Deep Causal Inference for Point-referenced Spatial Data with Continuous Treatments

Ziyang Jiang, Zach Calhoun, Yiling Liu, Lei Duan, David Carlson · 2024

Read Deep Causal Inference for Point-referenced Spatial Data with Continuous Treatments by Ziyang Jiang, Zach Calhoun, Yiling Liu, Lei Duan, David Carlson (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04285.txt.

Introduction

Ziyang Jiang and four co-authors build a deep learning framework for causal inference with spatial data and continuous treatments. Spatial data pose hard problems, including spillover between nearby units and unobserved confounding. High dimensional inputs such as satellite images add further difficulty for classic methods.

The framework joins a neural network with an approximate Gaussian process to handle spatial interference and hidden confounding. A generalized propensity score approach deals with outcomes that are only partly observed. Tests on synthetic, semi synthetic, and real data derived from satellite imagery show clear gains over linear spatial regression. In real case studies the model gives more plausible effect estimates for policy use.

Catalog record

CREATORZiyang Jiang, Zach Calhoun, Yiling Liu, Lei Duan, David Carlson
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04285

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Deep Causal Inference for Point-referenced Spatial Data with Continuous Treatments Ziyang Jiang, Zach Calhoun, Yiling Liu, Lei Duan, David Carlson Abstract Causal reasoning is often challenging with spatial data, particularly when handling high-dimensional inputs. To address this, we propose a neural network (NN) based framework integrated with an approximate Gaussian process to manage spatial interference and unobserved confounding. Additionally, we adopt a generalized propensity-score-based approach to address partially observed outcomes when estimating causal effects with continuous treatments. We evaluate our framework using synthetic, semi-synthetic, and real-world data inferred from satellite imagery. 1 1 1 Code is available at: https://github.com/jzy95310/deep_sci . Our results demonstrate that NN-based models significantly outperform linear spatial regression models in estimating causal effects. Furthermore, in real-world case studies, NN-based models offer more reasonable predictions of causal effects, facilitating decision-making in relevant applications. A Preprint 1 Introduction Drawing causal relationships from data is essential across multiple disciplines, such as economic studies Howard et al. (2010) , drug discovery Michoel and Zhang (2023) , and neuroscience experiments Jiang et al. (2023a) . However, many of the existing causal inference methodologies rely on a number of assumptions, including the Stable Unit Treatment Value Assumption (SUTVA) Rosenbaum and Rubin (1983) ; Rubin (2005) and the principle of strong ignorability (i.e., the absence of unmeasured confounders) Pearl (2009) . These assumptions can be violated when dealing with spatial data, which plays a crucial role in various scientific fields including environmental science Haining (2003) ; Banerjee et al. (2003) ; Cressie (2015) ; Zheng et al. (2021) ; Jiang et al. (2022) , urban planning Sudhira et al. (2003) ; Scott and Horner (2008) ; Schabenberger and Gotway (2017) ; Yan (2022) ; Hu et al. (2023) , agriculture Rajesh (2011) ; Plant (2018) , distributed networking Zhu (2022) , public health Rushton (2003) ; Waller and Gotway (2004) ; Zhu and Hu (2021) , and beyond. In this paper, we focus on causal inference related to a specific type of spatial data: point-referenced data, where we observe realizations or measurements of an underlying spatial process at a fixed set of locations. For instance, a measurement might represent an observation of pollutant levels. While it is theoretically conceivable to assume the existence of pollutant levels across an entire spatial domain, in practice, we are limited to finite measurements obtained from ground monitoring stations. There are two major differences between causal inference on non-spatial and spatial data Reich et al. (2021) . First , the treatment assigned to one unit may affect the outcomes of other units (usually adjacent or neighboring units) in the spatial domain, which we call spatial interference or spillover effects . Also, it is crucial to consider unobserved spatial confounding variables, as comprehensive data on all relevant confounders (such as climatological or regulatory factors) are almost never observed but are anticipated to exhibit spatial variation and affect both treatment and target variables in most scenarios Papadogeorgou et al. (2019) . Moreover, when the scale of unobserved spatial confounding is greater than the spatial variation of the observed variables, including this effect reduces the bias of estimates of treatment effects Paciorek (2010) . Significant progress has been made in causal inference for point-referenced spatial data in linear models. Specifically, to account for the unobserved spatial confounder, some common approaches include introducing a spatial proximity term into the propensity score matching procedure Papadogeorgou et al. (2019) , comparing observations that are spatially close but differ in treatment to eliminate the effect of the unobserved confounder Imbens and Lemieux (2008) ; Bor et al. (2014) ; Keele and Titiunik (2015) , or explicitly modeling the unobserved spatial confounder as a zero-mean Gaussian process (GP) Marques et al. (2022) ; Calhoun et al. (2024) . In addition, when dealing with spatial interference, researchers make different assumptions about the form of interference (e.g., group-based interference Perez-Heydrich et al. (2014) ; Zigler and Papadogeorgou (2021) , network-based interference Aronow and Samii (2017) ; Tchetgen Tchetgen et al. (2021) ; Ogburn et al. (2022) , process-based interference Cross et al. (2019) , etc.) and come up with different solutions such as structural equation model Bovendorp et al. (2019) and Bayesian statistical model Papadogeorgou and Samanta (2023) . Nevertheless, these methods are not sufficiently effective as the causal effects of both unobserved confounders and spatial interference can be highly nonlinear. For example, when treatments, confounders, and targets are all inferred from satellite imagery, the relationship among these variables can be complex and heavily dependent on their spatial variation. Also, many of the existing works assume there is only one binary treatment, which limits their applicability on spatial data, as we may wish to consider multiple, continuous treatments that commonly exist in environmental problems (e.g., variable amounts of tree cover, continuous levels of albedo, air pollution levels, etc.). In light of these observations, in this study, we propose to integrate deep neural networks (NNs) with the spatial regression model for causal inference on point-referenced data. We posit that NN-based spatial regression model would be able to capture nonlinear causal relationships in the presence of spatial interference and unobserved confounders. Our contributions can be summarized as follows. • We explore spatial causal inference on point-referenced data under the potential outcomes framework with continuous treatments where the SUTVA assumption can be relaxed. • We develop a deep-neural-network-based spatial causal inference framework and integrate it with an approximate GP to handle treatments and measured confounders inferred from high-dimensional data. • We employ a generalized propensity-score-based approach to address the challenge of partially observed outcomes in the context of continuous treatments. • To validate the efficacy of our proposed methodology, we perform experiments on synthetic and semi-synthetic datasets, and real-world case studies that include satellite imagery. • We investigate various architectures of NNs and evaluate their impact on the performance of the proposed framework. 2 Causal Inference for Point-referenced Spatial Data We first define the necessary notations and assumptions for causal inference on spatial data. We will use upper-case letters (e.g., T_{1},\dots,T_{M} , Y ) for one-dimensional random variables and lower-case letters (e.g., t_{1},\dots,t_{M} , y ) for their corresponding realizations. Multi-dimensional random variables and realizations will be denoted using bold fonts (e.g., \boldsymbol{X} and \boldsymbol{x} ). In conventional causal inference settings with one single treatment, it is standard to define T as the treatment, \boldsymbol{X} as the set of observed confounders, and Y as the outcome. However, in our case, we may have multiple treatments. If so, we denote them as T_{1},\dots,T_{M} ; otherwise, we use T for a single treatment. As discussed in the introduction, in spatial settings, the treatment received by one unit can affect the outcome of other units, a phenomenon known as spatial interference or spillover effect . While in an ideal scenario, the outcome of one unit could be influenced by all units within a spatial region, we restrict our consideration to the set of treatments \overline{\boldsymbol{T}} within a defined “neighboring area” (see Figure 1(b) , which simplifies the problem to a one-dimensional case, though the actual problem is in two dimensions) for each unit, which we refer to as local interference . We posit that treatments beyond this area are distant enough from the unit to

Read the complete text