The spin-phonon relaxation mechanism of single-molecule magnets in the presence of strong exchange coupling

Sourav Mondal 1, Julia Netz 2, David Hunger 3, Simon Suhr 4, Biprajit Sarkar 4,5, Joris van Slageren 3, Andreas Köhn 2, Alessandro Lunghi 1 · 2024

Read The spin-phonon relaxation mechanism of single-molecule magnets in the presence of strong exchange coupling by Sourav Mondal 1, Julia Netz 2, David Hunger 3, Simon Suhr 4, Biprajit Sarkar 4,5, Joris van Slageren 3, Andreas Köhn 2, Alessandro Lunghi 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04362.txt.

Introduction

Mondal and co-authors give in a 2024 study the first full account of how a two-cobalt molecule loses its magnetism through lattice shakes. Such single-molecule magnets could store data at tiny scales, but their memory fades as spins trade energy with vibrations. Big internal fields were known to slow that fade, with no full theory for pairs.

Their first-principles model matched lab data with fine accuracy and traced each decay path. It also showed how the paths depend on the link between the two cobalt atoms. A four-cobalt cluster, they predict, would shut one decay path off entirely.

Catalog record

CREATORSourav Mondal 1, Julia Netz 2, David Hunger 3, Simon Suhr 4, Biprajit Sarkar 4,5, Joris van Slageren 3, Andreas Köhn 2, Alessandro Lunghi 1
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04362

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The spin-phonon relaxation mechanism of single-molecule magnets in the presence of strong exchange coupling Sourav Mondal 1, Julia Netz 2, David Hunger 3, Simon Suhr 4, Biprajit Sarkar 4,5, Joris van Slageren 3, Andreas Köhn 2, Alessandro Lunghi 1 Abstract Magnetic relaxation in coordination compounds is largely dominated by the interaction of the spin with phonons. Large zero-field splitting and exchange coupling values have been empirically found to strongly suppress spin relaxation and have been used as the main guideline for designing new molecular compounds. Although a comprehensive understanding of spin-phonon relaxation has been achieved for mononuclear complexes, only a qualitative picture is available for polynuclear compounds. Here we fill this critical knowledge gap by providing a full first-principle description of spin-phonon relaxation in an air-stable Co(II) dimer with both large single-ion anisotropy and exchange coupling. Simulations reproduce the experimental relaxation data with excellent accuracy and provide a microscopic understanding of Orbach and Raman relaxation pathways and their dependency on exchange coupling, zero-field splitting, and molecular vibrations. Theory and numerical simulations show that increasing cluster nuclearity to just four cobalt units would lead to a complete suppression of Raman relaxation. These results hold a general validity for single-molecule magnets, providing a deeper understanding of their relaxation and revised strategies for their improvement. Introduction Coordination complexes with large magnetic anisotropies have been shown to display slow relaxation of their magnetic moment. Compounds of this class have been named single-molecule magnets (SMMs), in recognition of their similarities with hard magnets [ 1 ] , and have attracted a large interest for potential applications such as nanomagnetism [ 2 ] , spintronics [ 3 ] and more recently quantum information science [ 4 ] . One of the main priorities for advancing these applications is mitigating the dramatic increase of the spin relaxation rate with temperature, T . The spin dynamics of a molecular spin is deeply affected by its interaction with the surrounding lattice, namely the spin-phonon coupling, which ultimately leads to a state with a zero expectation value of the magnetization [ 5 ] . At high temperatures, the spin relaxation time, \tau , follows the Arrhenius law \tau=\tau_{0}e^{U_{\mathrm{eff}}/\mathrm{k_{B}}T}\>, (1) where the effective magnetization reversal barrier U_{\mathrm{eff}} can be taken as a measure of magnetic anisotropy [ 6 ] . Very early on, it was recognized that in the absence of under-barrier processes, the effective energy barrier is U_{\mathrm{eff}}=|D|S^{2} , where D is the molecular axial zero-field splitting and S is the ground-state total spin value. For negative values of D , the maximum values of the spin projections, M_{S}=\pm S , are the lowest in energy, and up to 2S sequential phonon quanta have to be absorbed/emitted to go from M_{S}=S\rightarrow M_{S}=-S and reverse the spin orientation. As the factor |D|S^{2} increases in value, phonons with high energy (and thus low thermal population) are needed to initiate this process, leading to a slower relaxation, as expressed by Eq. 1 . This relaxation mechanism falls under the name of Orbach and maximising D has proved to be the best strategy to reduce its detrimental effects on the spin [ 7 , 8 ] . To this end, much effort has been devoted to the design of mononuclear coordination compounds and outstanding results have been achieved, e.g. U_{\mathrm{eff}}\sim 450 cm -1 [ 9 ] and 1500 cm -1 [ 10 ] in linear Co(II) and Dy(III) mononuclear complexes, respectively. However, minimizing the effect of Orbach relaxation is not the sole challenge in the field, and other spin relaxation mechanisms are operative. For instance, Quantum Tunneling of the Magnetization (QTM) operates at low temperatures and is primarily responsible for the closure of the magnetic hysteresis curve at magnetic zero field. Exchange coupling was recognized to slow down QTM and its study has been at the centre stage of the field since the very beginning [ 11 ] . However, the maximization of both zero-field splitting and exchange coupling, in the attempt to quench both Orbach and QTM relaxation, has proved challenging [ 12 ] . On the one hand, as the field moved to SMMs with large single-ion zero-field splittings, the phenomenology of spin-phonon relaxation has become much more complex and Raman and direct phonon-mediated relaxation mechanisms have started to play a role at low temperature and high magnetic field, respectively [ 13 , 14 ] . Moreover, whilst early SMMs, like Mn 12 [ 1 ] , and Fe 4 [ 15 ] , were mostly based on ions with low zero-field splitting and large exchange coupling values, most compounds with large zero-field splitting fall in a weak or intermediate exchange coupling regime [ 16 ] . Molecules of this class present a multitude of low-energy spin states available for relaxation, making the interpretation of experiments far from trivial and unequivocal [ 17 , 14 ] . In recent years, the combination of ab initio computational methods and the theory of open quantum systems has made it possible to simulate spin-phonon relaxation in magnetic molecules [ 18 , 5 ] , opening a window on the microscopic details of this process. Ab initio simulations of spin relaxation have played a key role in resolving conflictual interpretations of spin relaxation in mononuclear compounds, particularly in the interpretation of Raman relaxation [ 19 , 20 ] , and resolving a large number of misinterpretations of experiments [ 21 ] . A first-principles description of spin-phonon coupling and relaxation in SMMs has not only aided the interpretation of the experiments [ 22 , 21 ] but has also provided insights into the nature of spin-phonon coupling and its relation to molecular structure [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] . However, ab initio studies of spin relaxation have so far been exclusively performed for mononuclear compounds and our understanding of spin relaxation in polynuclear SMMs is still largely phenomenological. In order for the field of exchange-coupled SMMs to progress it is now imperative to achieve a complete understanding of their spin relaxation and address the urgent questions of the nature of spin-phonon coupling and relaxation mechanisms in these compounds. In this contribution, we use ab initio open quantum systems theory to address spin relaxation in polynuclear clusters and complete the microscopic interpretation of Orbach and Raman spin-phonon relaxation in SMMs. For this purpose, we use the radical-bridged Co(II) dimer [K(18-crown-6] 2 ][K(H 2 O) 4 ][Co(bmsab)] 2 ( \mu -tmsab)] ( \mathbf{Co_{2}Rad} ), where bmsab is the dianion of 1,2-bis(methanesulfonamide) benzene and tmsab is the radical-trianion of 1,2,4,5-tetrakis(methanesulfonamide)benzene. This recently reported compound [ 26 ] exhibits some of the largest U_{\mathrm{eff}} and slowest relaxation among transition metal complexes. Importantly, unlike most Ln-based SMMs, this compound is air-stable, potentially representing an optimal building block for future technologies based on SMMs. Last but not least, the electronic structure of this compound has recently been exhaustively characterized [ 26 ] , and spin relaxation in its mononuclear building block [ 14 ] has been successfully explained with ab initio methods [ 27 ] , thus offering an ideal starting point for our study. Figure 1: \mathbf{Co_{2}Rad} molecular structure. The three-dimensional structure of the anion \mathbf{Co_{2}Rad} is reported with the colour code: Co in brown, H in white, C

Read the complete text