Clustering and Runaway Merging in a Primordial Black Hole Dominated Universe
Ian Holst, Gordan Krnjaic, Huangyu Xiao · 2024
Read Clustering and Runaway Merging in a Primordial Black Hole Dominated Universe by Ian Holst, Gordan Krnjaic, Huangyu Xiao (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01890.txt.
Introduction
Ian Holst, Gordan Krnjaic, and Huangyu Xiao study what happens when primordial black holes come to dominate the early universe. Their 2024 paper explains that such black holes, if present, grow in relative weight as radiation thins out, and can take over unless they start out vanishingly rare. That era is poorly constrained for light black holes that evaporate before the first atomic nuclei form.
Using a standard statistical method for collapsing matter, the team calculated how these black holes cluster. Inside clusters, members can merge, and the mergers can run away: most of a cluster ends up in one black hole far heavier than any of its parts. Such mergers would rewrite the mass spread of the whole population. The heavy leftovers evaporate later and leave marks that observations could see, ruling out choices once thought viable.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ian Holst, Gordan Krnjaic, Huangyu Xiao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01890
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Clustering and Runaway Merging in a Primordial Black Hole Dominated Universe Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-24-0133-T Ian Holst, Gordan Krnjaic, Huangyu Xiao Abstract If primordial black holes (PBH) are present in the early universe, their contribution to the energy budget grows relative to that of radiation and generically becomes dominant unless the initial abundance is exponentially small. This black hole domination scenario is largely unconstrained for PBHs with masses ≲ 10 9 g \lesssim 10^{9}\,\mathrm{g} , which evaporate prior to Big Bang nucleosynthesis. However, if the era of PBH domination is sufficiently long, the PBHs form clusters and can merge appreciably within these objects. We calculate the population statistics of these clusters within the Press-Schechter formalism and find that, for a wide range of PBH masses and Hubble rates at the onset of PBH domination, the mergers within PBH clusters can exhibit runaway behavior, where the majority of the cluster will eventually form a single black hole with a mass much greater than the original PBH mass. These mergers can dramatically alter the PBH mass distribution and leave behind merged relic black holes that evaporate after Big Bang nucleosynthesis and yield various observational signatures, excluding parameter choices previously thought to be viable. I Introduction Figure 1: Example timeline describing the black hole domination scenario. At t=t_{\mathrm{form}} a subdominant population of PBHs forms during radiation domination in the early universe. Since PBHs redshift like nonrelativistic matter, their energy fraction grows linearly during this era and they dominate the energy budget at t=t_{i} , which serves as the starting point for our analysis in this paper. During PBH domination, density perturbations grow linearly with scale factor and PBH clusters begin to form. Within a range of cluster masses, PBH mergers can be fast compared to Hubble expansion and consume most of the cluster in a runaway merger. This process forms a sub-population of more massive, longer lived PBH relics which can survive past t=\tau when the original PBH population evaporates due to Hawking emission. Thus, even though the original PBH population evaporates before BBN, the relic population can have important consequences for BBN and CMB observables and may also survive into the later universe. This sequence of events gives rise to gravitational waves from the PBH mergers, the Hawking emission at evaporation, and from second order scalar perturbations. First postulated by Hawking in 1971 HawkingGravitationallyCollapsedObjects1971 , primordial black holes (PBH) may have formed in the early universe from large density fluctuations on small scales; see Ref. SasakiPBHsPerspectivesGW2018 for a review. If the PBH mass scale falls within 10^{17}\,\mathrm{g}<m<10^{23}\,\mathrm{g} , PBHs can viably accommodate the total dark matter abundance in our universe CarrConstraintsPBHs2021 ; GreenPBHsDMCandidate2021 ; for m>10^{23}\,\mathrm{g} , these objects are subject to various astrophysical bounds and can account for a small fraction of dark matter. The cosmological abundance of lighter PBHs with mass <10^{17}\,\mathrm{g} is generically subject to stringent cosmological limits from the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) AcharyaCMBBBNConstraints2020 . However, these low mass limits only apply if the initial PBHs survive past BBN. If, instead, the PBH lifetime is shorter than \sim 1\,\mathrm{s} , they can realize a vastly wider range of initial abundances, and can even temporarily dominate the cosmic energy density. For example, if the radiation dominated early universe had a temperature T_{\mathrm{form}} at the time of PBH formation, then for any initial PBH energy fraction f_{\mathrm{BH}} that satisfies HooperDarkRadiationSuperheavy2019 f_{\mathrm{BH}}>1.6\times 10^{-13}{\left(\frac{10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV}}{T_{\mathrm{form}}}\right)}{\left(\frac{10^{9}\,\mathrm{g}}{m}\right)}^{3/2}\!\!, (1) the PBH population eventually dominates the cosmic energy budget before evaporating through Hawking radiation to restore the Standard Model radiation bath. Since the lifetime of a BH is \tau\sim G^{2}m^{3}\sim 1\,\mathrm{s}\,{\left(\frac{m}{10^{9}\,\mathrm{g}}\right)}^{3}, (2) the BHD scenario can only viably restore the radiation dominated universe for m\lesssim 10^{9}\,\mathrm{g} ; larger PBH mass values result in a radiation temperature below the MeV scale at the time of PBH evaporation HooperDarkRadiationSuperheavy2019 . Once the early universe enters a regime of black hole domination (BHD), its homogeneous properties are largely set by the PBH mass and are insensitive to the details of earlier epochs. For example, assuming a monochromatic PBH mass function, there is a one-to-one relationship between m and the radiation temperature resulting from evaporation HooperDarkRadiationSuperheavy2019 , the PBH merger rate SasakiPBHScenarioGW2016 ; RaidalGWsPBHMergers2017 ; ZagoracGUTScalePBHs2019 ; HooperHotGravitonsGWs2020 , the radiation densities of exotic new species HooperDarkRadiationSuperheavy2019 ; Shallue:2024hqe , the baryon asymmetry Baumann:2007yr ; MorrisonMelanopogenesisDMalmost2019 ; HooperGUTBaryogenesisPBHs2021 ; Bernal:2022pue , and even the mass of dark matter if it is produced non-thermally through Hawking radiation LennonBHGenesisDM2018 ; MorrisonMelanopogenesisDMalmost2019 ; HooperDarkRadiationSuperheavy2019 ; Cheek:2021odj . While the existing literature on BHD has addressed many aspects of this compelling scenario, one important question remains unanswered: how does gravitational clustering affect the predictions of BHD? As in any other matter dominated phase AllahverdiFirstThreeSeconds2021 , during BHD, cosmological perturbations grow linearly with the cosmic scale factor and gravitationally bound structures begin to form. Depending on the duration of this early matter dominated era, the denser conditions in these black hole clusters could sharply enhance PBH merger rates and result in a dramatically modified mass distribution at the time of evaporation. Since clustering is purely gravitational, the details of early structure formation only depend on the time elapsed between the onset of BHD at t=t_{i} and PBH evaporation at t=\tau . In this paper, we use the Press-Schechter formalism PressFormationGalaxiesClusters1974 to study cluster formation and PBH mergers during an era of BHD. We find that, depending on the duration of BHD, PBH mergers can be very efficient in large clusters and significantly modify the initial PBH mass function. This both changes the generically UV insensitive predictions of BHD and even excludes certain regions of parameter space in which many PBHs grow through mergers to survive into the BBN and CMB eras. Earlier work has considered clusters of cosmologically stable PBH in the later universe after matter-radiation equality FishbachAreLIGOsBHs2017 ; DeLucaClusteringEvolutionPBHs2020 ; FrancioliniPBHMergersThree2022 ; DelosStructureFormationPBHs2024 , or focused on PBH mergers in the early Universe without cluster formation (the “quasi-linear regime”) HooperHotGravitonsGWs2020 ; DeLucaClusteringEvolutionPBHs2020 ; NakamuraGWsCoalescingBH1997 ; IokaBHBinaryFormation1998 ; AliHaimoudMergerRatePBH2017 ; RaidalFormationEvolutionPBH2019 ; DeLucaHeavyPBHsStrongly2023 ; SasakiPBHScenarioGW2016 ; RaidalGWsPBHMergers2017 ; ZagoracGUTScalePBHs2019 , while Refs. DeLucaHeavyPBHsStrongly2023 ; ChisholmClusteringPBHsII2011 explored the formation of heavier PBH from strongly clustered lighter ones (clusteringenesis), but did not specify a mechanism for this enhanced initial clustering at PBH formation. Ref. KimPBHReformationEarly2024 studied PBH formation from the growth of density perturbations in PBH domination but did not consider mergers in PBH clusters. Black hole mergers in clusters have also been studied in the context of building supermassive black holes in galaxies XuDynamicsMassiveBHs1994 ; TanakaAssemblySupermassiveBHs2009 ; InayoshiAssemblyFirstMassive2020 . Our analysis is complementary as we consider evaporating PBHs with m<10^{9}\,\mathrm{g} and calculate their clustering behavior in the early universe in a BHD era, which has not been studied before. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II we review the cosmological aspects of PBH domination and evaporation. In Sec. III we describe PBH cluster formation and the internal dynamics of these clusters. In Sec. IV we calculate the evolution of PBH mass distribution due to mergers in clusters. In Sec. V we discuss the observational consequences of BHD with clustering, including contributions to dark matter, dark radiation, and primordial gravitational waves (GW). Throughout our analysis we use natural units where \hbar=c=k_{B}=1 .