Hilbert’s 10 th 10^{\text{th}} Problem via Mordell curves
Somnath Jha, Debanjana Kundu, Dipramit Majumdar · 2024
Read Hilbert’s 10 th 10^{\text{th}} Problem via Mordell curves by Somnath Jha, Debanjana Kundu, Dipramit Majumdar (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04253.txt.
Introduction
Somnath Jha, Debanjana Kundu and Dipramit Majumdar study Hilbert's tenth problem over certain number fields, in work from 2024. The problem asks, in this setting, whether an algorithm can decide if polynomial equations have solutions in those fields. Their results give unsolvability for a large share of cases built from roots of unity and cube roots of primes.
For five-sixths of all primes, the problem is unsolvable over the stated field. An infinite family of square-free integers yields unsolvability for a wider class of fields as well. The proof uses complex multiplication elliptic curves tied to the cube sum problem, with the curve parameter varying in a chosen congruence class.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Somnath Jha, Debanjana Kundu, Dipramit Majumdar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04253
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hilbert’s 10 th 10^{\text{th}} Problem via Mordell curves Somnath Jha, Debanjana Kundu, Dipramit Majumdar Abstract . We show that for 5 / 6 5/6 -th of all primes p p , Hilbert’s 10 th 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable for the ring of integers of ℚ ( ζ 3 , p 3 ) \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt[3]{p}) . We also show that there is an infinite set S S of square-free integers such that Hilbert’s 10 th 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable over the ring of integers of ℚ ( ζ 3 , D , p 3 ) \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt{D},\sqrt[3]{p}) for every D ∈ S D\in S and for every prime p ≡ 2 , 5 ( mod 9 ) p\equiv 2,5\pmod{9} . We use the CM elliptic curves y 2 = x 3 − 432 D 2 y^{2}=x^{3}-432D^{2} associated to the cube-sum problem, with D D varying in suitable congruence class, in our proof. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 11G05, Secondary: 11U05, 11D25 Introduction In 1900, D. Hilbert posed the following question (which was the tenth in his list of twenty-three questions): does there exist an algorithm (Turing machine) that takes as input polynomial equations over \mathbb{Z} and decides whether they have integer solutions. Building on the work of M. Davis, H. Putnam, and J. Robinson in [ DP61 , DPR61 , Rob69 ] , Y. Matiyasevich proved that computably enumerable sets over \mathbb{Z} are exactly the same as the Diophantine sets over \mathbb{Z} ; see [ Mat70 ] . In other words, he proved that Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable. Soon after in 1978, J. Denef and L. Lipshitz [ DL78 ] asked whether there exists an algorithm (Turing machine) that takes as input polynomial equations over \mathcal{O}_{F} (the ring of integers of a number field F ) and decides whether they have integer solutions. A straight-forward argument shows that if \mathbb{Z} is Diophantine in \mathcal{O}_{F} , then the analogue of Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem for \mathcal{O}_{F} has a negative solution. At the start of the 21st century, it was first observed by B. Poonen that there is a connection between rank stabilization of elliptic curve in extensions of number fields and Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem, [ Poo02 ] . The result was further strengthened by A. Shlapentokh (which is recorded in Theorem 1.2 ) and has been one of the key tools in proving new cases of the conjecture of Denef–Lipshitz. For several classes of number fields, Denef–Lipshitz conjecture has been established. For example, (i) if a number field is totally real, (ii) if it a quadratic extension of a totally real number field, (iii) if the number field is abelian or (iv) if it has precisely one (pair of) complex places. There are also important related works of B. Mazur–K. Rubin [ MR10 ] . For degree 6 number fields of the form \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-q},\sqrt[3]{p}) as p and q vary over certain explicit set of primes of positive density, Denef–Lipshitz conjecture was established in [ GFP20 , KLS24 ] . On the other hand, [ SW23 ] proves that for a positive proportion of integers a , Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable for \mathcal{O}_{F} where F is of the form \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[6]{a}) . We consider Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem for the ring of integers of certain S_{3} extensions and degree 12 extensions of \mathbb{Q} . The Kummer extension \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt[3]{m}),m\in\mathbb{Z} is the first layer of the so called ‘false Tate curve’ extension for p=3 and is widely studied in (non-commutative) Iwasawa theory. Using Mordell curves \mathsf{E}_{a}\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}y^{2}=x^{3}+a,a\in\mathbb{Z} and its cubic twists, we apply results on the cube-sum problem to prove new cases of the Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem. In particular, we prove the following results Theorem A . For \frac{5}{6} -th of all primes p , Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem has a negative solution over the ring of integers of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt[3]{p}) . Proposition A . Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable over the ring of integers of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt{D},\sqrt[3]{p}) , where D varies over an infinite set S consisting of square-free integers and p is a prime such that p\equiv 2,5\pmod{9} . Further, \#(S\cap[-X,X])\gg X^{1-\epsilon} where X\gg 0 and for any \epsilon>0 . We emphasize that this result complements the results proven in [ KLS24 ] and indeed provides (infinitely many) new examples of number fields where Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem is unsolvable. We are interested in Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem for the ring of integers of \mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{3},\sqrt[3]{m}),m\in\mathbb{Z} and it raised the following natural question which is of interdependent interest: given a Mordell elliptic curve \mathsf{E}_{a}\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}y^{2}=x^{3}+a,a\in\mathbb{Z} does there exist a cube-free integer D co-prime to a such that precisely one of the elliptic curves \mathsf{E}_{a},\mathsf{E}_{aD^{2}},\mathsf{E}_{aD^{4}} has positive Mordell–Weil rank over \mathbb{Q} ? We did an extensive computation on this on SAGE/MAGMA which are mentioned in Section 2 . This led us to apply results from the cube-sum problem. As we were completing our preprint, C. Pagano–P. Koymans announced an unconditional proof of the unsolvability of Hilbert’s 10^{\text{th}} problem [ KP24 ] over the ring of integers of any number field. Their result is accomplished by constructing elliptic curves \mathsf{E} and studying their quadratic twists to guarantee that there is no rank growth of \mathsf{E} in certain quadratic extensions. They use 2 -descent argument and tools from additive combinatorics. On the other hand, our approach involves studying cubic twists instead of quadratic twists of elliptic curves. In fact, we specifically use Mordell curves. We use results from the cube-sum problem to study the cubic twists of the Mordell curves. Thus our method is different. Even more recently, L. Alpöge–M. Bhargava–W. Ho–A. Shnidman announced another proof [ ABHS25 ] . Organization Including this introduction, there are three sections in this short note. Section 1 is preliminary in nature, where we record crucial results that will be used in the main argument. In Section 2 , we discuss the main motivation behind this note and also raise questions which we have not been able to answer completely. In Section 3 , we state and prove the main result of our note. 1. Preliminaries In this section, we record some results which will be used crucially in our argument(s). 1.1. Cube-Sum Problem The classical Diophantine cube-sum problem asks the question: which integers D can be expressed as a sum of two rational cubes? An integer D is called a cube-sum (resp. not a cube-sum), if x^{3}+y^{3}=D has (resp. does not have) a rational solution. The elliptic curve X^{3}+Y^{3}=DZ^{3} can be expressed in the Weierstrass equation as y^{2}=x^{3}-432D^{2} and for a cube-free integer D>2 it is known that torsion subgroup of {\mathsf{E}_{-432D^{2}}(\mathbb{Q})} vanishes. Thus, a cube-free integer D>2 satisfies D=a^{3}+b^{3} for a,b\in\mathbb{Q} if and only if the Mordell-Weil group E_{-432D^{2}}(\mathbb{Q}) has a positive rank. The cube-sum problem has been studied in great detail with important contributions by J. Sylvester, F. Lucas, T. Pépin, E. Selmer, P. Satgé, D. Lieman, F. R. Villegas–D. Zagier etc. Some recent works include [ DV18 , CST17 , HSY19 , ABS22 ] . We refer to [ DV18 , ABS22 ] for a literature review. We record the special cases below which will be used in the article. Theorem 1.1 . (a) Suppose that p\equiv 2,5\pmod{9} is an odd prime. By [ Syl79 , Section 2] the integers p,p^{2},9p, and 9p^{2} are