Disentangling the influence of excitation energy and compound nucleus angular momentum on fission fragment angular momentum

Simone Cannarozzo, Stephan Pomp, Andreas Solders, Ali Al-Adili, Zhihao Gao, Mattias Lantz, Heikki Penttilä, Anu Kankainen, Iain Moore, Tommi Eronen, Zhuang Ge, Jouni Ruotsalainen, Maxime Mougeot, Ville Virtanen, Arthur Jaries, Marek Stryjczyk, Andrea Raggio · 2024

Read Disentangling the influence of excitation energy and compound nucleus angular momentum on fission fragment angular momentum by Simone Cannarozzo, Stephan Pomp, Andreas Solders, Ali Al-Adili, Zhihao Gao, Mattias Lantz, Heikki Penttilä, Anu Kankainen, Iain Moore, Tommi Eronen, Zhuang Ge, Jouni Ruotsalainen, Maxime Mougeot, Ville Virtanen, Arthur Jaries, Marek Stryjczyk, Andrea Raggio (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04340.txt.

Introduction

Simone Cannarozzo and co-authors reported this 2024 experiment on why fission fragments spin so hard. When a heavy nucleus splits, the pieces fly out with large spin, and the source of that spin is debated. The team measured ratios between long-lived states of differing spin in fission products. Such ratios act as a spin thermometer for the split.

They split thorium with alpha particles at a Finnish facility, making uranium nuclei with high average spin. The ratios ran higher than in neutron-caused fission of uranium, where the starting spin is lower. Photon-caused fission data from the literature showed no link to excitation energy. The authors conclude the starting nucleus's spin alone explains the gap, so part of fragment spin is inherited, not made in the split.

Catalog record

CREATORSimone Cannarozzo, Stephan Pomp, Andreas Solders, Ali Al-Adili, Zhihao Gao, Mattias Lantz, Heikki Penttilä, Anu Kankainen, Iain Moore, Tommi Eronen, Zhuang Ge, Jouni Ruotsalainen, Maxime Mougeot, Ville Virtanen, Arthur Jaries, Marek Stryjczyk, Andrea Raggio
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04340

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Disentangling the influence of excitation energy and compound nucleus angular momentum on fission fragment angular momentum Simone Cannarozzo, Stephan Pomp, Andreas Solders, Ali Al-Adili, Zhihao Gao, Mattias Lantz, Heikki Penttilä, Anu Kankainen, Iain Moore, Tommi Eronen, Zhuang Ge, Jouni Ruotsalainen, Maxime Mougeot, Ville Virtanen, Arthur Jaries, Marek Stryjczyk, Andrea Raggio Abstract The origin of the large angular momenta observed for fission fragments is still a question under discussion. To address this, we study isomeric yield ratios (IYR), i.e. the relative population of two or more long-lived metastable states with different spins, of fission products. We report on IYR of 17 isotopes produced in the 28 MeV α \alpha -induced fission of 232 Th at the IGISOL facility of the University of Jyväskylä. The fissioning nuclei in this reaction are 233,234,235 U*. We compare our data to IYR from thermal neutron-induced fission of 233 U and 235 U, and we observe statistically significant larger IYR in the 232 Th( α \alpha ,f) reaction, where the average compound nucleus (CN) spin is 7.7 ℏ \hbar , than in 233,235 U(n th ,f), with average spins 2.6 and 3.6 ℏ \hbar , respectively. To assess the influence of the excitation energy, we study literature data of IYR from photon-induced fission reactions, and find that, within current uncertainties, the IYR indicate no dependency of the CN excitation energy. We conclude that the different IYR seem to be due to the different CN spins alone. This would imply that the FF angular momentum only partly comes from the fission process itself, and is in addition influenced by the angular momentum present in the CN. Since its discovery in 1939 Hahn and Strassmann 1939 , considerable progress has been made in advancing our understanding of nuclear fission. However, several fundamental questions remain unresolved Andreyev et al. 2018 ; Schmidt and Jurado 2018 . One concerns the origin of fission fragment angular momenta, first raised by Wilhelmy et al. Wilhelmy et al. 1972 . In binary fission, after the nucleus reaches the saddle point, two clusters of nucleons begin to form the two nascent fragments. Wilhelmy et al. observed that the fragments emerging after scission typically carry significant angular momentum (in the order of 7 \hbar Wilhelmy et al. 1972 ), even in spontaneous fission of the 0 + spin nucleus 252 Cf. The physical process responsible for the generation of fission fragment (FF) spin is still highly debated Andreyev et al. 2018 ; Wilson et al. 2021 ; Randrup and Vogt 2021 ; Marević et al. 2021 ; Vogt and Randrup 2021 ; Bulgac 2022 ; Scamps and Bertsch 2023 . The two most widely accepted explanations suggest that the angular momentum can be partially determined by the excitation of collective relative orbital motions between the two prefragments before scission Rasmussen et al. 1969 ; Moretto et al. 1989 ; Bulgac et al. 2022 ; Døssing et al. 2024 , and/or by Coulomb repulsion around scission Hoffman 1964 ; Randrup 2023 . At the same time, other factors may also influence the angular momentum generation, such as the deformation of the FFs and the nuclear shell structure Marević et al. 2021 ; Wilkins et al. 1976 ; Bertsch et al. 2019 . Recently, Wilson et al. proposed post-scission generation of the angular momentum Wilson et al. 2021 . They experimentally observed the same saw-tooth shaped dependency of the FFs angular momentum on the mass for three different low-energy fissioning systems, concluding that completely uncorrelated torques are generated by the rupture of the neck connecting the nascent fragments Wilson et al. 2021 . However, uncorrelated angular momenta have later also been obtained through pre-scission model calculations by Randrup et al. Randrup and Vogt 2021 and Scamps et al. Scamps and Bertsch 2023 , showing that the post-scission model advanced by Wilson et al. is not the only possible explanation for their observation. Any model describing angular momenta of FFs must account for the influence of both excitation energy and angular momentum of the compound nucleus (CN). The influence of CN conditions on FF spins has been the focus of extensive research, both through experimental activities Wilson et al. 2021 ; Giha et al. 2023 ; Gjestvang et al. 2023 ; Qi et al. 2018 ; Laborie et al. 2018 ; Aumann et al. 1977 and theoretical modeling Kawano et al. 2023 ; Vogt and Randrup 2021 ; Bulgac et al. 2021 . Within the Hauser-Feshbach fission fragment de-excitation model, Kawano et al. Kawano et al. 2023 indeed found indications that FFs from photofission and neutron-induced fission might have similar angular momenta at the same excitation energy of the CN, regardless of its spin. Similarly, in the FREYA code Vogt and Randrup 2021 , Randrup and Vogt assume that the main fraction of the CN angular momentum goes into the relative motion of the FFs, while their spin is mainly determined by the temperature of the fissioning nucleus at scission. Furthermore, within the framework of a fully microscopical model, Bulgac et al. showed Bulgac et al. 2021 that an increase in the compound nucleus excitation energy might produce FFs at higher spin. They concluded that the average spin of the FFs increases with the kinetic energy of the incident neutrons in the fission reactions of 235 U and 239 Pu. From an experimental perspective, Bulgac’s result is supported by References Giha et al. 2023 ; Laborie et al. 2018 ; Qi et al. 2018 which report an increase of the \gamma -ray multiplicity as a function of the kinetic energy of the incident neutrons in the fission reactions of 238 U and 239 Pu. Figure 1: PI-ICR images produced during the experimental campaign. Identified nuclei are marked in the plots. A number of pictures show the presence of contaminants and asymmetrical tails (see Fig. 3 ). Phase-accumulation times were optimized to ensure that the regions of interest do not overlap with other ion species. A different way of looking for correlations is to use the spin-trap isomers of the produced nuclei. The FPs, after the neutron evaporation and the \gamma -rays cascade, eventually decay into a (meta)stable nuclear state, before further \beta -decay towards the line of stability. A large number of nuclei have more than one long-lived metastable state, differing in spin and excitation energy. The angular momentum of a FF influences the population of the isomeric states Vandenbosch and Huizenga 1960 ; Huizenga and Vandenbosch 1960 . Therefore, the ratio between the production rate of two or more long-lived metastable states, the so-called isomeric yield ratio (IYR), provides access to the angular momentum of fission fragments Wilhelmy et al. 1972 ; Naik et al. 1988 ; Naik et al. 1995 ; Naik et al. 2024 ; Rakopoulos et al. 2018 ; Rakopoulos et al. 2019 ; Al-Adili et al. 2019 ; Gao et al. 2024 . Table 1: Measured IYR for fission products from 232 Th( \alpha ,f) and relevant nuclear data. The values of half-life (t 1/2 ), spin (J), and excitation energy (E {}_{\text{exc}} ) were obtained from the Nubase2020 evaluation Kondev et al. 2021 , except for 123 In and 123 Cd, for which more recent values were retrieved from the ENSDF database

Read the complete text