Macroscopic arrow of time from multiscale perspectives
Mahendra K. Verma · 2024
Read Macroscopic arrow of time from multiscale perspectives by Mahendra K. Verma (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03890.txt.
Introduction
Mahendra Verma reviews why time runs one way in the everyday world when the deep laws of physics do not care. Microscopic equations work the same forward and backward, yet eggs break and never unbreak. His 2024 perspective piece surveys the main frameworks that explain this arrow of time and weighs how they fit together.
Three ideas anchor the review. The second law of thermodynamics states that disorder grows. In driven, draining systems such as turbulence, energy cascades from large scales to small ones, and that one-way flow stamps a direction on events. Open systems, which trade particles and energy with their surroundings, are likewise hard to reverse. Causality, the rule that causes precede effects, adds a further break. Verma argues that the multiscale energy flow, often overlooked, deserves a central place beside the classic entropy story.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mahendra K. Verma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03890
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Macroscopic arrow of time from multiscale perspectives Mahendra K. Verma Abstract Fundamental laws of physics are symmetric under time reversal ( T T ) symmetry, but the T T symmetry is strongly broken in the macroscopic world. In this Perspective, I review T T symmetry breaking frameworks: second law of thermodynamics, multiscale energy transfer , and open systems . In driven dissipative nonequilibrium systems, including turbulence, the multiscale energy flux from large scales to small scales helps determine the arrow of time. In addition, open systems are often irreversible due to particle and energy exchanges between the system and the environment. Causality is another important factor that breaks the T T symmetry. Introduction. – Fundamental laws of classical and quantum physics (except those involving weak nuclear force, which this Perspective ignores) are symmetric under time reversal, denoted by T [ 1 ] . Suppose that x ( t ) represents the classical trajectory of a particle. If we reverse the velocity of the particle at time t_{f} , then, according to T symmetry, the particle will retrace the original trajectory x ( t ). An equivalent way is to film the original motion. If this movie played backward depicts the system evolution with the reversed velocity of the final state, then the system is reversible. Microscopic systems experiencing gravity and electromagnetic forces exhibit the above behaviour. However, macroscopic systems have a definite direction of time [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . For example, a tree grows and then dies; pieces of a broken egg do not come together to form the original egg. This apparent inconsistency of T symmetry at the microscopic and macroscopic scales is called the arrow of time problem [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . The present Perspective deals with this issue. As pointed out by Boltzmann [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 9 , 10 ] , the second law of thermodynamics breaks the T symmetry strongly in macroscopic systems because the entropy of these systems always increase. Note, however, that the second law is rooted in thermodynamics, and it is not clear whether it could be convincingly generalized to more complex systems such as earthquakes [ 11 ] , turbulence [ 12 ] , human body, etc. For turbulent flows, Verma [ 13 ] argued that multiscale energy transfer (or energy flux or energy cascade ) can break T symmetry, or provide an arrow of time. In a three-dimensional (3D) driven turbulence, the energy cascades from large scales to small scales [ 12 ] . In time-reversed movie of the flow, the energy will flow from small scales to large scales, which is absurd. Hence, we can use the energy flux as a diagnostic to determine the arrow of time in turbulence. Similarly, the energy transfers dictate the arrow of time in other driven dissipative systems, e.g., earthquakes, fragmentation, and crack propagation, where the energy flows from large scales to small scales [ 13 ] . Some researchers [ 14 , 15 ] quantified time irreversibility in a turbulent flow using the deviations in the forward and reversed trajectories of Lagrangian particles. The T symmetry is also broken in open systems because of force, energy, and particle exchanges between the system and environment. For example, a periodically-forced oscillator and an electromagnetically-driven molecule are irreversible. Chemical reactions (e.g., combustion), Earth’s atmosphere (driven by the Sun), Earthquakes (driven by plate techtonics), and astrophysical turbulence (driven by supernovas, jets, and winds) are prime examples of irreversible open systems. Causality, an important property of an open system, too breaks T symmetry at the macroscopic level. Note that entropy is not well defined for some open systems, e.g., earthquakes. In addition, many molecular collisions are irreversible due to the complex interactions between the electrons of the atoms [ 16 ] . In this Perspective we briefly describe various frameworks that break T symmetry at macroscopic level. For clarity, brevity, and focus, I avoid discussions on entropies of information and computation [ 17 , 18 ] , black hole entropy [ 19 ] , Landauer’s principle [ 20 ] , and cosmological and psychological arrows of time [ 5 , 6 ] . Second law of thermodynamics. – The second law of thermodynamics is most often employed to break the T symmetry macroscopically [ 2 , 9 , 10 , 5 , 6 ] . Lebowitz [ 4 , 3 ] presents Boltzmann’s arguments as follows. Figure 1 illustrates four snapshots of the gas expansion after the separator between the two halves is opened. The gas particles evolve via the following equations of motion: m{\bf\dot{x}_{\alpha}={p}_{\alpha}} and {\bf\dot{p}}_{\alpha}=-\nabla_{\alpha}\sum_{\beta}V_{\alpha,\beta} , where \alpha,\beta are particle labels; {\bf x}_{\alpha} and {\bf p}_{\alpha} are respectively the position and momentum of particle \alpha ; and V_{\alpha,\beta} is the inter-particle potential between particles \alpha and \beta . All the particles have mass m . \onefigure [height=!, width=7cm]Lebowitz.pdf Figure 1: Successive evolution of the gas confined in the lower half of the box (a) to the equilibrium state (d). Taken from Lebowitz [ 4 ] . Reprinted with permission from Elsevier. A system configuration is represented by a point in the available phase space volume \sum_{\alpha}\int d{\bf p}_{\alpha}d{\bf q}_{\alpha} . Boltzmann [ 2 ] constructs a macrostate by combining nearby configurations, which includes all permutations of particles in a snapshot of Fig. 1 [ 2 , 4 ] . We denote the macrostates corresponding to Fig. 1 (a,b,c,d) using \Gamma_{a} , \Gamma_{b} , \Gamma_{c} , and \Gamma_{d} respectively. Boltzmann derived the entropy of an ideal gas under equilibrium as [ 2 , 9 , 10 ] S={k_{B}\log W}=Nk_{B}\left[\log\frac{V}{N}+\frac{3}{2}\log\frac{4\pi mE}{3Nh^{2}}+\frac{5}{2}\right], (1) where W is the number of microstates; E,N,V are respectively the energy, number of particles, and volume of the system; h,k_{B} are respectively the Planck and Boltzmann constants; and m is the mass of each particle. The above entropy, referred to as the Boltzmann entropy , is same as the thermodynamic entropy proposed by Clausius, and it always increases with time until the system reaches an equilibrium [ 10 ] . A cautionary remark is in order. Equation ( 1 ) applies to an ideal gas under equilibrium, which may not be the case for Fig. 1 (b,c). However, we use the above entropy formula assuming quasi-equilibrium evolution. As argued by Boltzmann [ 2 ] , most configurations of Fig. 1(c) evolve to Fig. 1(d), which is the equilibrium state of the system. This process is called thermalization . Note, however, that a precise time reversal (exact {\bf p}_{\alpha}\to-{\bf p}_{\alpha} ) of a configuration of Fig. 1 (c) will evolve to Fig. 1 (b) and then to Fig. 1 (a). However, this is an atypical event. A small error in the reversed velocity yields a very different result. For this case, a configuration of Fig. 1 (c) will evolve towards Fig. 1 (b) for a short while, and then it turns around and evolves towards Fig. 1 (c) and then to Fig. 1 (d). Chaos theory indicates that a small error in the initial condition can get amplified in a nonlinear system [ 21 ] . This feature plays an important role in the above randomization process [