Revisiting Lipid Nanoparticle Composition and Structure: A Critical Take on Simulation Approaches
Marius F.W. Trollmann, Paolo Rossetti, Rainer A. Böckmann · 2024
Read Revisiting Lipid Nanoparticle Composition and Structure: A Critical Take on Simulation Approaches by Marius F.W. Trollmann, Paolo Rossetti, Rainer A. Böckmann (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02731.txt.
Introduction
Marius Trollmann, Paolo Rossetti, and Rainer Böckmann wrote a short comment in 2024 on a study of tiny fat based carriers that hold RNA. The comment takes a close look at how computer models were used in that study to picture what the carriers look like inside. It questions some of the choices made in those model runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marius F.W. Trollmann, Paolo Rossetti, Rainer A. Böckmann |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 4 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02731
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting Lipid Nanoparticle Composition and Structure: A Critical Take on Simulation Approaches
Marius F.W. Trollmann, Paolo Rossetti, Rainer A. Böckmann
Abstract
†
†
equal-contributors:
These authors contributed equally to this work.
The impact of pH on the structural organization of lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) has been well-documented, with both all-atom and coarse-grained simulations revealing a pH-dependent phase transition
Trollmann2022-aw
;
Philipp2023-hq
;
Paloncyova2023-kv
;
Ramezanpour2019-yx
. Specifically, at low pH (where aminolipids are fully protonated), LNP-mimetic systems exhibit a lipid bilayer phase, while at high pH, they transition to an LNP-like structure (Fig.
1
). This structure comprises a hydrophobic core primarily made up of aminolipids and cholesterol, surrounded by a monolayer of helper lipids (e.g., DSPC and PEGylated lipids), cholesterol, and a few aminolipids
Trollmann2022-aw
;
Paloncyova2023-kv
;
Yanez-Arteta2018-am
;
Kjolbye2024-cq
.
Figure 1:
Equilibrated LNP formulations at low and high pH
Trollmann2022-aw
. At low pH, the protonated aminolipids from, together with the helper lipids, a lipid bilayer. Upon increase in pH, here a deprotonation of the aminolipids, a phase transition occurs that is characterized by a drastic decrease of the lateral membrane area and the formation of a hydrophobic core. This transition is artificially blocked for simulations within the
NP_{z}T
ensemble
Garaizar2024-ts
.
A recent study published in PNAS
Garaizar2024-ts
challenges this understanding by employing
direct coexistence
(DC) simulations. Rather than simulating complete LNPs, the authors modeled smaller cross-sectional systems with a hydrophobic core sandwiched between lipid monolayers in an aqueous environment — an approach similar to previous studies
Ramezanpour2019-yx
;
Trollmann2022-aw
;
Kjolbye2024-cq
. However, unlike prior results, these DC simulations indicated minimal structural changes between neutral and acidic pH (see Fig. 5 of
Garaizar2024-ts
), with protonated lipids remaining uniformly distributed within the core (as shown in Fig. 2B of
Garaizar2024-ts
), leading to charge densities of approximately 0.4-0.5 e
{}_{\text{o}}
/nm
3
. This charge distribution implies a significant electrostatic energy of approximately
10^{11}\dots 10^{13}
kJ/mol for LNPs of 100-200 nm in size (as in the LNP1 and LNP2 systems described in
Garaizar2024-ts
, dielectric constant
\epsilon_{r}\approx 10
assumed). This level of energy is roughly 20–140 times the equivalent of TNT.
Such a charge distribution seems improbable and may stem from the chosen simulation ensemble. By fixing the monolayer area while coupling only the
z
-direction (normal to the surface) to environmental pressure (
NP_{z}T
ensemble), the study’s setup restricts the system’s ability to undergo structural modifications that would naturally arise from the protonation of all aminolipids (from a core-monolayer phase to a lipid bilayer) or from changes in LNP formulation. This constraint likely hinders an unbiased exploration of the LNP core-shell architecture and establishes an energetic barrier that inhibits RNA escape under neutral pH conditions, a phenomenon suggested from previous unbiased simulations
Trollmann2022-aw
;
Paloncyova2023-kv
. Moreover, differences observed between the two LNP formulations, such as DSPC-water micellar structures below the LNP surface, seem predetermined by the systemic bias introduced by this setup and highly sensitive to system configuration. Therefore, the simulations by Garaizar
et al.
Garaizar2024-ts