Unified analysis of phase-field models for cohesive fracture

Jian-Ying Wu · 2024

Read Unified analysis of phase-field models for cohesive fracture by Jian-Ying Wu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03836.txt.

Introduction

Jian-Ying Wu wrote a review from 2024 unifying the phase-field models used to simulate cohesive fracture, where cracks open gradually against a softening grip. The approach smears a sharp crack into a band so computers can track it. Every model in the family is set by three functions: one shapes the crack profile, one degrades the material law, and one defines the driving force. Wu shows how choices among them decide what a model can and cannot do.

A demand is that the band's width never shrink as failure proceeds, or the crack law gets distorted. Older models crack the problem only in a vanishing limit or for one softening curve. The phase-field cohesive zone model largely fixes this with a length-aware degradation rule. With the profile choice, its two variants cover nearly any softening law. Wu clears up misreadings and shows worked examples.

Catalog record

CREATORJian-Ying Wu
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE100 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03836

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unified analysis of phase-field models for cohesive fracture Jian-Ying Wu Abstract Due to the great success achieved in the modeling of brittle fracture, the phase-field approach to cohesive fracture becomes popular. Despite the recent noteworthy contributions, a unified theoretical framework is lacking, imposing difficulty in selecting proper models and for further improvement. To this end, we address in this review unified analysis of phase-field models for cohesive fracture. Aiming to regularize the Barenblatt (1959) cohesive zone model, all the discussed models are distinguished by three characteristic functions, i.e., the geometric function dictating the crack profile, the degradation function for the constitutive relation and the dissipation function defining the crack driving force. The latter two functions coincide in the associated formulation, while in the non-associated one they are designed to be different. Distinct from the counterpart for brittle fracture, in the phase-field model for cohesive fracture the regularization length parameter has to be properly incorporated into the dissipation and/or degradation functions such that the failure strength and traction–separation softening curve are both well-defined. Moreover, the resulting crack bandwidth needs to be non-decreasing during failure in order that imposition of the crack irreversibility condition does not affect the anticipated traction–separation law (TSL). With a truncated degradation function that is proportional to the length parameter, the Conti et al. (2016) model and the latter improved versions can deal with crack nucleation only in the vanishing limit and capture cohesive fracture only with a particular TSL. Owing to a length scale dependent degradation function of rational fraction, these deficiencies are largely overcome in the phase-field cohesive zone model ( PF-CZM ). Among many variants in the literature, only with the optimal geometric function, can the associated PF-CZM apply to general non-concave softening laws and the non-associated PF-CZM to (almost) any arbitrary one. Some mis-interpretations are clarified and representative numerical examples are presented. 1 Introduction Ever since the pioneering work of Francfort and Marigo (1998) , the variational approach to fracture has become very popular in the community of fracture mechanics. Being the numerically more amenable counterpart, the variational phase-field model (PFM) ( Bourdin et al., 2000 ) is one of the most promising tools in capturing fracture induced failure of solids, e.g., crack nucleation, propagation, branching and merging, etc., in a standalone framework; see Bourdin et al. (2008) ; Ambati et al. (2015) ; Wu et al. (2020b) . Motivated by the Ambrosio and Tortorelli (1990) elliptic regularization of the Mumford and Shah (1989) functional, in the variational PFM the sharp crack is geometrically regularized into a localized crack band with the bandwidth measured by a small but finite length scale parameter. The crack surface area can be evaluated through a volume integral in terms of a spatially continuous field variable, i.e., the crack phase-field d(\boldsymbol{x})\in[0,1] , and its spatial gradient \nabla d . With the strain and surface energy functions of the cracking solid properly defined, a set of coupled partial differential equations (PDEs) governing the displacement field and the crack phase-field are derived from either the variational principle ( Bourdin et al., 2008 ) or the irreversible thermodynamics ( Miehe et al., 2010a ) . The resulting PFM is usually characterized by two characteristic functions of the crack phase-field, i.e., the geometric function determining the crack profile and the degradation function defining the strain energy potential ( Wu, 2017 ) . Initially the PFM was applied to linear elastic or brittle fracture ( Griffith, 1921 ) in which the surface energy density (i.e., the energy dissipation per surface area) is treated as a material property — fracture energy. After the great successes achieved in brittle fracture, e.g., the popular models AT2 ( Bourdin et al., 2000 ; Miehe et al., 2010a ) and AT1 ( Pham et al., 2011 ) , research efforts were exerted to regularize the cohesive zone model (CZM) ( Barenblatt, 1959 ) . As the surface energy density function is no longer a constant, one strategy is to quantify explicitly the crack opening ( Bourdin et al., 2008 ) , which is a challenging task in the context of smeared or regularized cracks. Along this direction, Verhoosel and de Borst (2013) introduced an auxiliary field variable, in addition to the displacement field and the crack phase-field, to approximate the crack opening; see also Chen and de Borst (2022) . Nguyen et al. (2016) avoided introducing such an auxiliary field by computing the crack opening at two opposing points at the interface, but the selection of these points is arbitrary and problem-dependent. In such PFMs though the crack opening can be directly evaluated, the crack propagation path has to be known a priori , losing the merit of phase-field models in dealing with arbitrary crack propagation. By means of only the displacement field and the crack phase-field, Conti et al. (2016) ; Conti et al. (2024) proposed a PFM for cohesive fracture. Despite adoption of the same quadratic geometric function as in the AT2 model for brittle fracture ( Bourdin et al., 2000 ; Miehe et al., 2010a ) , an elegant modification is to use a degradation function that is proportional to the phase-field length scale parameter. It was proved that in the 1D scenario the resulting PFM \varGamma -converges to the CZM with a nonlinear softening curve, and the 2D fracture responses were numerically investigated in Freddi and Iurlano (2017) ; Lammen et al. (2023) . Alternatively, Lorentz and coworkers ( Lorentz and Godard, 2011 ; Lorentz et al., 2012 ; Lorentz, 2017 ) proposed a PFM (in the name of gradient damage model or GDM) for cohesive fracture. Though the same linear geometric function is adopted as in the AT1 model for brittle fracture ( Pham et al., 2011 ; Mesgarnejad et al., 2015 ) , the degradation function of rational fraction depends explicitly on the length scale parameter. Application of this model to the 1D problem (usually uniaxial stretching or uniaxial straining) yields a semi-analytical traction–separation (crack opening) law with a particular nonlinear softening curve. Though the crack opening is not evaluate explicitly, the above two PFMs both converge to the Barenblatt (1959) CZM upon a vanishing length scale, at least in the 1D scenario. As the geometric function is identical to that adopted for brittle fracture, this anticipated feature can only be attributed to the degradation function which depends not only on the crack phase-field but also on the incorporated length scale parameter. Importantly, these models are able to deal with arbitrary crack propagation as their counterparts for brittle fracture do. However, they also exhibit the following deficiencies: 1. Firstly, the length-scale dependent degradation function is assumed a priori and inflexible to be adapted for general softening curves. As a consequence, only rather limited traction–separation laws can be captured and the initial slope heavily affecting the fracture behavior cannot be well controlled. For instance, the Conti et al. (2016) model and the Lorentz (2017) model both give particular nonlinear softening curves with finite ultimate crack opening, while the linear and exponential softening commonly adopted for cohesive fracture cannot be reproduced. 2. Secondly and more importantly, the crack irreversibility condition \dot{d}(\boldsymbol{x})\geq 0 was overlooked when seeking the analytical solution or proving the \varGamma -convergence in

Read the complete text