Simple and Effective Portfolio Construction with Crypto Assets

Kasper Johansson, Stephen Boyd · 2024

Read Simple and Effective Portfolio Construction with Crypto Assets by Kasper Johansson, Stephen Boyd (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02654.txt.

Introduction

Adding crypto coins to a stock and bond portfolio need not be complex, Kasper Johansson and Stephen Boyd argue in a 2024 paper. Crypto assets swing wildly and break the neat bell curves of classic theory. Still, a simple extension of standard risk spreading gives sturdy mixes, they show.

An even simpler rule emerges from their tests: hold a fixed crypto share beside standard assets, and dilute with cash to hit a target risk level. The echo of the classic sixty-forty stock-bond split is deliberate. Risk habits of the mix stay steady across market moods in their checks. Investors gain a plain recipe for a small crypto sleeve without exotic math or constant rebalancing.

Catalog record

CREATORKasper Johansson, Stephen Boyd
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02654

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simple and Effective Portfolio Construction with Crypto Assets Kasper Johansson, Stephen Boyd Abstract We consider the problem of constructing a portfolio that combines traditional financial assets with crypto assets. We show that despite the documented attributes of crypto assets, such as high volatility, heavy tails, excess kurtosis, and skewness, a simple extension of traditional risk allocation provides robust solutions for integrating these emerging assets into broader investment strategies. Examination of the risk allocation holdings suggests an even simpler method, analogous to the traditional 60/40 stocks/bonds allocation, involving a fixed allocation to crypto and traditional assets, dynamically diluted with cash to achieve a target risk level. 1 Introduction Since the introduction of cryptocurrencies in 2009 [ Nak08 ] , the field of crypto trading has rapidly grown. In this note we consider the problem of constructing a portfolio of assets, including a combination of traditional financial assets such as stocks and bonds with crypto assets such as Bitcoin and Ethereum. Our conclusion is that despite the well known extreme swings of crypto currency values, simple standard portfolio construction methods suffice to realize the benefits of including crypto assets in a portfolio. Figure 1 shows the normalized prices of Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH), and the S&P 500 index (SP500) over the past six years. To the eye it reasonably seems that crypto returns are quite different from traditional returns. Table 1 lists some metrics for these asset returns over the same period, which also suggest that crypto asset returns fundamentally differ from traditional asset returns. For example, ETH at one point dropped in value by a factor of almost 20\times , while the maximum drop in value of SP500 is only one third. Figure 1 : Normalized prices of BTC, ETH, and SP500. Table 1 : Performance metrics for BTC, ETH, and SP500. Metric BTC ETH SP500 Return (%) 43.3 47.0 13.7 Volatility (%) 58.1 71.6 19.5 Sharpe 0.75 0.66 0.70 Drawdown (%) 83.3 93.9 33.9 Stylized facts of crypto returns, such as extreme volatility, heavy tails, excess kurtosis, and skewness, have been well documented [ LT21 , HPR19 , KRNY24 ] . Figure 2 shows quantile-quantile (QQ) plots of the log returns of BTC, ETH, and SP500 over the last six years. Figure 2 : Quantile-quantile plot of log returns of BTC, ETH, and SP500. All three return distributions have tails that deviate significantly from the normal distribution, with the crypto asset returns exhibiting more extreme tail behavior than the market index. The 1st and 99th return percentiles are shown in the plots as dashed green lines; here too we see that crypto asset returns have considerably bigger tails than the market index, even when normalized to have the same volatility. The documented characteristics of crypto asset returns have made conventional investors hesitant to include them in their portfolios, due to perceptions of risk and unpredictability. While asset managers may have additional concerns, such as legislative risk and other fundamental factors like the ongoing debate about the legitimacy of crypto as a real asset [ Yar13 , Kru13 , Kru11 , CK13 ] , we will focus here on the concerns related to the statistical properties of crypto asset returns. These characteristics of crypto asset returns have also led to a wealth of research on how to extend traditional portfolio construction methods to include crypto assets, including methods similar to those used for traditional assets [ Hol20 , BM19 , Bur19 , HRF19 ] , as well as more complex machine learning driven methods [ RRdSJB22 , JL17 , LB20 , JXL17 , Ram21 , RRdSJB22 ] . Despite the documented differences between crypto and conventional asset returns, some authors have argued that the two asset classes are fundamentally similar [ Pal24 , Chap. 2] , even though the crypto asset returns and volatilities are much higher. We agree with this perspective. In this note we show a simple method for constructing a portfolio of traditional and crypto assets using a risk allocation framework, (hopefully) debunking the idea that novel and complex machine learning approaches are necessary to manage a portfolio that includes crypto assets. Based on a back-test of the risk allocation method, we propose an even simpler portfolio construction method, reminiscent of the traditional 60/40 stocks/bonds split, which consists of a 90/10 split of traditional and crypto assets, followed by dynamic (time-varying) dilution with cash, to achieve a given ex-ante risk. We refer to this simple portfolio as DD90/10. Outline. In § 2 we review previous and related work. We introduce in § 3 an approach for constructing a portfolio that combines traditional and crypto assets within a risk allocation framework. We illustrate the performance of this method on historical data in § 4 . Finally, in § 5 we propose the DD90/10 portfolio allocation strategy, and show that it has performance similar to the risk allocation strategy. 2 Related work 2.1 Stylized facts of financial return data Stylized facts of financial return series refer to a set of empirical observations that are consistently observed across different financial markets and asset classes. We review some of the most prominent stylized facts for financial assets, and refer the reader to [ Pal24 , Chap. 2] for a more comprehensive overview. Equities. Stylized facts for equity returns include the non-normal distribution of returns, characterized by heavy tails and excess kurtosis [ MT10 , BB06 ] . Another fact is volatility clustering, where large price movements tend to be followed by additional large movements, regardless of direction. While returns themselves are generally uncorrelated over time, the absolute or squared returns often display strong autocorrelation, highlighting a pattern in the magnitude of fluctuations. Furthermore, the leverage effect is a notable feature, where negative returns increase future volatility to a greater extent than positive returns of the same size. Equity return distributions have also been shown to exhibit asymmetry between positive and negative returns [ JWZZ20 ] . Cryptocurrencies. Cryptocurrencies exhibit several patterns similar to traditional financial assets, but with more extreme behavior [ HPR19 , GBWZ23 ] . They are highly volatile, with large price fluctuations and heavy-tailed return distributions. Volatility tends to cluster, with periods of high volatility followed by more volatility. While returns show no autocorrelation in the short term, return magnitudes do exhibit autocorrelation. Cryptocurrencies also exhibit asymmetry in returns [ KRNY24 ] . 2.2 Portfolio construction Portfolio construction involves selecting a combination of assets by balancing the trade-off between expected return and portfolio risk. Here we discuss key historical contributions to the field, along with some recent advancements. For more extensive overviews, refer to texts such as [ GK00 , Chap. 14] , [ Nar24 , Chap. 6] , and the studies by [ CT06 , KTF14 , CK23 , GB23 , BJK+24 ] . Markowitz portfolio construction. Before Markowitz’s seminal work in 1952, portfolio construction was largely based on heuristics and rules of thumb. Markowitz introduced a quantitative framework for portfolio construction, where the return of a portfolio is modeled as a random variable, and the expected return is maximized for a desired level of risk [ Mar52 ] . Despite its simplicity, and having over 70 years of history, the Markowitz model remains the foundation of quantitative

Read the complete text