Gravitational-Wave Signatures of Nonstandard Neutrino Properties in Collapsing Stellar Cores

Jakob Ehring, Sajad Abbar, Hans-Thomas Janka, Georg Raffelt, Ko Nakamura, Kei Kotake · 2024

Read Gravitational-Wave Signatures of Nonstandard Neutrino Properties in Collapsing Stellar Cores by Jakob Ehring, Sajad Abbar, Hans-Thomas Janka, Georg Raffelt, Ko Nakamura, Kei Kotake (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02750.txt.

Introduction

Jakob Ehring and co-authors propose a new way to hunt for unusual neutrino behavior inside collapsing stars. Their 2024 paper notes that extra flavor swapping, driven by physics beyond the standard model, could stir the newborn neutron star far more strongly. Stronger churning there would shake spacetime harder right after the core bounces.

That shaking would produce loud gravitational waves across a wide band of frequencies, during a phase that is normally quiet. A detected signal of that kind would point to nonstandard neutrino traits that lab tests struggle to reach. The authors frame the plan as multi-messenger astronomy: gravitational waves plus the usual light and particles from a supernova, read together.

Catalog record

CREATORJakob Ehring, Sajad Abbar, Hans-Thomas Janka, Georg Raffelt, Ko Nakamura, Kei Kotake
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02750

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational-Wave Signatures of Nonstandard Neutrino Properties in Collapsing Stellar Cores Jakob Ehring, Sajad Abbar, Hans-Thomas Janka, Georg Raffelt, Ko Nakamura, Kei Kotake Abstract We present a novel multi-messenger approach for probing nonstandard neutrino properties through the detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from collapsing stellar cores and associated supernova explosions. We show that neutrino flavor conversion inside the proto-neutron star (PNS), motivated by physics Beyond the Standard Model (BSM), can significantly boost PNS convection. This effect leads to large-amplitude GW emission over a wide frequency range during an otherwise relatively quiescent GW phase shortly after core bounce. Such a signal provides a promising new avenue for exploring nonstandard neutrino phenomena and other BSM physics impacting PNS convection. Introduction. —Since their first detection on September 14, 2015, by the LIGO and Virgo collaborations LIGOScientific:2016aoc , GWs from compact objects have become crucial tools for probing new physics under extreme conditions Bauswein+2010 ; Yunes:2013dva ; Orsaria+2019 ; Tsang+2019 ; Andersson2019 ; Weih+2020 ; Bauswein+2020 . In this Letter , we demonstrate that GWs produced by collapsing stellar cores and associated supernova (SN) explosions can serve as powerful probes of new physics that influences convection within the hot PNS, with a particular focus on nonstandard neutrino properties. In the cores of collapsing stars, asymmetric motions of large masses with high velocities leave an imprint on spacetime in the form of GWs. While such signals from SNe have yet to be observed, neutrino-hydrodynamic simulations predict several contributions. In nonrotating progenitors, an initial GW burst arises from “prompt” convection behind the decelerating SN shock shortly after bounce, caused by a negative entropy gradient. This activity calms down after a few 10 ms, followed by a generic phase (around 100 ms) of fairly low GW emission. Subsequently, violent mass motions connected to hydrodynamic instabilities in the neutrino-heated postshock layer and PNS oscillations, stimulated either by mass downflows from outside or by convection inside the PNS, become the primary sources. Later, GWs also come from long-lasting PNS convection, accretion of fallback mass, and the asymmetric morphology of expanding explosion ejecta and emitted neutrinos, both leading to a long-term GW strain or “memory” Braginsky+1987 ; Christodoulou1991 ; Favata2010 . In rotating, collapsing stellar cores, additional sources include the core deformation at bounce, causing different characteristic burst signals, triaxial hydrodynamic (spiral and bar-mode) and magneto-hydrodynamic instabilities, and mass ejection in polar jets (see Ott2009 ; Kotake2013 ; KotakeKuroda2017_Handbook ; Kalogera+2021 ; Abdikamalov+2022 ; Arimoto+2023 ; Mezzacappa+2024 for reviews). Neutrino flavor conversion (FC) in the SN environment introduces a major uncertainty in current SN modeling. The high neutrino densities lead to complex, nonlinear, collective FC scenarios that can spawn a range of intriguing phenomena Pastor:2002we ; Duan:2006an ; Duan:2010bg ; Chakraborty:2016yeg ; Volpe:2023met . Despite growing evidence of their relevance for SN dynamics, FC has been ignored in most simulations. It is only recently that multi-dimensional neutrino-hydrodynamic SN simulations have started to include schematic implementations Ehring2023a ; Ehring2023b ; Nagakura:2022kic . Specifically, the phenomenon of fast FC (FFC) was considered, where FC might occur on much smaller scales than other phenomena in the SN core. These studies indicate that FCs can both support or suppress neutrino-driven explosions, depending on the progenitor and the FC region Ehring2023b . However, FFCs thus explored Ehring2023a ; Ehring2023b are not expected inside the PNS, at least not during the first few 100 ms after bounce Glas2020a ; Abbar:2019zoq ; Nagakura:2021hyb . On the other hand, BSM neutrino properties provide several mechanisms for generic FC within the PNS. For instance, nonstandard neutrino self-interactions ( \nu NSSI) Bialynicka-Birula:1964ddi ; Bardin:1970wq ; Berryman:2022hds can lead to neutrino flavor equipartition inside the PNS Abbar:2022jdm . Likewise, BSM magnetic transition moments for Majorana neutrinos can also cause some sort of equipartition between neutrinos and antineutrinos if there are strong magnetic fields inside the PNS Abbar:2020ggq ; Kharlanov:2020cti ; Sasaki:2021bvu . Such an equipartition could significantly impact the thermodynamics of SNe Suliga:2024oby . Here we show that FC inside the PNS, at densities above a few 10^{12} g cm -3 , visibly intensifies the GW signal shortly after bounce, during the otherwise relatively GW-quiescent phase. This enhancement arises from strong, localized heating caused by the conversions of \nu_{x} and \bar{\nu}_{x} (x=\mu,\tau) to \nu_{e} and \bar{\nu}_{e} , which are immediately absorbed in the medium. This increased heating leads to strong convective activity, which in turn can excite hydrodynamic gravity modes (g-modes) near the PNS surface, resulting in strong GW emission. This effect is schematically illustrated in Fig. 1 . Simulation Setup and GW Analysis. —The considered simulations were discussed in Ref. Ehring2023b . They were conducted with the neutrino-hydrodynamics code Alcar Just2015a ; Just2018a , assuming axial symmetry (2D). Alcar is a state-of-the-art, Eulerian, conservative, higher-order Godunov-type finite-volume solver designed for both 1D and multi-D nonrelativistic fluid dynamics, coupled with a two-moment scheme to treat energy-dependent, three-flavor neutrino transport. General relativistic corrections for gravity and transport are included. The key features of the code and the implementation details of the neutrino FCs are described in Ref. Ehring2023a . Figure 1: FC of high-energy \nu_{x} and \bar{\nu}_{x} create \nu_{e} and \bar{\nu}_{e} in the PNS interior, an effect assumed to occur at the black dashed circle. If this happens well inside the average electron-type neutrinosphere, the newly created \nu_{e} and \bar{\nu}_{e} are quickly absorbed by free nucleons. This strong local heating (bright orange layer) enhances PNS convection (orange layer). The convective shell as well as g-mode activity (so-called gravity waves, not to be confused with gravitational waves) instigated in the convectively stable near-surface layer emit GWs. The FC implementation in Refs. Ehring2023a ; Ehring2023b was motivated by FFCs, but the parametric representation can be interpreted in terms of any BSM physics that would cause similar effects. The following recipe was used: (1) We assume that pairwise \nu\bar{\nu} FCs are “instantaneous,” meaning that they take place over spatial scales much smaller than the numerical grid cells and over time scales much shorter than the computational time steps Xiong:2024pue . This description may also be reasonable for BSM-induced FCs, where the scales are governed, for example, by the BSM neutrino interaction potential or the magnetic field strength Abbar:2022jdm ; Abbar:2020ggq ; Kharlanov:2020cti ; Sasaki:2021bvu . (2) We assume that the FCs result in flavor equilibrium under the constraint that lepton number is individually conserved for each flavor, particularly for electron-type neutrinos. BSM physics could violate this restriction, potentially allowing for full flavor equilibration, meaning that our more limited assumption is conservative. (3) Our FC treatment conserves total energy and momentum, while respecting the Pauli exclusion principle. (4) We activate FCs throughout the region where the matter density \rho is below a chosen threshold value, \rho_{\mathrm{c}} . The simulations were initially evolved in 1D until core bounce and then mapped onto a 2D polar coordinate grid with 640 logarithmically spaced radial zones and 90 equally spaced angular zones. The central core of 2 km was kept 1D, thus permitting larger time steps without significant effects on the hydrodynamic evolution. To initiate nonradial instabilities, which otherwise arise only from uncontrolled numerical noise, we perturbed the local density in every cell of the computational grid during the mapping with a random amplitude of up to 0.1 %. We selected

Read the complete text