the vanishing value of the Higgs boson mass, which separates the phases of broken and unbroken electroweak symmetry. While these proposals on near-criticality and the abyss scenario involve special points where the vacuum is on the verge of becoming unstable, the abyss scenario also involves an instability that does not correspond to a phase boundary, namely the point where the classical potential becomes unbounded from below; the symmetry breaking phases are controlled by an independent model parameter. The well-known metastability of the Higgs potential in the standard model Isidori:2001bm might give some motivation for considering beyond-the-standard-model scenarios that live relatively close to instability. Whether the assumed form of the potential in the abyss scenario can be understood via some dynamical mechanism is an interesting question; here we focus instead on a new phenomenological application. The abyss scenario of Ref. Georgi:2024rxw explored how the electroweak scale may be related to a much higher energy scale, while here we consider the possibility that a similar tuning may relate the electroweak scale to a dark sector that is characterized by a much lower energy scale. Instead of a cubic term to tilt the potential, strong dynamics in the dark sector generates a linear term in the scalar potential (which, of course, could be subsequently shifted away to generate cubic terms). Tuning to the edge of the positivity domain of this potential (a boundary that we refer to as the edge of the “dark abyss”) separates the dark and the electroweak scales, where the latter is triggered by scalar mixing. This construction leads to a scenario that is significantly constrained once the Higgs vev and mass are fixed ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk , and a mixing angle in the scalar sector is restricted to be below its experimental bound Claude:2021sye . Our paper is organized as follows. In the next section, we define our model and the tuning that leads to separation of the dark and electroweak energy scales. In Sec. III we discuss the phenomenology of the dark sector and show, for the purposes of illustration, how a viable dark matter candidate can be obtained. We also point out other similar dark sectors to which the present approach might be applied. In Sec. IV , we summarize our conclusions. II The Model We work with a model of dynamical dark chiral symmetry breaking proposed by one of the authors and Ramos in Ref. Carone:2015jra . The gauge group of the model is G_{\rm SM}\times SU(N) {}_{D}\times SU(2) D where G_{\rm SM} is the gauge group of the standard model, and SU(N) D is an unbroken “dark color” group that becomes strongly coupled in the infrared. The dark sector matter includes a left-handed doublet and two right-handed singlets under the SU(2) D gauge group. \Upsilon_{L}=\left(\begin{array}[]{c}p_{L}\\ m_{L}\end{array}\right)\,,\,\,\,\,\,p_{R}\,,\,\,\,\,\,m_{R}\,\,\,, (1) which transform in the fundamental representation of the dark color group. Given this fermion content, we take N to be even so that the theory is free of the SU(2) Witten anomaly Witten:1982fp . The dark sector also includes an SU(2) D doublet field \phi that spontaneously breaks the SU(2) D gauge group. We call the fields p and

Read the complete text