Power spectrum of magnetic relaxation in spin ice: anomalous diffusion in a Coulomb fluid
David Billington, Edward Riordan, Clara Cafolla-Ward, Jordan Wilson, Elsa Lhotel, Carley Paulsen, Dharmalingham Prabhakaran, Steven T. Bramwell, Felix Flicker, Sean R. Giblin · 2024
Read Power spectrum of magnetic relaxation in spin ice: anomalous diffusion in a Coulomb fluid by David Billington, Edward Riordan, Clara Cafolla-Ward, Jordan Wilson, Elsa Lhotel, Carley Paulsen, Dharmalingham Prabhakaran, Steven T. Bramwell, Felix Flicker, Sean R. Giblin (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04376.txt.
Introduction
David Billington and co-authors measure magnetic noise in a material called spin ice in a 2024 paper. In spin ice, magnetic moments can act like free magnetic charges, called monopoles, that wander through the crystal. Past noise studies found a pink noise pattern and odd motion at low temperatures, but results at higher temperatures clashed.
The team used a magnetic response method that reaches far higher frequencies than past noise work. They measured the key exponent between two and twenty degrees above absolute zero. Their values show real departures from plain random motion up to about twenty degrees, larger than past noise studies found. Results varied by sample, which points to a role for crystal defects. The work refines the picture of monopole motion in a dense, strongly linked fluid.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David Billington, Edward Riordan, Clara Cafolla-Ward, Jordan Wilson, Elsa Lhotel, Carley Paulsen, Dharmalingham Prabhakaran, Steven T. Bramwell, Felix Flicker, Sean R. Giblin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04376
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Power spectrum of magnetic relaxation in spin ice: anomalous diffusion in a Coulomb fluid David Billington, Edward Riordan, Clara Cafolla-Ward, Jordan Wilson, Elsa Lhotel, Carley Paulsen, Dharmalingham Prabhakaran, Steven T. Bramwell, Felix Flicker, Sean R. Giblin Abstract Magnetization noise measurements on the spin ice Dy 2 Ti 2 O 7 have revealed a remarkable ‘pink noise’ power spectrum S ( f , T ) S(f,T) below 4 K, including evidence of magnetic monopole excitations diffusing in a fractal landscape. However, at higher temperatures, the reported values of the anomalous exponent b ( T ) b(T) describing the high frequency tail of S ( f , T ) S(f,T) are not easy to reconcile with other results in the literature, which generally suggest significantly smaller deviations from the Brownian motion value of b = 2 b=2 , that become negligible above T = 20 T=20 K. We accurately estimate b ( T ) b(T) at temperatures between 2 K and 20 K, using a.c. susceptibility measurements that, crucially, stretch up to the relatively high frequency of f = 10 6 f=10^{6} Hz. We show that previous noise measurements underestimate b ( T ) b(T) and we suggest reasons for this. Our results establish deviations in b ( T ) b(T) from b = 2 b=2 up to about 20 K. However studies on different samples confirms that b ( T ) b(T) is sample dependent: the details of this dependence agree in part, though not completely, with previous studies of the effect of crystal defects on monopole population and diffusion. Our results establish the form of b ( T ) b(T) which characterises the subtle, and evolving, nature of monopole diffusion in the dense Coulomb fluid, a highly correlated state, where several dynamical processes combine. They do not rule out the importance of a fractal landscape picture emerging at lower temperatures where the monopole gas is dilute. The spin ice material Dy 2 Ti 2 O 7 has long been of principal interest among highly frustrated magnets. Large crystal field splittings combine with the large ( 10\,\mu_{B} ) fields of the magnetic Dy 3+ ions to create an excellent approximation to classical Ising spins. These occupy a pyrochlore lattice of corner-sharing tetrahedra, whose triangular faces lead to geometrical frustration in which the spins cannot simultaneously minimise their energies. Polarised neutron scattering at T<1 K reveals spin correlations characteristic of ‘ice rule’ states in which two spins point in, and two out, of each tetrahedron in agreement with a residual entropy measured by specific heat Bramwell and Harris 2020 . Part of the excitement about spin ices is that the minimal excitations would take the form of mobile, localised sources and sinks of magnetization, resembling classical analogues of magnetic monopoles Castelnovo et al. 2008 ; Ryzhkin 2005 . Spin ice may be pictured as a dilute Coulomb gas of magnetic monopoles below \sim 1 K and an increasingly dense Coulomb fluid of both single and double charge magnetic monopoles above that temperature Kaiser et al. 2018 . A new tool to probe monopole dynamics came from theoretical proposals to use magnetic noise spectroscopy Jaubert and Holdsworth 2011 ; Kirschner et al. 2018 , which passively probes the magnetic field fluctuations outside the sample. This technique allows a direct measurement of the noise spectral density S(f,T) . It has previously been applied to spin glasses, for example Hérisson and Ocio 2002 . The function S(f,T) can alternatively be inferred from response measurements like a.c. susceptibility or neutron scattering, by means of the fluctuation dissipation theorem Kubo 1966 . Methodology based on the response function is the standard approach, but it can be valuable to compare the two different measurements of S(f,T) in cases of slow and complex dynamics, as afforded by spin glasses Hérisson and Ocio 2002 and spin ice Snyder et al. 2004 ; Matsuhira et al. 2011 ; Dasini et al. 2004 , where the fluctuation-dissipation theorem may not apply Raban et al. 2022 . Here we focus on a temperature regime where we expect the fluctuation dissipation theorem to apply, so the two measures of S(f,T) should be identical Morineau et al. 2024 . In the case of spin ice, numerical simulations suggested that magnetic monopoles would lead to a noise spectral density as function of frequency S(f)\sim 1/f^{b}(T) , with 1\leq b\leq 2 varying with temperature T , at frequencies above about 1\, kHz Kirschner et al. 2018 . This ‘pink noise’ would therefore be measurably distinct from the b=2 ‘red noise’ expected for a simple paramagnet. This prediction was quickly confirmed experimentally using SQUID-magnetometry on Dy 2 Ti 2 O 7 , with pink noise measured at temperatures between 1-4\, K, and frequencies up to 2.5\, kHz. The anomalous b(T) was found to decrease with increasing temperature, from b=1.5 at T=1\,\textrm{K} to b=1.2 at T=4\,\textrm{K} Dusad et al. 2019 . A subsequent noise measurement in the temperature range 0.8-3.8\, K, with frequencies up to 10^{5}\, Hz, found close agreement, with b=1.6 at T=1\,\textrm{K} again decreasing to b=1.2 at T=3.8\,\textrm{K} Samarakoon et al. 2022 . Recent theoretical work has proposed a mechanism by which b=1.50 can arise from the motion of isolated magnetic monopoles, relevant at the lowest temperatures of the spin ice regime (around 650\, mK), as a result of their seeing an effectively fractal hopping environment Hallén et al. 2022 . However, these measurements have revealed a central mystery. Above 20\, K it is well-established from neutron spin echo experiments that the classical spin ice materials based on Dy and Ho have b=2 Gardner et al. 2011 ; Ehlers et al. 2003 . While the data are more complete for Ho 2 Ti 2 O 7 Ehlers et al. 2003 , it is clear that Dy 2 Ti 2 O 7 behaves in essentially the same way and on a similar temperature scale. Hence we can certainly expect a crossover to b=2 around T=20 K. Yet the noise-measured b(T) are seen to decrease from b(1\,\textrm{K})=1.5 with increasing temperature to a value b(4\,\textrm{K})=1.2 , with little sign of the expected approach to b=2 Dusad et al. 2019 ; Samarakoon et al. 2022 . In this paper we confirm that, while showing some sample variation, b is significantly closer to 2 than implied by noise measurements and it evolves smoothly towards b=2 at higher temperature. A reason for systematic error in the noise-based estimates of b could be a generic one: owing to the discrete time sampling and associated discrete Fourier transform, noise-based estimates of S(f,T) measured in time are prone to distortions unless the sampling rate significantly exceeds the highest frequency component in the signal (an aspect of the Nyquist sampling theorem) Kirchner 2005 . This condition cannot simply be achieved when S(f,T) has a high frequency power law tail. The ‘aliasing’ of the high frequency signal to lower frequencies then means that a log-log plot of the estimated S(f,T) will show a point of inflection and a “flattened”, or pushed-up, high frequency tail. This leads to the possibility that the exponent b could be under-estimated. This problem was discussed by Kirchner Kirchner 2005 , who proposed a method of