A mathematical language for linking fine-scale structure in spikes from hundreds to thousands of neurons with behaviour
Alexandra N. Busch, Roberto C. Budzinski, Federico W. Pasini, Ján Mináč, Jonathan A. Michaels, Megan Roussy, Roberto A. Gulli, Benjamin W. Corrigan, J. Andrew Pruszynski, Julio Martinez-Trujillo, Lyle E. Muller · 2024
Read A mathematical language for linking fine-scale structure in spikes from hundreds to thousands of neurons with behaviour by Alexandra N. Busch, Roberto C. Budzinski, Federico W. Pasini, Ján Mináč, Jonathan A. Michaels, Megan Roussy, Roberto A. Gulli, Benjamin W. Corrigan, J. Andrew Pruszynski, Julio Martinez-Trujillo, Lyle E. Muller (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03804.txt.
Introduction
Alexandra Busch and co-authors build a mathematical language for neural spike patterns in a 2024 paper. New probes record spikes from hundreds or thousands of neurons at once in awake animals, but describing patterns in that flood, and tying them to behavior, lacks a rigorous tool. Spike counts vary from trial to trial, which breaks standard comparisons.
Their new operation breaks complex spike patterns into simple structured pieces. That gives a clear distance measure between patterns, a way to spot repeating sub-patterns, and a path to link patterns with actions. Applied to recordings from monkey prefrontal cortex during a virtual reality memory task, the method found hidden structure that predicted both the animal's decisions and its errors.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexandra N. Busch, Roberto C. Budzinski, Federico W. Pasini, Ján Mináč, Jonathan A. Michaels, Megan Roussy, Roberto A. Gulli, Benjamin W. Corrigan, J. Andrew Pruszynski, Julio Martinez-Trujillo, Lyle E. Muller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03804
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A mathematical language for linking fine-scale structure in spikes from hundreds to thousands of neurons with behaviour Alexandra N. Busch, Roberto C. Budzinski, Federico W. Pasini, Ján Mináč, Jonathan A. Michaels, Megan Roussy, Roberto A. Gulli, Benjamin W. Corrigan, J. Andrew Pruszynski, Julio Martinez-Trujillo, Lyle E. Muller Abstract Recent advances in neural recording technology allow simultaneously recording action potentials from hundreds to thousands of neurons in awake, behaving animals. However, characterizing spike patterns in the resulting data, and linking these patterns to behaviour, remains a challenging task. The lack of a rigorous mathematical language for variable numbers of events (spikes) emitted by multiple agents (neurons) is an important limiting factor. We introduce a new mathematical operation to decompose complex spike patterns into a set of simple, structured elements. This creates a mathematical language that allows comparing spike patterns across trials, detecting sub-patterns, and making links to behaviour via a clear distance measure. We first demonstrate the method using Neuropixel recordings from macaque motor cortex. We then apply the method to dual Utah array recordings from macaque prefrontal cortex, where this technique reveals previously unseen structure that can predict both memory-guided decisions and errors in a virtual-reality working memory task. These results demonstrate that this technique provides a powerful new approach to understand structure in the spike times of neural populations, at a scale that will continue to grow more and more rapidly in upcoming years. Neurons process sensory inputs, perform computation, and generate motor output via action potentials, or “spikes”. These discrete events are brief one-milisecond electrical impulses that form the basis for communication between neurons in mammalian brains Bear et al. 2020 . Researchers often route an electrode recording directly into a speaker, allowing them to find neurons by hearing spikes as distinct “click” sounds. Neuroscientists have been listening to the “clicks” of single neurons since the 1920s (Fig. 1 a) Adrian and Bronk 1929 . New technologies, however, such as Utah arrays and Neuropixel probes, have rapidly increased the number of neurons that can be recorded simultaneously (Fig. 1 b) Jun et al. 2017 ; Steinmetz et al. 2021 . Recordings from multiple Neuropixel probes now open the possibility to link patterns in the spikes of hundreds — or even thousands — of neurons to sensory processing, motor behaviour, and cognition Steinmetz et al. 2019 ; Durand et al. 2023 . Despite these advances in recording from many neurons, however, it remains unclear how neurons may coordinate their spikes to support sensory, motor, and cognitive computations. Many studies have investigated the temporal evolution of spiking activity across neuronal populations (see for example Riehle et al. 2000 ; Broome et al. 2006 ; Rabinovich et al. 2008 ; Steinemann et al. 2024 ; Mehrotra et al. 2024 ). These works have led to two primary hypotheses: the first posits that a true underlying rate varies meaningfully over time to encode information, and that spikes are stochastic samples of this rate. Many robust methods, such as state-space analysis Srinivasan et al. 2006 , population decoding Quian Quiroga and Panzeri 2009 , and factor analysis Churchland et al. 2012 , enable testing this hypothesis in large-scale spike recordings Stringer and Pachitariu 2024 . The second hypothesis is that meaningful coordination may exist in the spikes across a population of neurons at the level of individual trials. Several studies have investigated this possibility Mainen and Sejnowski 1995 ; Fellous et al. 2004 ; Butts et al. 2007 ; Kayser et al. 2010 ; Mackevicius et al. 2012 ; Xie et al. 2024 , but it remains difficult to systematically analyze spike patterns in large neural populations, and to link these patterns to behaviour. The lack of a rigorous mathematical language for variable numbers of events (spikes) emitted by multiple agents (neurons) is the limiting factor. This methodological gap means that, while it has been possible to test the first hypothesis in large-scale spike recordings, the second hypothesis remains relatively untested. Figure 1: Decomposing large-scale spiking data into structured sub-patterns. (a) Schematic of connected neurons. An action potential travels down the axon to signal connected neurons. (b) Schematic of a Neuropixel probe. (c) Three seconds of spiking data recorded from a Neuropixel probe implanted in the motor cortex of a macaque monkey performing a reaching task. Several repeating, structured sub-patterns are present in this recording. Spikes contributing to two of these sub-patterns are coloured in red and blue respectively. By extending this analysis, the complete spike pattern can be decomposed into structured sub-patterns by determining which spikes align with basis spike-pattern elements. To illustrate the difficulty of addressing the second hypothesis, consider a population of hundreds to thousands of neurons. This population will emit many spikes, with these “clicks” from individual neurons overlapping in complex patterns over time. If a neuroscientist were to play the “clicks” from all these neurons through a speaker, the result would be like listening to a thousand telegraphs sending messages all at once. If the telegraphs encode messages independently, then we have some hope of recovering the encoded messages; however, if messages are interwoven across telegraphs, as would happen if neurons in a population coordinate fine-scale patterns in their spikes, no mathematical method currently exists to detect and quantify structure in this complex series of overlapping events. A tool for breaking down complex spike patterns into simpler elements would make it possible to detect repeating, structured sub-patterns in neural activity, just as we might identify coordinated messages across telegraphs (Fig. 1 c). Such a decomposition could also ask whether fine-scale structure in spike patterns may be related to behaviour and cognition in experimental tasks. The key challenge that has hindered such a method results from the difficulty in adapting the mathematics underlying standard decomposition techniques to discrete spiking data from thousands of neurons. Mathematical decomposition techniques rely on computing the “match” between real-world input data and a set of simpler elements. In general, this “match” is computed by the inner product, a mathematical operation that requires two input vectors to have the same number of entries. However, it is unclear how to compute the inner product between two spike patterns, because neurons fire variable numbers of spikes across trials, resulting in spike patterns of different sizes. To avoid this challenge, it is possible to smooth the spikes from each cell and estimate a continuous firing rate Churchland et al. 2012 ; Williams et al. 2018 ; Mackevicius et al. 2019 , or to limit to a single spike (or burst) from each neuron Gollisch and Meister 2008 ; Yiling et al. 2023 ; Xie et al. 2024 . While these approaches allow computing the inner product with two vectors of the same size, they lose the full temporal resolution of the recording, potentially blurring structure in spikes across cells. Here, we introduce a novel mathematical transformation that solves this fundamental challenge. This transform can be applied to spike patterns from tens of milliseconds to seconds in length, and across thousands of cells, resulting in a mathematically precise description for the fine-scale structure in large-scale spike patterns. This transform provides a natural way to decompose spike patterns into simple, orthogonal elements, which in turn offers a way to detect