Geometric bound on structure factor
Yugo Onishi, Alexander Avdoshkin, Liang Fu · 2024
Read Geometric bound on structure factor by Yugo Onishi, Alexander Avdoshkin, Liang Fu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02656.txt.
Introduction
Yugo Onishi and co-authors present a 2024 result in the physics of solids. They study the structure factor, a value that shows how the parts of a solid are spread out. At small momentum, one term of this value turns out to have a strict upper bound. The bound comes from a shape based object tied to how electron states twist through momentum space.
Bands of electron states that reach the bound obey a rule much like Laplace's equation. The authors call these harmonic bands. They give cases in one and two dimensions, including Landau levels. A second bound, of a topological kind, also follows. Both bounds together may help spot special bands. Such bands could favor rare states called fractional Chern insulators.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yugo Onishi, Alexander Avdoshkin, Liang Fu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02656
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Geometric bound on structure factor Yugo Onishi, Alexander Avdoshkin, Liang Fu Abstract We show that a quadratic form of quantum geometric tensor in k k -space sets a bound on the q 4 q^{4} term in the static structure factor S ( q ) S(q) at small 𝒒 {\bf\it q} . Bands that saturate this bound satisfy a condition similar to Laplace’s equation, leading us to refer to them as harmonic bands . We provide examples of harmonic bands in one- and two-dimensional systems, including (higher) Landau levels. The geometric bound further leads to a topological bound on the q 4 q^{4} term, which is saturated only when the band geometry satisfies the trace condition and, additionally, the quantum geometric tensor is uniform in k k -space. We speculate that these bounds taken together provide a useful guide for identifying Chern bands that favor (Abelian or non-Abelian) fractional Chern insulators. Introduction. — The static structure factor is an important physical observable that characterizes density correlations in ground states of electronic systems. While the Bragg peaks in the structure factor have been used to identify periodic crystal structures and charge density wave orders, the structure factor away from reciprocal lattice vectors also encodes rich information about the electronic structure and physical responses of the system. For example, the structure factor is related to the density responses through the fluctuation-dissipation theorem [ 1 ] . In interacting systems, it determines the interaction energy of the ground state, and also offers a way to estimate the excitation energy, as shown by Feynman for liquid Helium systems [ 2 ] . A related approach based on the projected structure factor was developed to study the collective modes in fractional quantum Hall systems [ 3 ] . Recently, an exact general relation between the structure factor and the many-body quantum geometry was established [ 4 ] , enabling direct measurement of the ground state quantum geometry via X-ray scattering and electron loss spectroscopy [ 5 ] . Specifically, for insulating states in reduced dimensions or with short-range interaction, the static structure factor at leading order in the wavevector q is directly related to the many-body quantum metric. The many-body quantum metric is also closely related to polarization fluctuation [ 6 ] , localization of electron wavefunction [ 7 ] , the spread of Wannier functions [ 8 ] , and the Bloch band geometry in noninteracting band insulators. Furthermore, this geometric perspective naturally leads to universal bounds on physical observables in topological phases [ 9 , 4 , 10 , 11 ] . In this work, we explore the relation between quantum geometry and the static structure factor S({\bf\it q}) of band insulators beyond the leading order in q . Specifically, we show that the isotropic part of S({\bf\it q}) at fourth order in q (denoted as S_{4} ) has a universal bound determined by the quadratic form of the quantum geometric tensor. This establishes a connection between the structure factor and fluctuations of quantum geometric tensor in k -space. Interestingly, we find that this geometric bound is saturated when the band geometry satisfies a certain “harmonic” condition. Examples of harmonic bands in one- and two-dimensional systems, including higher Landau levels, are provided. This geometric bound allows us to derive a topological bound on S_{4} . This bound is saturated only when the band geometry satisfies the trace condition [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] and is uniform in k -space. Our geometric and topological bounds on S_{4} offer a useful guide for identifying Chern bands that are promising for hosting fractional Chern insulators, including non-Abelian ones. In this work, we define the static structure factor as the following equal-time density-density correlation function: \displaystyle S({\bf\it q}) \displaystyle\equiv\frac{1}{N_{e}}\expectationvalue{{n}_{\vec{q}}{n}_{-\vec{q}}} (1) where {n}_{{\bf\it q}}=\int\differential{r}e^{-i{\bf\it q}\dotproduct{\bf\it r}}n({\bf\it r}) is the number density operator at wavevector {\bf\it q} , and N_{e} is the total number of electrons. In tight-binding models, n_{{\bf\it q}} is defined as n_{{\bf\it q}}=\sum_{i}e^{-i{\bf\it q}\dotproduct{\bf\it r}_{i}} with {\bf\it r}_{i} the position of site i . With this convention, S({\bf\it q}=0)=N_{e} . Note that this normalization differs from that used in Refs. [ 9 , 4 ] . Atomic insulators. — To gain intuition about the structure factor of band insulators at small q , let us start with a simple example of an array of atoms forming a d -dimensional cubic lattice. When the lattice constant a is large enough, we can neglect the hopping between the atoms and the system is an atomic insulator. Its energy eigenstates are given by the localized orbitals of individual atoms, denoted as \phi_{n}({\bf\it r}-{\bf\it R}) , with {\bf\it R} the position of an atom and n the label for each atomic orbital. When each atom has one electron occupying n=0 orbital, the structure factor at {\bf\it q} away from the reciprocal lattice vectors is given by (see SM for the derivation) \displaystyle S({\bf\it q}) \displaystyle=1-\absolutevalue{\expval{e^{-i\vec{q}\vdot\vec{r}}}_0}^{2} (2) where \expectationvalue{\dots}_{0}=\int\differential{r}(\dots)\absolutevalue{\phi_0(\vec{r})}^{2} is the expectation value in n=0 orbital. The quantity \expectationvalue{e^{-i\vec{q}\vdot\vec{r}}}_{0} contains all the moments of {\bf\it r} for the probability distribution p({\bf\it r})=\absolutevalue{\phi_0(\vec{r})}^{2} . Thus, the structure factor completely captures electron density distribution within an atom. At small {\bf\it q} , we expand S({\bf\it q}) in {\bf\it q} and obtain \displaystyle S({\bf\it q}) \displaystyle=\expectationvalue{(\vec{q}\vdot\vec{r})^2}_{0}-\frac{2}{4!}\quantity(\expval{(\vec{q}\vdot\vec{r})^4}_0 + 3\expval{(\vec{q}\vdot\vec{r})^2}_0^2)+\dots \displaystyle=K_{\alpha\beta}\frac{\bar{q}_{\alpha}\bar{q}_{\beta}}{2\pi}+\dots, (3) where \bar{q}_{\alpha}=q_{\alpha}a is the dimensionless wavevector. Here, we have chosen the origin such that \expectationvalue{\vec{r}}_{0}=0 , and K is a rank-2 tensor given by \displaystyle K_{\alpha\beta} \displaystyle=2\pi\frac{\expectationvalue{r_{\alpha}r_{\beta}}_{0}}{a^{2}}, (4) which represents the position fluctuation of an electron within the atom. Although q^{4} term is more complicated, its isotropic component is fairly simple. We define the isotropic component of S({\bf\it q}) as \bar{S}(q)=\int_{\absolutevalue{\vec{q}}=q}\differential{\Omega}S({\bf\it q})/A_{d} , where d is the spatial dimension, \int\differential\Omega is integration over solid angle, and A_{d} is the total solid angle in d -dimensions. We expand \bar{S}(q) in q as \displaystyle\bar{S}(q) \displaystyle=\frac{S_{2}}{2!}\frac{\bar{q}^{2}}{2\pi}-\frac{S_{4}}{4!}\quantity(\frac{\bar{q}^2}{2\pi})^{2}+\dots, (5) where S_{2} and S_{4} are given by \displaystyle S_{2} \displaystyle=\frac{4\pi}{da^{2}}\expectationvalue{r^2}_{0}=\frac{2}{d}\tr K, (6) \displaystyle S_{4} \displaystyle=\frac{12}{d(d+2)}\quantity((\tr K)^2 + \tr(K^2)) \displaystyle\quad+\frac{6(2\pi)^{2}}{d(d+2)a^{4}}\expectationvalue{(r^2-\expval{r^2})^2}_{0}. (7) Here and hereafter, \tr represents the sum over the spatial indices x,y,\dots . In probability theory, the fourth moment, such as \expectationvalue{x^4} , is referred to as kurtosis (up to appropriate normalization), thus we shall call S_{4} kurtosis from now on. Since the last term in S_{4} is semi-positive, we see a lower bound on S_{4} determined solely by the quadratic coefficients of structure factor, K : \displaystyle S_{4}\geq\frac{12}{d(d+2)}\quantity((\tr K)^2 + \tr(K^2)). (8) Notably, the bound on S_{4} is set by the square of K . Since K is related to quantum metric [ 20 ] , this observation suggests a relation between S_{4} and the quadratic form of quantum geometry. In the rest of this work, we will present a generalization of Eq. ( 8 ) that applies to all band insulators. That is, the isotropic part of S(q) at q^{4} order has a lower bound given by the quadratic form of quantum geometry in k -space, involving both the quantum metric and Berry curvature. General theory. — Consider a d -dimensional non-interacting band insulator. The static structure factor at finite small {\bf\it q} is given by [ 4 ] \displaystyle S({\bf\it q}) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\nu}\int[dk]\Tr[P({\bf\it k})(P({\bf\it k})-P({\bf\it k}+{\bf\it