Dark Galactic subhalos and the Gaia snail
Daniel Gilman, Jo Bovy, Neige Frankel, Andrew Benson · 2024
Read Dark Galactic subhalos and the Gaia snail by Daniel Gilman, Jo Bovy, Neige Frankel, Andrew Benson (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02757.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Gilman and co-authors test whether dark clumps in our galaxy made the snail swirl seen in star data. The work dates to 2024. A space eye showed a clear spiral in the up-down spread of stars near the Sun. Bright mate galaxies can stir such swirls, but dark clumps are far more in count.
The team built a chance model for clump paths and a fast way to read disk response. They also model how star hits blur old swirls with time. Dark clumps alone stir too weak a swirl to match the one seen. Still, they should leave small speed waves near the disk mid plane to this day.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Gilman, Jo Bovy, Neige Frankel, Andrew Benson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Dark Galactic subhalos and the Gaia snail Daniel Gilman, Jo Bovy, Neige Frankel, Andrew Benson Abstract Gaia has revealed a clear signal of disequilibrium in the solar neighborhood in the form of a spiral (or snail) feature in the vertical phase-space distribution. We investigate the possibility that this structure emerges from ongoing perturbations by dark ( 10 6 M ⊙ − 10 8 M ⊙ ) \left(10^{6}M_{\odot}-10^{8}M_{\odot}\right) Galactic subhalos. We develop a probabilistic model for generating subhalo orbits based on a semianalytic model of structure formation, and combine this framework with an approximate prescription for calculating the response of the disk to external perturbations. We also develop a phenomenological treatment for the diffusion of phase-space spirals caused by gravitational scattering between stars and giant molecular clouds, a process that erases the kinematic signatures of old ( t ≳ 0.6 t\gtrsim 0.6 Gyr) events. Perturbations caused by dark subhalos are, on average, orders of magnitude weaker than those caused by luminous satellite galaxies, but the ubiquity of dark halos predicted by cold dark matter makes them a more probable source of strong perturbation to the dynamics of the solar neighborhood. Dark subhalos alone do not cause enough disturbance to explain the Gaia snail, but they excite fluctuations of ∼ 0.1 − 0.5 km s − 1 \sim 0.1-0.5\ \rm{km}\ \rm{s^{-1}} in the mean vertical velocity of stars near the Galactic midplane that should persist to the present day. Subhalos also produce correlations between vertical frequency and orbital angle that could be mistaken as originating from a single past disturbance. Our results motivate investigation of the Milky Way’s dark satellites by characterizing their kinematic signatures in phase-space spirals across the Galaxy. I Introduction The Gaia mission has revolutionized research in Galactic dynamics through precise kinematic measurements of a billion stars [ 31 ] . The exquisite data obtained through this survey [ 32 , 33 , e.g.] reveals in unprecedented detail an unexpected phenomenon discovered by Widrow et al. [80] : the distribution function of stars in the solar neighborhood, the portion of the Milky Way \sim 8\ \rm{kpc} from the Galactic center and confined to |z|\lesssim 2\ \rm{kpc} away from the Galactic midplane, exhibits clear deviations from dynamic equilibrium. Correlations between the vertical velocity and height above the Galactic midplane manifest as a prominent spiral in the vertical ( z -direction) phase-space distribution [ 2 , 9 ] . The phase-space spiral detected by Gaia, sometimes referred to as the Gaia snail, reflects the response of the Galactic disk to one or several perturbations to the dynamics of the solar neighborhood. The evolution of a perturbation into a spiral pattern in the distribution function occurs as a result of phase mixing [ 73 , e.g.] : because the frequency of vertical oscillations near the Galactic midplane changes with height, over time an initial displacement of test particles (stars) from their equilibrium trajectories winds into a spiral. The properties of emergent spirals depend on the gravitational potential of the Galactic disk, which determines how quickly an initial perturbation becomes sheared and distorted [ 80 , 78 , 8 , 7 , e.g.] . The properties of phase spirals also depend on the source of the perturbation. Due to its close passage to the solar neighborhood in the past gigayear, the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy, or a massive satellite with similar properties, was regarded as the most probable culprit for the dynamic perturbation that spawned the Gaia snail [ 38 , 56 , 57 , 17 , 10 , 11 ] . However, further investigation revealed problems with this hypothesis. Although Sagittarius appears to cause a detectable perturbation, models that include only Sagittarius struggle to explain the amplitude of the perturbation measured by Gaia, even when assuming it has retained most of its mass since accretion onto the Milky Way. Assuming a single event caused the perturbation, it is possible to unwind the snail to determine when the perturbation occurred [ 16 , 17 , 79 , 34 , 24 , e.g.,] . However, the Gaia snail defies association with a single dynamic perturbation time, and instead suggests multiple events occurred over the past \sim 0.5\ \rm{Gyr} [ 29 , 1 ] . The snail exhibits various other complex features, such as correlations between perturbation strength, timing, and angular momentum, suggesting that an interplay between numerous factors contribute to the observed phenomenon [ 16 , 59 , 45 , 34 , 29 , 60 , 39 , 46 , 30 ] . We note, however, that [ 24 ] show that a single perturbation can produce a complex signal when accounting for the 3D configuration of the system. The transition from a single-arm to doubled-armed spiral seen in the Gaia data is similarly difficult to explain if one assumes a single event caused the snail [ 45 ] . Various other sources of perturbation, such as the Galactic bar or the Galaxy’s spiral arms [ 62 , 44 , 53 ] , could contribute to the out-of-equilibrium properties of the local phase space, although, considered individually, they struggle to explain all aspects of the data. As shown by Tremaine et al. [74] , an ensemble of small perturbations, rather than one large perturbation, can also give rise to coherent phase spirals. Cold dark matter (CDM) provides a source of these small perturbations in the form of dark-matter subhalos. According to CDM, most galaxies reside inside of halos with masses at infall \gtrsim 10^{8}M_{\odot} . Below 10^{8}M_{\odot} , the fraction of halos that retain enough stars to form a detectable galaxy plummets toward zero [ 64 , e.g.] . The abundance of halos scales approximately as the inverse of the halo mass. Since at least one halo, the host of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy, has come close enough to the solar neighborhood to affect the vertical dynamics, many more lower-mass halos could have passed in even closer proximity. Therefore, the question is not whether these more ubiquitous low-mass halos can cause perturbations to the Gaia snail, but how this signal manifests, and whether it is detectable. The idea that the Milky Way satellite population could affect the properties of galactic disks has existed since long before Gaia launched into space [ 69 , e.g.] . However, most analyses consider their effects on larger scales than those relevant for understanding the detailed properties of the Gaia snail, and only consider the impact of the most-massive perturbers, objects which should host detectable galaxies. For example, Kazantzidis et al. [52] performed N-body simulations of \sim 10^{10}M_{\odot} objects interacting with a stellar disk, and identified several morphological features across the disk that form as a result of these interactions. Moetazedian & Just [61] showed that the vertical heating across the Milky Way’s disk is dominated by the most-massive subhalos, a result confirmed by Grand et al. [40] . García-Conde et al. [35] performed high-resolution simulations of the Galactic disk evolving in the presence of several sources of perturbation, including subhalos, and identified correlations between breathing and bending modes in the disk and the passage of suhbalos. Their results were consistent with the analysis presented by Chequers et al. [22] , who found that substructure can