Design, Characterization, and Validation of a Variable Stiffness Prosthetic Elbow

Giuseppe Milazzo, Simon Lemerle, Giorgio Grioli, Antonio Bicchi, Manuel G. Catalano · 2024

Read Design, Characterization, and Validation of a Variable Stiffness Prosthetic Elbow by Giuseppe Milazzo, Simon Lemerle, Giorgio Grioli, Antonio Bicchi, Manuel G. Catalano (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03985.txt.

Introduction

Milazzo and four co-authors described a prosthetic elbow in twenty twenty-four whose stiffness the wearer can adjust. A joint that can soften or stiffen on demand could copy how a real arm braces for a push or relaxes for a gentle task, yet most artificial arms stay rigid.

The design uses two motors pulling against each other, like the biceps and triceps, with springs in the loop. One version packs everything into the forearm for people missing the arm below the shoulder. A second version splits the motors between the upper arm and forearm to spread the weight. Tests showed a one hundred twenty degree bend, a wide stiffness range, and the strength to lift three kilograms. The design weighs up to half less than earlier adjustable elbows of this kind.

Catalog record

CREATORGiuseppe Milazzo, Simon Lemerle, Giorgio Grioli, Antonio Bicchi, Manuel G. Catalano
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03985

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Design, Characterization, and Validation of a Variable Stiffness Prosthetic Elbow Giuseppe Milazzo, Simon Lemerle, Giorgio Grioli, Antonio Bicchi, Manuel G. Catalano Abstract Intuitively, prostheses with user-controllable stiffness could mimic the intrinsic behavior of the human musculoskeletal system, promoting safe and natural interactions and task adaptability in real-world scenarios. However, prosthetic design often disregards compliance because of the additional complexity, weight, and needed control channels. This paper focuses on designing a Variable Stiffness Actuator (VSA) with weight, size, and performance compatible with prosthetic applications, addressing its implementation for the elbow joint. While a direct biomimetic approach suggests adopting an Agonist-Antagonist (AA) layout to replicate the biceps and triceps brachii with elastic actuation, this solution is not optimal to accommodate the varied morphologies of residual limbs. Instead, we employed the AA layout to craft an elbow prosthesis fully contained in the user’s forearm, catering to individuals with distal transhumeral amputations. Additionally, we introduce a variant of this design where the two motors are split in the upper arm and forearm to distribute mass and volume more evenly along the bionic limb, enhancing comfort for patients with more proximal amputation levels. We characterize and validate our approach, demonstrating that both architectures meet the target requirements for an elbow prosthesis. The system attains the desired 120° range of motion, achieves the target stiffness range of [2, 60] Nm/rad, and can actively lift up to 3 kg. Our novel design reduces weight by up to 50% compared to existing VSAs for elbow prostheses while achieving performance comparable to the state of the art. Case studies suggest that passive and variable compliance could enable robust and safe interactions and task adaptability in the real world. I Introduction Missing a limb profoundly impacts individuals’ physical, emotional, and social well-being. Prosthetic devices seek to address these issues by replicating the natural capabilities and appearance of human limbs. However, current prostheses are still far from achieving the functionality of their natural counterparts and rather focus on restoring users’ auto-sufficiency with rudimental motor capabilities. Most upper limb prosthetic research concentrates on hands as they serve as the primary interface for interacting with the environment. Nevertheless, approximately 21% of upper limb loss occurs above the elbow joint [ 1 ] , underscoring the need to address motor functions at the elbow and wrist levels. The development of mechanical systems replicating human characteristics typically focuses on shape, power, and kinematics, overlooking their behavior during physical interactions. Nevertheless, aligning the impedance of natural and artificial limbs during the design process would achieve robust, safe, and natural interactions within unknown and dynamic environments [ 2 ] . Humans modulate limb impedance through muscular cocontraction, exploiting a compliant behavior to minimize interaction forces in constrained tasks or explore unknown environments while increasing stiffness to accomplish assignments that demand precision or resisting external perturbations [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Therefore, upper limb prostheses should incorporate user-controllable impedance [ 6 ] . (a) (b) Fig. 1: The presented variable stiffness elbow and distinct applications in transhumeral prostheses. (a) The bionic limb on the left adopts the VS-Elbow AA to locate all components below the elbow joint, thus being suitable for distal transhumeral amputations. The prosthesis on the right employs the VS-Elbow D2 to achieve a sparser mass distribution, enhancing user comfort in more proximal transhumeral amputations. Panel (b) highlights the two implementations of the variable stiffness elbow: the VS-Elbow AA on the left and the VS-Elbow D2 on the right. A natural approach to controlling variable impedance prostheses correlates their stiffness with antagonistic muscle cocontraction and motion with the difference in muscular activity measured by the user’s electromyography (EMG) signals [ 6 , 7 ] . A more sophisticated method may be to adopt EMG-driven muscle-tendon models [ 8 ] . Sensinger et al. investigated the applicability of EMG-driven active impedance control of an elbow joint, concluding that users do not deliberately adjust the impedance level during reaching tasks if around a suitable baseline [ 9 ] . More recently, Blank et al. proved that preferred impedance levels are task-dependent [ 5 ] , implying potential benefits for user-modulated impedance in prosthetic limbs and highlighting the need for more effective EMG control strategies. Variable impedance can be implemented in robots actively through software control [ 10 ] or passively by embedding reconfigurable elastic elements in the mechanical design [ 11 ] . However, software impedance regulation requires accurate sensing of the output state and fast actuation and computation, which are unlikely to be achieved in prostheses due to weight and size constraints [ 12 ] . Conversely, passive impedance regulation is intrinsically robust, as the embedded elastic elements inherently absorb shocks and store energy, potentially improving performance in explosive or cyclic tasks and reducing power consumption [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] , [ 17 ] . Nevertheless, this approach leads to more complex mechanisms, requiring an additional actuator to reconfigure the compliant elements and achieve stiffness modulation. Consequently, the resulting increase in size and weight poses challenges in meeting the morphological design requirements of prostheses. Commercial elbow prostheses 1 1 1 Fillauer Utah Arm U3 , 2 2 2 Ottobock Dynamic Arm feature rigid actuation that can be locked to hold external weights, proportionally controlled for active motion, or unlocked to swing freely, minimizing effort in lowering the arm and improving walking performance, by reducing metabolic cost and enhancing gait stability [ 18 ] , [ 19 ] . Even research prototypes conventionally adopt rigid actuation [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , and rarely implement active impedance control [ 9 ] . However, the literature also contains a few examples of employing passive impedance regulation in prosthetic devices, such as ankle-foot [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] , hand [ 26 ] , wrist [ 27 ] , and elbow [ 28 , 29 ] prostheses. In [ 28 ] , the authors present a prosthetic elbow featuring a VSA that varies joint stiffness by modulating the preload of linear springs. However, the first prototype design was bulky and has been optimized in the presented work. In [ 29 ] , Baggetta et al. propose a similar architecture achieving stiffness modulation via 3D-printed torsion springs, whose geometry has been optimized to fit a desired non-linear behavior. However, the tested range of joint stiffness and torque fell substantially below the functional requirements of the human elbow. This manuscript focuses on the design, characterization, and validation of a prosthetic elbow achieving Variable Stiffness (VS) through non-linear and redundant elastic actuation, expanding the work introduced in [ 28 ] . We present a generic approach to the design of VS elbows and two design instances aiming to deliver a prosthesis tailored to accommodate diverse user needs and residual limb morphologies. In addition to [ 28 ] , we present the VS-Elbow AA, a novel hardware designed with an Agonist-Antagonist layout to accommodate lengthy residual limbs. Here, we show its implementation in a complete transhumeral prosthesis that can be fully contained in the user’s forearm. Moreover, we present the VS-Elbow D2, which is a more optimized and compact version of the prototype introduced in [ 28 ] , implementing a distributed

Read the complete text