Selective Thermalization, Chiral Excitations, and a Case of Quantum Hair in the Presence of Event Horizons

Akhil U Nair, Rakesh K. Jha, Prasant Samantray, Sashideep Gutti · 2024

Read Selective Thermalization, Chiral Excitations, and a Case of Quantum Hair in the Presence of Event Horizons by Akhil U Nair, Rakesh K. Jha, Prasant Samantray, Sashideep Gutti (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02560.txt.

Introduction

Akhil Nair and co-authors derive a variant of the Unruh effect in 2024, where an empty space looks warm to a speeding observer. They ask two sharp questions about selective effects. Can only some momentum modes be warmed, and can only left-handed particles be excited?

They compare two nested wedges of spacetime, shifted along a light direction. For a scalar field, the shift warms modes of one sign and leaves the other in vacuum. For fermions, one handedness gets excited while the other stays near empty. The setup may hint at quantum hair near event horizons.

Catalog record

CREATORAkhil U Nair, Rakesh K. Jha, Prasant Samantray, Sashideep Gutti
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02560

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Selective Thermalization, Chiral Excitations, and a Case of Quantum Hair in the Presence of Event Horizons Akhil U Nair, Rakesh K. Jha, Prasant Samantray, Sashideep Gutti Abstract The Unruh effect is a well-understood phenomenon, where one considers a vacuum state of a quantum field in Minkowski spacetime, which appears to be thermally populated for a uniformly accelerating Rindler observer. In this article, we derive a variant of the Unruh effect involving two distinct accelerating observers and aim to address the following questions: (i) Is it possible to selectively thermalize a subset of momentum modes for the case of massless scalar fields, and (ii) Is it possible to excite only the left-handed massless fermions while keeping right-handed fermions in a vacuum state or vice versa? To this end, we consider a Rindler wedge R 1 R_{1} constructed from a class of accelerating observers and another Rindler wedge R 2 R_{2} (with R 2 ⊂ R 1 R_{2}\subset R_{1} ) constructed from another class of accelerating observers such that the wedge R 2 R_{2} is displaced along a null direction w.r.t R 1 R_{1} by a parameter Δ \Delta . By first considering a massless scalar field in the R 1 R_{1} vacuum, we show that if we choose the displacement Δ \Delta along one null direction, the positive momentum modes are thermalized, whereas negative momentum modes remain in vacuum (and vice versa if we choose the displacement along the other null direction). We then consider a massless fermionic field in a vacuum state in R 1 R_{1} and show that the reduced state in R 2 R_{2} is such that the left-handed fermions are excited and are thermal for large frequencies. In contrast, the right-handed fermions have negligible particle density and vice versa. We argue that the toy models involving shifted Rindler spacetime may provide insights into the particle excitation aspects of evolving horizons and the possibility of Rindler spacetime having a quantum strand of hair. Additionally, based on our work, we hypothesize that massless fermions underwent selective chiral excitations during the radiation-dominated era of cosmology. I Introduction Black holes are one of the most mysterious astrophysical objects that have ever been detected due to their classical and quantum properties. Black holes can emit particles and radiation due to quantum effects near the event horizon; this phenomenon is known in the literature as Hawking radiation Hawking 1971 . The spectrum of particles is shown to be thermal distribution at late times Hawking 1971 . The astrophysical black holes are formed due to the collapse of matter and radiation, forming an event horizon that prevents any object from escaping from a black hole to the outside. The black holes give rise to many unresolved questions, like the problem of the existence of spacetime singularities or information paradox. These are still unresolved and await concrete theoretical proofs and justifications. Rindler spacetime has been used as a toy model to study and understand various aspects of black hole event horizon and Hawking radiation. This is because of the discovery of the Unruh effect Unruh 1976 . Though the Rindler spacetime is interesting in its own right, much of its importance comes from the fact that it happens to be near the horizon limit of generic black holes (non-extremal). Therefore, extensive work is being carried out in Rindler spacetime to eventually understand black hole horizons in the context of thermodynamics, entanglement entropy, and quantum information ( Almheiri et al. 2021 ; Witten 2018a ; Bousso et al. 2022 ; Raju 2022 ; Carlip 2015 ) . One area that is not yet fully understood is the quantum signatures of evolving horizons. If one considers that a black hole is formed by gravitational collapse, its mass evolves, and so does its event horizon (the boundary of the trapped region). The more relevant notion in this scenario is the apparent horizon. Based on the causal nature of the evolving horizon, it is classified broadly as a dynamical horizon if its tangent is spacelike (a typical collapsing of matter scenario) and a timelike tube if its tangent is timelike Ashtekar and Krishnan 2002 ( occurs in cosmological scenarios or during the collapse of homogeneous dust models like the Oppenheimer-Snyder collapse model Oppenheimer and Snyder 1939 ). A uniform notion for evolving horizons is introduced in Ref. Bousso and Engelhardt 2015 known as holographic screens (the dynamical horizon then is a spacelike future holographic screen). There is an even less explored scenario where the evolving horizon is null. This scenario occurs during the radiation-dominated era in cosmological evolution Ben-Dov 2004 ; Raviteja et al. 2021 . The work done in this article might prove useful for deducing the clues towards possible quantum signatures for this scenario, as argued in the paragraphs below. The Rindler spacetimes provide interesting toy models for understanding the quantum signatures of evolving horizons. When one constructs two different Rindler spacetimes using two separate classes of uniformly accelerating observers (say R_{1} and R_{2} respectively), we can arrange the observers in such a way that R_{2} is a subsystem of R_{1} ( R_{2}\subset R_{1} ). The Fig. 1 illustrates the situation. For R_{2} to be a subsystem of R_{1} , it is easy to see that the bifurcation point of R_{2} is spacelike or null separated from R_{1} as shown in Figs. 1 , 2 , and 3 . A good toy model for the case of dynamical horizons is a nested sequence of spacelike shifted Rindler spacetimes, as argued in Ref. Gutti et al. 2023 . This is because a dynamical horizon in the context of black holes makes a series of spacelike jumps in the increasing radial direction. The situation resembles a nested sequence of Rindler wedges. The nested sequence of wedges that occur in the case of dynamical horizons (or future holographic screens) has been used to prove the important results concerning the increase in entanglement entropy in the outer region of a black hole in ADS/CFT context Engelhardt and Wall 2018 . A review of relevant literature on entanglement in quantum field theoretic setting is discussed in ( Witten 2018a ; Nishioka 2018a ; Headrick 2019 ; Casini and Huerta 2022 ; Calabrese and Cardy 2004 ; Hollands and Sanders 2017 ) . Few papers have dealt with shifted Rindler scenarios and have interesting results. In Ref. Lochan and Padmanabhan 2021a , the authors consider Rindler spacetime R_{1} and another Rindler spacetime R_{2} shifted along the spatial direction. They showed that if quantum fields in R_{1} are in vacuum, R_{2} has a thermal spectrum of particles. In Ref. Gutti et al. 2023 , the authors addressed a question as to the uniqueness of particle content in R_{2} starting from a vacuum state in Minkowski spacetime depending on whether we consider R_{1} between R_{2} and Minkowski spacetime or not ( R_{2}\subset R_{1}\subset M with M as Minkowski spacetime). Here are a few interesting questions, some of which are answered in this article. Suppose there is a spacetime with a quantum field living on it in a vacuum state. Can we construct subsystems of this system demarcated due to horizons to partially excite or thermalize a subset of modes? Can Rindler spacetime exhibit a strand

Read the complete text