High-z stellar masses can be recovered robustly with JWST photometry

R. K. Cochrane, H. Katz, R. Begley, C. C. Hayward, P. N. Best · 2024

Read High-z stellar masses can be recovered robustly with JWST photometry by R. K. Cochrane, H. Katz, R. Begley, C. C. Hayward, P. N. Best (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02622.txt.

Introduction

Telescopes now weigh young galaxies by their light, and critics have warned the weights could be off tenfold. Cochrane and co-authors put a standard fitting code on trial using fake galaxies from a large cosmic simulation, with synthetic telescope images built to match the real instrument. They fit those images with several assumed star-formation histories and compare the answers with the truth.

Recovered masses landed within about a factor of three for most galaxies between five and ten billion years back, and over ninety percent fell within half an order of magnitude. Small galaxies read slightly heavy and big ones slightly light, a tilt the authors trace to bright emission lines fooling the fits.

Catalog record

CREATORR. K. Cochrane, H. Katz, R. Begley, C. C. Hayward, P. N. Best
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02622

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

High-z stellar masses can be recovered robustly with JWST photometry R. K. Cochrane, H. Katz, R. Begley, C. C. Hayward, P. N. Best Abstract Robust inference of galaxy stellar masses from photometry is crucial for constraints on galaxy assembly across cosmic time. Here, we test a commonly-used Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting code, using simulated galaxies from the S phinx 20 cosmological radiation hydrodynamics simulation, with JWST NIRCam photometry forward-modelled with radiative transfer. Fitting the synthetic photometry with various star formation history models, we show that recovered stellar masses are, encouragingly, generally robust to within a factor of ∼ 3 \sim 3 for galaxies in the range M ⋆ ∼ 10 7 − 10 9 ​ M ⊙ M_{\star}\sim 10^{7}-10^{9}\,\rm{M_{\odot}} at z = 5 − 10 z=5-10 . These results are in stark contrast to recent work claiming that stellar masses can be underestimated by as much as an order of magnitude in these mass and redshift ranges. However, while > 90 % >90\% of masses are recovered to within 0.5 ​ dex 0.5\,\rm{dex} , there are notable systematic trends, with stellar masses typically overestimated for low-mass galaxies ( M ⋆ ≲ 10 8 ​ M ⊙ M_{\star}\lesssim 10^{8}\,\rm{M_{\odot}} ) and slightly underestimated for high-mass galaxies ( M ⋆ ≳ 10 9 ​ M ⊙ M_{\star}\gtrsim 10^{9}\,\rm{M_{\odot}} ). We demonstrate that these trends arise due to the SED fitting code poorly modelling the impact of strong emission lines on broadband photometry. These systematic trends, which exist for all star formation history parametrisations tested, have a tilting effect on the inferred stellar mass function, with number densities of massive galaxies underestimated (particularly at the lowest redshifts studied) and number densities of lower-mass galaxies typically overestimated. Overall, this work suggests that we should be optimistic about our ability to infer the masses of high- z z galaxies observed with JWST (notwithstanding contamination from AGN) but careful when modelling the impact of strong emission lines on broadband photometry. 1 1 1 email: [email protected] I Introduction Observational constraints on the assembly of stellar mass are foundational for our understanding of galaxy formation and evolution. Large spectroscopic and photometric surveys have enabled constraints on the evolving stellar mass function (SMF) from z\sim 0 out to z\sim 8-9 ( Cole et al. 2001 ; Ilbert et al. 2009 ; Ilbert et al. 2013 ; Marchesini et al. 2009 ; Baldry et al. 2012 ; Moutard et al. 2016 ; Davidzon et al. 2017 ; Leja et al. 2020 ; Adams et al. 2021 ; McLeod et al. 2021 ; Weaver et al. 2023 , among many others) , with the most distant measurements made using deep Hubble Space Telescope ( HST ) imaging, which provided rest-frame ultraviolet (UV)-selected samples ( Duncan et al. 2014 ; Grazian et al. 2015 ; Song et al. 2016 ; Bhatawdekar et al. 2019 ; Kikuchihara et al. 2020 , e.g.) . JWST is providing a more complete census of stellar mass as early as z\sim 9 , enabling the identification of galaxies that were missed by the Lyman Break technique used to identify samples with HST ( Weibel et al. 2024 ) as well as the very faintest, low mass galaxies ( Navarro-Carrera et al. 2024 ) . Some early JWST results have been unexpected, and are in tension with predictions from models. These include the particularly high stellar masses derived for some high-redshift candidates ( Labbé et al. 2023 ; Rodighiero et al. 2023 ; Xiao et al. 2023 , e.g.) , which sparked suggestions of either a crisis with the Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) cosmological model ( Boylan-Kolchin 2023 ; Lovell et al. 2023 ) or evidence of more exotic physical scenarios, such as a variable stellar initial mass function (IMF: Steinhardt et al. 2022 ; Trinca et al. 2024 ). However, deriving stellar masses from photometry is subject to uncertainties in stellar evolution, the stellar IMF, the treatment of interstellar dust, AGN ‘contamination’, and the form of the star formation history (SFH), all of which are known to hamper accurate estimates ( Conroy et al. 2009 ; Conroy et al. 2010 ; Walcher et al. 2011 ; Michałowski et al. 2012 ; Michałowski et al. 2014 ; Conroy 2013 ) . One fundamental limitation is the effect of ‘outshining’, whereby younger, brighter stars dominate a galaxy’s SED and hide emission from older stars, leading to an underestimation of the total stellar mass ( Sawicki & Yee 1998 ; Papovich et al. 2001 ; Pforr et al. 2012 ; Pforr et al. 2013 ; Sorba & Sawicki 2015 ; Sorba & Sawicki 2018 ; Giménez-Arteaga et al. 2023 ; Giménez-Arteaga et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Another limitation is degenerate physical scenarios leading to similar photometry; for some of the high-redshift galaxies identified by JWST, strong emission lines, dust reddening or an AGN have mimicked the photometric signatures of a genuine evolved stellar population and potentially resulted in significantly overestimated stellar masses ( Schaerer & De Barros 2009 ; Barro et al. 2024 ; Desprez et al. 2023 ; Matthee et al. 2023 ; Trussler et al. 2023 ) . Tests of the methods used to recover galaxy physical properties are essential to understand the observations, refine fitting techniques, and hence maximise the value of JWST data. A limited amount of previous work has compared galaxy parameter estimates obtained using different Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) fitting codes ( Mobasher et al. 2015 ; Hunt et al. 2019 ; Cochrane et al. 2021 ; Pacifici et al. 2023 ; Best et al. 2023 , e.g.) and different prior assumptions ( Buat et al. 2014 , e.g.) . However, these tend to be tuned to specific populations - e.g. radio-selected galaxies as in Best et al. 2023 . Modelled galaxies - where the ‘ground truth’ physical properties are known and observed-frame photometry or spectra are forward-modelled - offer an alternative test bed for SED fitting. Basic tests have involved generating simplified parametric SFH models, and then refitting these to test the recovery of the input parameters ( Bisigello et al. 2019 ; Carnall et al. 2019 ; Suess et al. 2022 ) . Other studies have used mock galaxies drawn from semi-analytic models, with emission modelled using stellar population synthesis alongside simple dust models ( Pforr et al. 2012 ; Pforr et al. 2013 ; Mobasher et al. 2015 ) . Hydrodynamical simulations provide more sophisticated models for star formation and feedback, resulting in more complex star formation histories, which may not be well-represented by commonly-used parametric SFHs ( Simha et al. 2014 , e.g.) . Depending on resolution, such simulations can also provide information on the dust-star geometry, enabling more detailed treatments of dust attenuation ( Cochrane et al. 2019 ; Cochrane et al. 2023 ; Cochrane et al. 2024 , e.g. see) . Hydrodynamical simulations, with photometry generated via radiative transfer post-processing, have hence been used to test the fidelity of galaxy parameter recovery with common SED fitting codes ( Wuyts et al. 2009 ; Michałowski et al. 2014 ; Hayward & Smith 2015 ; Smith & Hayward 2018 ; Haskell et al. 2023 ; Haskell et al. 2024 , e.g.) . Although larger box

Read the complete text