Main problems in constructing quantum theory based on finite mathematics
2024
Read Main problems in constructing quantum theory based on finite mathematics (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01846.txt.
Introduction
Felix Lev lays out the main hurdles in rebuilding quantum theory on finite math, in a 2024 paper. Standard quantum theory uses endless number lines. Lev's version swaps them for a finite ring of numbers, and the standard theory falls out as a special case when the ring grows without bound. The swap changes a deep rule: in the standard theory, each basic object carries energy of one sign only, which splits the world into particles and antiparticles.
In the finite version, every basic state mixes both signs of energy at once. Charge-like labels that split particles from antiparticles then lose their strict meaning. Lev argues those labels work well only because the ring is huge today; early in the cosmos it may have been small. The paper gives simple models that show these effects without the heavy proofs of his past work.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2024 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01846
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Main problems in constructing quantum theory based on finite mathematics Abstract As shown in our publications, quantum theory based on a finite ring of characteristic p p (FQT) is more general than standard quantum theory (SQT) because the latter is a degenerate case of the former in the formal limit p → ∞ p\to\infty . One of the main differences between SQT and FQT is the following. In SQT, elementary objects are described by irreducible representations (IRs) of a symmetry algebra in which energies are either only positive or only negative and there are no IRs where there are states with different signs of energy. In the first case, objects are called particles, and in the second - antiparticles. As a consequence, in SQT it is possible to introduce conserved quantum numbers (electric charge, baryon number, etc.) so that particles and antiparticles differ in the signs of these numbers. However, in FQT, all IRs necessarily contain states with both signs of energy. The symmetry in FQT is higher than the symmetry in SQT because one IR in FQT splits into two IRs in SQT with positive and negative energies at p → ∞ p\to\infty . Consequently, most fundamental quantum theory will not contain the concepts of particle-antiparticle and additive quantum numbers. These concepts are only good approximations at present since at this stage of the universe the value p p is very large but it was not so large at earlier stages. The above properties of IRs in SQT and FQT have been discussed in our publications with detailed technical proofs. The purpose of this paper is to consider models where these properties can be derived in a much simpler way. Felix M. Lev Email: [email protected] Keywords: finite mathematics; standard mathematics; finite quantum theory; standard quantum theory MSC 2020: 11Axx, 11Txx, 13Mxx, 16Gxx, 81R05 List of Abbreviations FM: finite mathematics SM: standard mathematics SR: special relativity NM: nonrelativistic mechanics QT: quantum theory CT: classical theory FQT: Quantum theory based on finite mathematics SQT: Standard quantum theory IR: irreducible representation QFT: Quantum Field Theory NQT: Nonrelativistic Quantum Theory RQT: Relativistic Quantum Theory dS: de Sitter AdS: Anti de Sitter dSQT: de Sitter Quantum Theory AdSQT: Anti de Sitter Quantum Theory 1 The main goal of this paper One of the key problems of QFT is the problem of divergences: the theory gives divergent expressions for the S-matrix. While in renormalized theories, the divergences can be eliminated by renormalization, in non-renormalized QFTs, they cannot be eliminated and this is a great obstacle for constructing quantum gravity based on QFT. The problem of divergences has been considered by many physicists, and there has long been an idea in the air that this problem can only be solved within the framework of a discrete and finite quantum theory. It would seem natural to think that such a theory should proceed from discrete and finite mathematics. However, most mathematicians and physicists believe that SM (with infinities and continuities) is fundamental while discrete and finite mathematics is a science of a lower rank which is only needed for applications in some models. This point of view has developed for historical reasons (because more than 300 years ago Newton and Leibniz proposed the calculus of infinitesimals) and due to the fact that SM has achieved many impressive successes in describing experimental data. The calculus of infinitesimals seemed natural when people did not know about elementary particles and thought that any substance could be divided into any arbitrarily large number of arbitrarily small objects. But now we know that at the level of elementary particles there are no arbitrarily small parts and no continuity. Also, history tells us that if a theory successfully describes many experimental data, this is not yet a guarantee that this theory is the most fundamental. For example, NM successfully describes a lot of experimental data and before the creation of SR it was believed that NM was a fundamental theory. SR did not refute NM, but showed that the latter is a degenerate case of the former in formal limit c\to\infty where c is usually treated as the speed of light. As shown in our works [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , FM is more general (fundamental) than SM: the latter is a degenerate case of the former in formal limit p\to\infty where p is a characteristic of a ring in FM. Several famous physicists (e.g., Gross, Nambu, Schwinger and Weyl) discussed approaches when QT involves FM (see e.g., [ 5 ] ). They are called hybrid quantum systems and described in [ 6 ] . The reason is that here physical quantities belong to a finite ring but quantum states are elements of standard Hilbert spaces. On the other hand, in [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , we have proposed an approach called finite quantum theory (FQT) where not only physical quantities but also quantum states are described by finite rings. We have shown that FQT is more general (fundamental) than SQT: SQT is a degenerate case of FQT in formal limit p\to\infty where p is the characteristic of the ring in FQT. In SQT, elementary objects are described by IRs of symmetry algebras in which energies can be either \geq 0 or \leq 0 and there are no IRs with both positive and negative energies. In the first case, objects are called particles and in the second - antiparticles, and after secondary quantization, the energies of antiparticles also become positive. In SQT, particles and antiparticles are characterized by additive quantum number, e.g., the electric charge, the baryon number and others. If particle A is characterized by some additive quantum numbers and antiparticle B has the same mass and spin as A, but additive quantum numbers of B are equal to the corresponding additive quantum numbers of A with the opposite sign, then B is called the antiparticle for A. In SQT there are superselection rules that prohibit the superposition of a particle and its antiparticle. For example, electron-positron or proton-antiproton superpositions are prohibited, and this is interpreted as a consequence of the conservation of electric charge and baryon quantum number. However, in FQT, one IR necessarily contains states with both positive and negative energies. Since such states belong to the same IR, their superpositions are allowed and there are no superselection rules. One can formally call states with positive energies particles and assign some additive quantum numbers to them, and call states with negative energies antiparticles and assign opposite quantum numbers to them. Then it turns out that there are no conservation laws for such quantum numbers, and, for example, electron-positron or proton-antiproton superpositions are allowed. It is clear that this completely contradicts the basic concepts of SQT. In other words, in FQT, the standard concepts of electric charge, baryon quantum number and other additive quantum numbers do not work. This situation may prompt physicists to declare that FQT is not a physical theory and should be rejected. However, symmetry in FQT is higher than symmetry in SQT since one IR in FQT splits into two IRs in SQT with positive and negative energies in the formal limit p\to\infty when FM goes to SM. At