Evidence for environmental effects in the z = 4.3 z=4.3 protocluster core SPT2349 − - 56

Chayce Hughes, Ryley Hill, Scott C. Chapman, Manuel Aravena, Melanie Archipley, Veronica J. Dike, Anthony Gonzalez, Thomas R. Greve, Gayathri Gururajan, Chris Hayward, Kedar Phadke, Cassie Reuter, Justin Spilker, Nikolaus Sulzenauer, Joaquin D. Vieira, David Vizgan, George Wang, Axel Weiß, Dazhi Zho · 2024

Read Evidence for environmental effects in the z = 4.3 z=4.3 protocluster core SPT2349 − - 56 by Chayce Hughes, Ryley Hill, Scott C. Chapman, Manuel Aravena, Melanie Archipley, Veronica J. Dike, Anthony Gonzalez, Thomas R. Greve, Gayathri Gururajan, Chris Hayward, Kedar Phadke, Cassie Reuter, Justin Spilker, Nikolaus Sulzenauer, Joaquin D. Vieira, David Vizgan, George Wang, Axel Weiß, Dazhi Zho (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03790.txt.

Introduction

Chayce Hughes and co-authors study young galaxies crowded in a dense early cluster, in work from 2024. The cluster sits so far away that its light dates from when the universe was young. The team watched twenty-five dusty, star-forming galaxies in its core with a radio array in Chile.

They gauged two glow lines from carbon atoms in the galaxies' gas. The line balance in cluster galaxies ran much higher than in lone galaxies of like brightness. That points to hotter, denser gas in the cluster set. The authors read this as a sign that close encounters in the crowd push gas into galaxy cores. Local crowding thus seems to shape how these early galaxies grow.

Catalog record

CREATORChayce Hughes, Ryley Hill, Scott C. Chapman, Manuel Aravena, Melanie Archipley, Veronica J. Dike, Anthony Gonzalez, Thomas R. Greve, Gayathri Gururajan, Chris Hayward, Kedar Phadke, Cassie Reuter, Justin Spilker, Nikolaus Sulzenauer, Joaquin D. Vieira, David Vizgan, George Wang, Axel Weiß, Dazhi Zho
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03790

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence for environmental effects in the z = 4.3 z=4.3 protocluster core SPT2349 − - 56 Chayce Hughes, Ryley Hill, Scott C. Chapman, Manuel Aravena, Melanie Archipley, Veronica J. Dike, Anthony Gonzalez, Thomas R. Greve, Gayathri Gururajan, Chris Hayward, Kedar Phadke, Cassie Reuter, Justin Spilker, Nikolaus Sulzenauer, Joaquin D. Vieira, David Vizgan, George Wang, Axel Weiß, Dazhi Zhou Abstract We present ALMA observations of the [C I ] 492 and 806 GHz fine-structure lines in 25 dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) at z = 4.3 z\,{=}\,4.3 in the core of the SPT2349 − - 56 protocluster. The protocluster galaxies exhibit a median L [ C i ] ​ ( 2 − 1 ) ′ / L [ C i ] ​ ( 1 − 0 ) ′ L^{\prime}_{[\text{C{\sc i}}](2-1)}/L^{\prime}_{[\text{C{\sc i}}](1-0)} ratio of 0.94 with an interquartile range of 0.81–1.24. These ratios are markedly different to those observed in DSFGs in the field (across a comparable redshift and 850 μ \mu m flux density range), where the median is 0.55 with an interquartile range of 0.50–0.76, and we show that this difference is driven by an excess of [C I ](2–1) in the protocluster galaxies for a given 850 μ \mu m flux density. Assuming local thermal equilibrium, we estimate gas excitation temperatures of T ex = 59.1 − 6.8 + 8.1 T_{\rm ex}\,{=}\,59.1^{+8.1}_{-6.8}\, K for our protocluster sample and T ex = 33.9 − 2.2 + 2.4 T_{\rm ex}\,{=}\,33.9^{+2.4}_{-2.2}\, K for the field sample. Our main interpretation of this result is that the protocluster galaxies have had their cold gas driven to their cores via close-by interactions within the dense environment, leading to an overall increase in the average gas density and excitation temperature, and an elevated [C i ](2–1) luminosity-to-far-infrared luminosity ratio. I Introduction In the local Universe, galaxies residing within galaxy clusters are significantly different from their field counterparts [ 17 , 2 , 33 , e.g.,] : cluster galaxies are predominantly red ellipticals that stopped forming stars long ago, while field galaxies are predominantly blue spirals with much higher star-formation rates (SFRs). At high redshift ( z\,{\gtrsim}\,1.5 ), when most galaxy clusters are not yet virialized (a regime in which we call these objects protoclusters), quiescent galaxies are much less common within overdense environments [ 49 , e.g.] . Indeed, some observations suggest that protoclusters are actually in an elevated state of star-formation compared to the field [ 37 , 12 , 44 , e.g.,] , likely driven by mergers and interactions [ 27 , 22 , 3 , e.g.,] . However, the impacts that these processes imprint on protocluster galaxies are not well understood. The difficulty in directly probing environmental effects on protocluster galaxies stems from the fact that at high redshift, the contrast against the field is typically not large, and subtle differences are often impacted by degeneracies and small sample sizes – these include differences in stellar ages [ 51 , 45 , 24 , 55 , e.g.,] , metallicities [ 52 , 34 , 41 , e.g.,] , and resolved distributions of star formation and stellar mass [ 53 , 14 , e.g.,] , but there is no clear consensus on the importance (or existence, in some cases) of these differences. The protocluster SPT2349 - 56 was discovered as a bright point source in the South Pole Telescope (SPT) 2500 deg 2 millimetre-wavelength survey [ 18 ] , and it was later resolved into a collection of {>}\,30 dusty star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) at z\,{=}\,4.3 [ 30 , 20 , 47 , 4 ] . This system therefore presents an opportunity to directly observe how environmental effects arising from cluster formation are imprinted on cluster galaxies. By combining several continuum observations from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), Spitzer , Gemini , and the Hubble Space Telescope ( HST ), it appears that the protocluster galaxies in SPT2349 - 56 are consistent with the galaxy main sequence (i.e. field galaxies) around redshift 4 [ 47 , 21 ] . On the other hand, detections of the CO(4–3) transition (which is approximately proportional to gas mass) provided tentative evidence that the gas depletion timescales (defined as the ratio of gas mass to SFR) in the SPT2349 - 56 protocluster galaxies are shorter than for field galaxies [ 21 ] , but more evidence is needed. While observations of the total CO spectral line energy distribution (SLED) would provide more accurate constraints on the total gas mass, lower J lines (especially J\,{=}\,1 ) typically lack the spatial resolution to resolve many of the sources in the crowded SPT2349 - 56 protocluster. However, Zhou et al. [57] recently showed that observations of the CO(4–3) line towards the SPT2349 - 56 protocluster core from the Atacama Compact Array (ACA) recovered a 75% excess in integrated line strength compared to ALMA observations of the individual galaxies. The low angular resolution of the ACA observations effectively blended all of the protocluster galaxies into a single unresolved sources, meaning that a significant amount of gas (traced by CO(4–3)) must exist as extended emission outside of the individual protocluster galaxies, effectively resolved out by the high angular resolution of ALMA; similar conclusions have been discussed with regard to other protoclusters such as the Distant Red Core (DRC) at z\,{=}\,4.0 [ 36 , 23 ] . In this paper we use the neutral carbon atom ([C i ]) to further probe environmental effects on the properties of the SPT2349 - 56 galaxies. The two neutral atomic carbon fine structure lines ([C i ](1–0), \nu_{\rm rest}\,{=}\, 492.2 GHz, and [C i ](2–1), \nu_{\rm rest}\,{=}\, 809.3 GHz) fall within ALMA’s Bands 3 and 4 at z\,{=}\,4.3 , respectively. Owing to the simple three-level quantum structure of atomic carbon, the ratio of line luminosities can be used to probe the excitation temperature of the [C i ] gas [ 56 , 54 , 8 , 19 , e.g.,] . This offers a simple approach to probe the internal state of protocluster galaxies and field galaxies. Moreover, [C i ] (as an alternative to CO) has been proposed as a tracer of molecular gas [ 56 , 39 , 16 , e.g.,] , allowing for an independent assessment of the gas content in the SPT2349 - 56 sample. Throughout this paper we assume the \Lambda CDM cosmology from Planck Collaboration VI [42] (1 arcsec \,{=}\, 6.9 kpc at z\,{=}\, 4.3). II Data II.1 ALMA observations and data reduction The [C i ](1–0) transition redshifts to 92.9 GHz at z\,{=}\, 4.3, which can be observed by ALMA in Band 3. This transition was observed by the ALMA program 2017.1.00273.S (PI S. Chapman), taken as a two-pointing mosaic targeting all of the known core-component and northern-component protocluster galaxies reported in Hill et al. [20] . The [C i ](2–1) transition redshifts to ALMA’s Band 4 at 152.7 GHz; the core galaxies were observed by ALMA programs 2018.1.00018.S (PI S. Chapman) and 2021.1.01313.S (PI R. Canning), while the northern galaxies were only observed by the latter program. The array configuration used in both Band 4 observing programs were similar and the spectral coverages were configured to be nearly identical. The [C i ](2–1) line is partially blended (depending on the linewidth)

Read the complete text