The Origins of Lithium Enhancement in Polluted White Dwarfs
Benjamin C. Kaiser, J. Christopher Clemens, Simon Blouin, Erik Dennihy, Patrick Dufour, Ryan J. Hegedus, Joshua S. Reding · 2024
Read The Origins of Lithium Enhancement in Polluted White Dwarfs by Benjamin C. Kaiser, J. Christopher Clemens, Simon Blouin, Erik Dennihy, Patrick Dufour, Ryan J. Hegedus, Joshua S. Reding (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01878.txt.
Introduction
Benjamin Kaiser and six co-authors ask why some spoilt white dwarfs show high lithium past the norm. When white dwarfs take in rock waste from broke world bits, their air tells what the waste held. Three tales vie for the lithium glut. They are old and star made growth, crust stuff from a world, and a moon made from ring waste.
The team sets out new views and air fits for three dwarfs spoilt with lithium. They add one dwarf spoilt with metal but with no lithium. When they weigh traits in six stars, the old and star made tale looks most apt for three of them. The moon tale is most apt to be false in each case. One star for now fits none of the three tales.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benjamin C. Kaiser, J. Christopher Clemens, Simon Blouin, Erik Dennihy, Patrick Dufour, Ryan J. Hegedus, Joshua S. Reding |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 99 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01878
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Origins of Lithium Enhancement in Polluted White Dwarfs Benjamin C. Kaiser, J. Christopher Clemens, Simon Blouin, Erik Dennihy, Patrick Dufour, Ryan J. Hegedus, Joshua S. Reding Abstract The bulk abundances of exoplanetesimals can be measured when they are accreted by white dwarfs. Recently, lithium from the accretion of exoplanetesimals was detected in relatively high levels in multiple white dwarfs. There are presently three proposed hypotheses to explain the detection of excess lithium in white dwarf photospheres: Big Bang and Galactic nucleosynthesis, continental crust, and an exomoon formed from spalled ring material. We present new observations of three previously known lithium-polluted white dwarfs (WD J1824+1213, WD J2317+1830, and LHS 2534), and one with metal pollution without lithium (SDSS J1636+1619). We also present atmospheric model fits to these white dwarfs. We then evaluate the abundances of these white dwarfs and two additional lithium-polluted white dwarfs that were previously fit using the same atmospheric models (WD J1644–0449 and SDSS J1330+6435) in the context of the three extant hypotheses for explaining lithium excesses in polluted white dwarfs. We find Big Bang and Galactic nucleosynthesis to be the most plausible explanation of the abundances in WD J1644–0449, WD J1824+1213, and WD J2317+1830. SDSS J1330+6435 will require stricter abundances to determine its planetesimal’s origins, and LHS 2534, as presently modeled, defies all three hypotheses. We find the accretion of an exomoon formed from spalled ring material to be highly unlikely to be the explanation of the lithium excess in any of these cases. astropy [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] I Introduction White dwarfs are the end state of stellar evolution for the vast majority of stars. White dwarfs’ high surface gravity causes elements to stratify by mass, so in isolation, only the lightest elements, H and He, should be detectable at the surface. 1 1 1 C can be detected as a result of dredge up at lower temperatures in some white dwarfs [ 33 , e.g.] and other metals can be detected in hotter white dwarfs due to radiative levitation [ 20 , e.g.] . However, hundreds of white dwarfs have had heavier elements detected in their photospheres. These heavier elements are from recently accreted extrasolar planetary material, and their presence in the white dwarf photosphere enables a measurement of their relative abundances. Thus, we can obtain bulk abundance measurements of extrasolar planetesimals. Dozens of different elements have been detected from accreted extrasolar planetesimals in white dwarfs at various relative abundances (see Klein et al. [51] for a review). The differing abundance ratios have largely been attributed to the diversity of planetary abundances with the majority being comparable to Solar System bodies or parts thereof [ 39 , 18 ] . In 2021, lithium was discovered in five polluted white dwarfs [ 47 , 41 ] : WD J164417.01 - 044947.7 (hereafter WD J1644–0449) 2 2 2 We provide the full J2000 white dwarf name first, but we refer to each white dwarf throughout this work using a shorter name that was originally used in the literature. [ 47 ] , WD J133001.17+643523.69 (hereafter SDSS J1330+6435) [ 47 , 41 ] , WD J121456.38 - 023402.84 (hereafter LHS 2534) [ 41 ] , WD J182458.45+121316.82 (hereafter WD J1824+1213) [ 41 ] , and WD J231726.74+183052.75 (hereafter WD J2317+1830) [ 41 ] . All five white dwarfs’ lithium abundance ratios—Li/Ca in Kaiser et al. [47] and Li/Na in Hollands et al. [41] —were determined to be elevated compared to CI Chondrites from the Solar System. Kaiser et al. [47] proposed the lithium enhancement is a consequence of nucleosynthetic evolution of the Galaxy in which Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) provides higher Li/Ca in the early gas. Hollands et al. [41] proposed the lithium enhancement is a result of the accretion of continental crust with one of the white dwarfs accreting a “particularly lithium-rich” piece of continental crust. Another light element, Be, was recently discovered in two white dwarf photospheres [ 51 ] , and its abundance relative to Ca was also elevated relative to CI Chondrites. Klein et al. [51] posited the Be-enhancement was a consequence of the accreted planetesimals’ presence in a high proton bombardment location. Doyle et al. [30] proposed the high proton bombardment location as the icy rings of a gas giant with a magnetic field and proton flux comparable to Jupiter’s. The accreted bodies would be icy exomoons formed from former ring material that had been subjected to the high proton flux, which caused the spalling of O to produce elevated levels of Be. Doyle et al. [30] pointed out that elevated Li levels would also result from this spallation, and suggested this could be relevant for the Li-enhanced white dwarfs as well. Thus, there are three extant hypotheses to explain elevated Li levels of planetesimals accreted by white dwarfs: 1. Galactic nucleosynthetic evolution caused a dearth of heavier metals relative to lithium at early Galactic epochs [ 68 ] . Correspondingly, metal-deficient - and therefore Li-enhanced - exoplanetesimals formed from these nebulae with the white dwarf progenitors. These Li-enhanced planetesimals were then accreted by the white dwarfs causing the observed pollution [ 47 ] . 2. The continental crust of the Earth is enhanced in Li and K compared to CI Chondrites [ 73 ] . The white dwarfs accreted “particularly lithium-rich” continental crust material, which was presumably formed on Earth-like exoplanets that orbited the white dwarf progenitors [ 41 ] . 3. Li, Be, and B can be produced by bombarding C, N, and O nuclei with high energy protons in a process called spallation [ 69 ] . Icy exoplanetary rings around Jupiter-like gas giants were spalled by protons captured from the white dwarf progenitors’ stellar wind by the gas giants’ magnetospheres. This nuclear spallation produced Li, Be, and B in the exoplanetary rings. The rings were then reaccumulated to form exomoons, which were accreted by the white dwarfs [ 30 ] . We evaluate the abundances of the bodies accreted by the 5 Li-polluted whited dwarfs in the context of these 3 hypotheses, with the same atmospheric models used to derive all abundances consistently. First, we present follow-up spectroscopic observations aimed at assessing these three hypotheses in Section II . Our new observations include the following white dwarfs with Li identifications: LHS 2534, WD J1824+1213, and WD J2317+1830. We also present Gemini GMOS-N spectroscopic observations of the low temperature DZ WD J163601.35+161907.51 (hereafter SDSS J1636+1619) with null detections of Li and K. We perform atmospheric model fits to the Li-polluted white dwarfs and SDSS J1636+1619 in Section III.1 . We infer the abundances of the extrasolar planetesimals accreted by the 5 white dwarfs’ with Li detections and SDSS J1636+1619 in Section III.2 . We compute total ages of the white dwarfs discussed in Section III.3 . We evaluate the kinematic population memberships of the white dwarfs in Section III.4 . We derive the expected Galactic nucleosynthetic evolution of various abundances from archival data in Section III.5 . We address the spallation hypothesis in Section IV . We evaluate each white dwarf in the context of the geologic differentiation hypothesis and Big Bang combined with Galactic nucleosynthesis hypothesis in Section V . In Section VI , we