Evidence of a CP broken deconfined phase in 4D SU(2) Yang-Mills theory at π½ = π \theta=\pi from imaginary π½ \theta simulations
Mitsuaki Hirasawa, Masazumi Honda, Akira Matsumoto, Jun Nishimura, and Atis Yosprakob Β· 2024
Read Evidence of a CP broken deconfined phase in 4D SU(2) Yang-Mills theory at π½ = π \theta=\pi from imaginary π½ \theta simulations by Mitsuaki Hirasawa, Masazumi Honda, Akira Matsumoto, Jun Nishimura, and Atis Yosprakob (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-03683.txt.
Introduction
Mitsuaki Hirasawa and co-authors used computer models in 2024 to study a symmetry question in Yang-Mills theory, the theory behind the strong nuclear force. At a special setting of a setting in the theory, the CP symmetry is expected to break on its own at low heat level. Checking that is blocked by a severe sign problem that ruins models at the real setting.
The team modeled at imaginary values of the setting, where the sign problem disappears, then continued the results mathematically to the real setting. For the two-color case they measured the average topological charge and the heat level where matter deconfines. Their results give evidence that CP symmetry is broken at low heat level and is restored strictly above the deconfining heat level, matching anomaly-based expectations but differing from a large-color forecast.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mitsuaki Hirasawa, Masazumi Honda, Akira Matsumoto, Jun Nishimura, and Atis Yosprakob |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-03683
Browse the full library Β· About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evidence of a CP broken deconfined phase in 4D SU(2) Yang-Mills theory at π½ = π
\theta=\pi from imaginary π½ \theta simulations Mitsuaki Hirasawa, Masazumi Honda, Akira Matsumoto, Jun Nishimura, and Atis Yosprakob Abstract The spontaneous breaking of CP symmetry in 4D SU( N N ) pure Yang-Mills theory at ΞΈ = Ο \theta=\pi has recently attracted much attention in the context of the higher-form symmetry and the βt Hooft anomaly matching condition. Here we use Monte Carlo simulations to study the N = 2 N=2 case, which is interesting since it is the case opposite to the large- N N limit, where explicit calculations are available. In order to circumvent the severe sign problem due to the ΞΈ \theta term for real ΞΈ \theta , we first obtain results at imaginary ΞΈ \theta , where the sign problem is absent, and make an analytic continuation to real ΞΈ \theta . We use the stout smearing in defining the ΞΈ \theta term in the action to be used in our simulations. Thus we obtain the expectation value of the topological charge and the deconfining temperature at ΞΈ = Ο \theta=\pi , and provide evidence that the CP symmetry, which is spontaneously broken at low temperature, gets restored strictly above the deconfining temperature. This conclusion is consistent with the anomaly matching condition and yet differs from the prediction in the large- N N limit. Preprint: YITP-24-166, KEK-TH-2669, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-24, STUPP-24-274 1 Introduction The topological aspect of quantum field theory has been one of the most important subjects in both particle physics and condensed matter physics. In particular, the dynamical effect of the topological \theta term, which is purely non-perturbative, remains elusive due to the notorious sign problem in standard Monte Carlo methods. In condensed matter physics, the \theta parameter has been discussed intensively [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] in 2D O(3) non-linear sigma model, which is known as an effective model of the anti-ferromagnetic spin system. According to Haldaneβs conjecture [ 11 , 12 ] , this model is expected to be in a gapless phase at \theta=\pi , while it is in a gapped phase at \theta=0 . In particle physics, the topological \theta term may appear in 4D SU( N ) Yang-Mills (YM) theory including QCD ( N=3 ), and it breaks CP symmetry in general. However, the experimental upper bound on the neutron electric dipole moment suggests that the \theta parameter is unnaturally small as |\theta|\lesssim 10^{-10} [ 13 , 14 ] , which is a naturalness problem known as the strong-CP problem. There have been many attempts to explain this either phenomenologically [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] or theoretically [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . In fact, 4D SU( N ) YM theory has CP symmetry not only at \theta=0 but also at \theta=\pi due to the 2\pi periodicity in \theta . In particular, the CP symmetry at \theta=\pi is considered to be spontaneously broken at low temperature, while it is known to be unbroken at sufficiently high temperature [ 24 , 25 ] . Renewed interest in this issue has been triggered by recent developments in the higher-form symmetry [ 26 ] and the βt Hooft anomaly matching [ 27 ] , which predict that, at \theta=\pi , either the CP or the \mathbb{Z}_{N} center symmetry should be spontaneously broken unless the theory becomes gapless. Note here that the spontaneous breaking of the \mathbb{Z}_{N} center symmetry corresponds to deconfinement. Therefore the prediction implies that the theory cannot be in a gapped confined phase without breaking the CP symmetry [ 28 , 29 ] . In other words, the anomaly-matching condition claims that T_{\mathrm{CP}}\geq T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\pi)\ , (1.1) where T_{\mathrm{CP}} represents the temperature at which the CP symmetry at \theta=\pi gets restored, and T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\theta) represents the critical temperature of the deconfining transition, which depends on \theta in general. Thus, an interesting question is whether CP restoration coincides with the deconfining transition ( T_{\mathrm{CP}}=T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\pi) ) or not ( T_{\mathrm{CP}}>T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\pi) ) as depicted in the Left and Right panels of figure 1 , respectively. In particular, the second scenario implies the existence of a deconfined phase with spontaneously broken CP symmetry. deconfined confined CP broken T \theta \pi deconfined confined CP broken T \theta \pi Figure 1: Two scenarios for the (\theta,T) -phase diagram of 4D pure SU( N ) Yang-Mills theory consistent with the anomaly matching condition. The blue solid line represents the first-order phase transition associated with the spontaneous breaking of CP symmetry. The orange dotted curve represents the deconfining transition that is believed to be of the first order for N\geq 3 and of the second order for N=2 . The left panel represents the scenario T_{\mathrm{CP}}=T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\pi) , while the right panel represents the scenario T_{\mathrm{CP}}>T_{\mathrm{dec}}(\pi) , which implies the existence of a deconfined phase with spontaneously broken CP symmetry. It is known that the first scenario is realized in the large- N limit [ 30 , 31 ] , where the CP symmetry at \theta=\pi is spontaneously broken at low temperature, and it gets restored precisely at the deconfining temperature, at which the \mathbb{Z}_{N} center symmetry gets spontaneously broken. Given the belief that the deconfining transition is of the first order for N\geq 3 and of the second order for N=2 , it was argued in Ref. [ 28 ] that the first scenario is likely to be realized for N\geq 3 but not necessarily for N=2 . This issue has also been investigated in the SU( N ) supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory (SYM) deformed by the gaugino mass and compactified on S^{1} with periodic boundary conditions [ 32 ] , which flows into the pure (non-supersymmetric) YM theory in the IR limit. Regarding the radius of S^{1} as an analog of the inverse temperature, it was found that the phase diagram looks like figure 1 (Left) for N\geq 3 , whereas for N=2 , it looks like figure 1 (Right), namely, there exists a CP-broken deconfined phase 1 1 1 It was pointed out [ 33 ] that this intermediate phase is analogous to the partially deconfined phase in large- N gauge theories, where the transition from the completely deconfined phase to the partially deconfined phase should be accompanied with the spontaneous breaking of the global symmetry, which is the CP symmetry in the present case. . One should keep in mind, however, that the gaugino mass has to be small enough to make the analysis based on supersymmetry reliable. Note also that the radius of S^{1} with periodic boundary conditions cannot be regarded as the inverse temperature, which actually requires anti-periodic boundary conditions for the gaugino field. Thus there is a strong motivation to investigate the phase diagram of 4D SU( N ) pure YM theory with small N directly by numerical methods. There are various approaches that have been proposed to overcome the sign problem caused by the \theta term. In particular, the so-called subvolume method was applied to 4D SU(2) YM theory, where it was suggested that the CP symmetry at \theta=\pi is broken at zero temperature and