Density formulas for p p -adically bounded primes for hypergeometric series with rational and quadratic irrational parameters
Cameron Franc, Nathan Heisz, Hannah Nardone · 2024
Read Density formulas for p p -adically bounded primes for hypergeometric series with rational and quadratic irrational parameters by Cameron Franc, Nathan Heisz, Hannah Nardone (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-02523.txt.
Introduction
Cameron Franc, Nathan Heisz, and Hannah Nardone count how often primes behave tamely for hypergeometric series, in a 2024 paper. Such series are built from factorials with adjustable parameters, and for each prime one can ask whether the series stays bounded in the p-adic sense. The share of good primes, the density, turns out to encode deep facts about the series' symmetries.
For series whose parameters are rational numbers, the authors extend an exact density formula from the simplest family to a broader one. The density equals one exactly when the symmetry group is finite, matching a classic classification. For parameters from a quadratic number field, they prove a lower bound on the density unconditionally. If the p-adic digits of such numbers are normally distributed, the bound becomes exact. Examples reaching the ceiling of one-half all come, so far, from imaginary quadratic fields.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cameron Franc, Nathan Heisz, Hannah Nardone |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-02523
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Density formulas for p p -adically bounded primes for hypergeometric series with rational and quadratic irrational parameters Thanks: We thank NSERC for support via a Discovery grant. Cameron Franc, Nathan Heisz, Hannah Nardone Abstract . We study densities of p p -adically bounded primes for hypergeometric series in two cases: the case of generalized hypergeometric series with rational parameters, and the case of F 1 2 {}_{2}F_{1} with parameters in a quadratic extension of the rational numbers. In the rational case we extend work from F 1 2 {}_{2}F_{1} to F n − 1 n {}_{n}F_{n-1} for an exact formula giving the density of bounded primes for the series. The density is shown to be one exactly in accordance with the case of finite monodromy as classified by Beukers-Heckmann. In the quadratic irrational case, we obtain an unconditional lower bound on the density of bounded primes. Assuming the normality of the p p -adic digits of quadratic irrationalities, this lower bound is shown to be an exact formula for the density of bounded primes. In the quadratic irrational case, there is a trivial upper bound of 1 / 2 1/2 on the density of bounded primes. In the final section of the paper we discuss some results and computations on series that attain this bound. In particular, all such examples we have found are associated to imaginary quadratic fields, though we do not prove this is always the case. 1. Introduction A classical problem in the study of hypergeometric series is to determine which series are integral. This problem is closely related to integrality of ratios of factorials, algebraicity of generalized hypergeometric series, and even the Riemann hypothesis — see [ 3 ] for a review of some of this work, and the recent paper [ 1 ] for an extension of some of these questions to the case of GKZ-hypergeometric series. The related problem of determining when a generalized hypergeometric series has finite monodromy was solved by Beukers-Heckmann [ 2 ] , preceded in the case of {}_{2}F_{1} by classical work of Schwarz. In these cases the algebraic series have rational hypergeometric parameters, and it is known by a classical result of Eisenstein that while the series need not have integral coefficients, there are at worst a finite number of primes that arise in the denominators of the series. Thus, while algebraic generalized hypergeometric series need not be integral, the density of primes where such a series is p -adically bounded equals one. In this paper we study densities of p -adically bounded primes for various hypergeometric series, typically non-algebraic. The study of p -adic boundedness of a hypergeometric series, spearheaded by Dwork [ 5 ] and Christol [ 4 ] , provided necessary and sufficient conditions for a generalized hypergeometric series {}_{n}F_{n-1} to be p -adically bounded. Franc-Gannon-Mason [ 6 ] showed that for all series {}_{2}F_{1} with rational hypergeometric parameters, there is a corresponding density of p -adically bounded primes, and this density is one exactly when the series is algebraic, that is, it comes from Schwarz’s classical list. Franc et.al. in [ 7 ] built on this work to establish an exact formula for the Dirichlet densities of bounded primes in the denominators of series {}_{2}F_{1} with rational parameters. Our first main result Theorem 3.6 extends this density formula to generalized hypergeometric series {}_{m}F_{n} and furthermore shows that the only case of interest in terms of boundedness of primes is the case where m=n+1 . These results can be summarized as follows: Theorem 1.1 . Let F(z)={}_{m}F_{n}(\alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{m};\beta_{1},\ldots,\beta_{n};z) denote a generalized hypergeometric series with rational hypergeometric parameters, \alpha_{i},\beta_{j}\in\mathbf{Q} . Then the set B of primes where F(z) is p -adically bounded has a Dirichlet density. This density is one if m>n+1 , and it is zero of m<n+1 . When m=n+1 , the density can be computed exactly using a simple formula given in Corollary 3.8 . In this case, the density is one if and only if F(z) is an algebraic function. The next case we discuss, starting in Section 4 , is that of hypergeometric series of the form f(z)={}_{2}F_{1}(a+b\sqrt{D},a-b\sqrt{D};c;z) where a,b,c,D\in\mathbf{Q} . Such series have rational expansions yet, if D is not square, then they are transcendental functions by [ 2 ] . The N -integrality of hypergeometric series {}_{m}F_{n} with parameters from quadratic fields has been studied by Hong-Wang [ 10 ] , and specific cases of {}_{2}F_{1} with quadratic irrational parameters have appeared as solutions to a differential equation concerning the arithmetic of modular forms on \Gamma_{0}(2) in work by Gottesman [ 8 ] . Some of our results in Section 4 can be summarized as follows: Theorem 1.2 . Let f(z)\in\mathbf{Q}[\![z]\!] be a hypergeometric series as above, where D is not a perfect square, and let B be the set of primes where f(z) is p -adically bounded. Then B has a Dirichlet density that is at most 1/2 , and which is bounded below by explicit formulas described in Propositions 4.8 and 4.10 . If one assumes that the p -adic digits of quadratic irrationalities are normal, then the density bounds in Propositions 4.8 and 4.10 are exact formulas. In the rational case of Theorem 1.1 , our arguments rely on the periodic p -adic expansions of rational numbers. In the quadratic irrational case of Theorem 1.2 , the expansions are no longer periodic, and so normality serves as a convenient replacement for this property. Actually, to establish our conjectural density formulas in Section 4 , we only need to assume a result about p -adic expansions of quadratic irrationalities, Conjecture 4.4 below, that is implied by p -adic normality of digits. We do not know if Conjecture 4.4 is in fact equivalent to p -adic normality. The density in Theorem 1.2 is bounded above by 1/2 for the simple reason that a series such as f(z) can only be p -adically bounded for primes p that split in \mathbf{Q}(\sqrt{D} ), cf. Proposition 4.1 . The reason why there are two density formulas, cf. Propositions 4.8 and 4.10 , is because the formulas are different in the cases where 2a is integral or not. Since the trace of a+b\sqrt{D} plays an important role in the proofs, whether the trace 2a has a truncating or periodic p -adic expansion affects the argument and the formulas. Section 5 is inspired by the Schwarz list for {}_{2}F_{1} , which essentially classifies series with density of bounded primes equal to one. For the case of series such as f(z) above, a natural quadratic irrational analogue is to classify series where the density of bounded primes is 1/2 . We do not resolve this question, but we discuss some computations towards it, and also establish some upper-bounds that indicate that it should be reasonably rare for a series such as f(z) to have a density of bounded primes equal to 1/2 . For example, in all of our examples, we only ever observed a density of 1/2 when the field K=\mathbf{Q}(\sqrt{D}) is imaginary quadratic. See Table 3 for some examples with a and c of small height. This rarity of large densities is in-line with the classical Schwarz list being rather sparse among all rational