On unipolar and bipolar HiPIMS pulse configurations to enhance energy flux to insulating surfaces Journal: Plasma Sources Sci. Technol.
M. Farahani, T. Kozák, A.D. Pajdarová, T. Tölg, J. Čapek · 2024
Read On unipolar and bipolar HiPIMS pulse configurations to enhance energy flux to insulating surfaces Journal: Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. by M. Farahani, T. Kozák, A.D. Pajdarová, T. Tölg, J. Čapek (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-04154.txt.
Introduction
Farahani and co-authors studied pulse designs in 2024 for a sputtering method that coats insulating surfaces. The method fires high power in short pulses, raising ionisation and energy of sputtered atoms. The team asked which pulse patterns deliver the most energy to an insulated film or substrate.
They compared single-polarity, two-polarity, and chopped versions of each, measuring energy with a thermal probe. For low-capacitance surfaces, two-polarity designs added little, since ions charge the surface fast. Chopping the positive pulse helped at medium capacitance by discharging the surface in off-times. Splitting the negative pulse also raised energy delivery in the single-polarity case, they found.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Farahani, T. Kozák, A.D. Pajdarová, T. Tölg, J. Čapek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-04154
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On unipolar and bipolar HiPIMS pulse configurations to enhance energy flux to insulating surfaces Journal: Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. M. Farahani, T. Kozák, A.D. Pajdarová, T. Tölg, J. Čapek Abstract High-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) delivers a high target power in short pulses, enhancing the ionization and energy of sputtered atoms and providing thus more possibilities to control the film properties. This study explores the effect of various pulse configurations (unipolar HiPIMS, bipolar HiPIMS, chopped unipolar, and chopped bipolar HiPIMS)ease energy flux to an insulated surface (e.g., substrate or growing film). The chopped bipolar HiPIMS configuration, featuring several short positive pulses replacing a single long positive pulse, is introduced, and the total energy fluxes are subsequently measured using a passive thermal probe. Moreover, the effect of the probe’s capacitance with respect to the ground is systematically investigated by connecting an external capacitor. Results show that for an insulated surface with low capacitance, bipolar pulse configurations do not significantly increase energy flux to the surface due to its rapid charging by plasma ions. Conversely, high surface capacitance facilitates an increase in energy flux, as a large potential difference between the plasma and the surface remains even for a long positive pulse. For medium surface capacitance (tens of nF), chopping the positive pulse in bipolar HiPIMS effectively increases the energy delivered to the film by discharging the surface in the off-times. The thermal probe measurements also confirm that energy to the film can be increased for unipolar HiPIMS configurations by splitting the negative pulse into several shorter pulses. Keywords : High power impulse magnetron sputtering, Bipolar HiPIMS, Chopped HiPIMS, Insulating surfaces, Energy flux, Thermal probe High-Power Impulse Magnetron Sputtering (HiPIMS) is an advanced technique used for thin film deposition, where the target material is sputtered within short, high-power pulses. These conditions produce a high fraction of ionized species and broaden their ion energy distribution functions, offering greater flexibility in tailoring the properties of the films. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . The energy of the ions may be further enhanced as they travel through a region where the plasma potential decreases. This occurs in the plasma sheath near the chamber surfaces (including substrates), where the plasma potential drops from a value corresponding to the conditions in the plasma volume (typically a few volts) to zero for grounded surfaces or to negative values for surfaces at floating potential. The extra energy gained by the ions is then determined by the difference between the plasma potential in the volume and at the surface. Additional ion acceleration is necessary if the energy delivered to the growing film by the ions is insufficient for the desired film properties. For conductive films and substrates, effective ion acceleration can be achieved through conventional HiPIMS with a continuous DC bias. The negative bias lowers the surface potential of the growing film, enlarging the potential difference responsible for the ion acceleration. However, this approach may result in the unintended incorporation of Ar gas into the growing film [ 6 , 7 ] . To solve these issues, synchronized pulsed DC bias is often preferred. By timing the bias to coincide with the metal-ion-rich portion of the HiPIMS pulse, this method minimizes gas entrapment in the material [ 8 , 7 ] . Bipolar HiPIMS has been proposed as an alternative when a DC substrate bias voltage is ineffective, such as for insulating surfaces. This approach introduces a positive voltage following the negative pulse, also establishing the potential difference for the ion acceleration. In this case, the potential difference arises because the plasma potential in the plasma volume rises to a value comparable to the applied positive voltage during the positive pulse [ 9 , 10 ] . However, for insulating surfaces, this acceleration quickly diminishes as the surface charges by impacting ions to the floating potential, which is close to the elevated potential of the plasma volume [ 5 , 6 ] . Therefore, this approach also provides limited control over ion energy. So, a more effective solution is needed to improve the usability of this technique for insulating surfaces. Building upon the developments in standard HiPIMS, chopping techniques have been successfully introduced to further enhance the performance of the process [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . By dividing each pulse into smaller segments, ”chopped HiPIMS” (or multi-pulse HiPIMS, abbreviated m-HiPIMS) has demonstrated significant improvements in ionization efficiency and deposition rate, which surpass the results of conventional HiPIMS [ 11 , 14 ] . Given these promising outcomes, applying the chopping technique to bipolar HiPIMS offers an exciting opportunity to further optimize the deposition processes. In this study, it is proposed to use several short segments of negative and positive pulses instead of using a single long negative and positive pulse to enhance energy flux to insulating surfaces/substrates. The effectiveness of this chopped bipolar HiPIMS technique is evaluated mainly based on the measured energy fluxes to a static thermal probe by comparing six pulse configurations, including standard unipolar and bipolar HiPIMS, as well as several configurations with multiple negative and positive pulses. We show that for certain conditions the chopped bipolar HiPIMS may provide a significant increase in the energy flux to an insulating surface. The experimental setup utilized a magnetron (VT100, Gencoa) with an unbalanced (type II) magnetic field configuration and a planar titanium target (100 mm in diameter) housed within a stainless-steel vacuum chamber with a volume of 24.4 liters. A turbomolecular pump, supported by a scroll pump, was used to evacuate the chamber (figure 1 ). Before the experiments, the base pressure inside the chamber was reduced below 4 \times 10^{-4}\,\mathrm{Pa} . The magnetron was driven by a custom-built pulsing unit capable of generating bipolar pulses, controlled by a waveform generator (Rigol DG4102), and powered with two DC power supplies (GS10, ADL for negative pulses and GEN600-1.3, TDK-Lambda for positive pulses). The target current was measured by a current probe (TCP303, Tektronix), and the target and thermal probe (see below) voltages were measured by two voltage probes (TESTEC, 100x attenuation); all connected to a digital oscilloscope (Picoscope 5444D, Pico Technology). Figure 1: Experimental setup with the passive thermal probe. TC denoted the connection of the integrated thermocouple used to measure the probe’s temperature. The various connections of the biasing wire are shown schematically. The diagnostic process was performed using the following pulse configurations: (1) standard HiPIMS, (2) standard bipolar HiPIMS, (3) chopped HiPIMS with five consecutive negative pulses, (4) bipolar HiPIMS with five cycles of alternating negative and positive pulses, (5) bipolar HiPIMS with five negative pulses, each followed by six short positive pulses, and (6) bipolar HiPIMS with five negative pulses, each followed by twelve short positive pulses (see figure 2 for the waveforms and a shorthand notation used throughout the paper). During all HiPIMS conditions, the total duration of negative and positive pulses was kept constant separately, ensuring the same duty cycle for all configurations. The Ar pressure was maintained at 1 Pa, with an Ar flow rate of 40 sccm. The average power delivered during the negative pulses was kept constant at 500 W. A positive voltage of 100 V was consistently applied during all positive