Source multipoles and energy-momentum tensors for spinning black holes and other compact objects in arbitrary dimensions
Massimo Bianchi, Claudio Gambino, Paolo Pani, Fabio Riccioni · 2024
Read Source multipoles and energy-momentum tensors for spinning black holes and other compact objects in arbitrary dimensions by Massimo Bianchi, Claudio Gambino, Paolo Pani, Fabio Riccioni (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01771.txt.
Introduction
Massimo Bianchi, Claudio Gambino, Paolo Pani, and Fabio Riccioni derive, in a 2024 physics paper, a general way to link a spinning object's inner source to its gravity field. In Newton's theory, a body's field can be read off from its multipole pattern, a ladder of ever finer shape terms. Doing the same in Einstein's theory has been less direct.
Working in momentum space, at first order in the gravity coupling, they build a broad class of energy and momentum tensors. Each tensor matches a given multipole pattern, in any number of dimensions. The tensors are built from mass and spin, at any order in spin. Set rules then yield the full pattern for the classic Kerr black hole and for its five dimensional kin. For Kerr, the summed source gives exactly the thin spinning disk found long ago.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Massimo Bianchi, Claudio Gambino, Paolo Pani, Fabio Riccioni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01771
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Source multipoles and energy-momentum tensors for spinning black holes and other compact objects in arbitrary dimensions Massimo Bianchi, Claudio Gambino, Paolo Pani, Fabio Riccioni Abstract Working in momentum space and at linear order in the gravitational coupling, we derive the most general class of energy-momentum tensors associated with a given multipolar structure of the spacetime in arbitrary dimensions, and built out of a mass and an angular momentum, at any order in the spin expansion. In this formalism, we are able to derive directly the full multipolar structure of any solution from the multipole expansion of the energy-momentum tensor, in complete analogy to Newtonian gravity. In particular, we identify the recurrence relations that allow obtaining the multipolar structure of the Kerr and the Myers-Perry black hole solutions, defining source multipoles in a General Relativity context for the first time. For these solutions, we are able to resum the energy-momentum tensor in momentum space at all orders in the angular momentum, and compute its real-space version. In the Kerr case we exactly obtain the matter source found by Israel, namely an equatorial, pressureless thin disk rotating at superluminal speed. For Myers-Perry in five dimensions, the matter distribution is a three-ellipsoid in four spatial dimensions with nontrivial stresses. Remarkably, for any dimensions, the matter configuration is a lower-dimensional distribution which has the same singularity structure as the fully non-linear black-hole solution. Our formalism underscores the advantage of working in momentum space to generate nontrivial matter sources for non-linear spacetimes, and could be used to construct regular non-exotic matter configurations that source spinning black hole solutions or horizonless compact objects with the same multipolar structure as black holes. I Introduction The study of black holes (BHs), particularly rotating ones, has been a cornerstone in understanding the complexities and non-linearities of gravity within the framework of General Relativity. It is hard to overestimate the monumental role that the Kerr solution [ 1 ] – describing the spacetime surrounding a rotating, uncharged BH – plays in astrophysics and in high-energy physics. However, despite its ubiquity across various areas in physics, the precise nature of the matter distribution that generates the Kerr metric remains elusive. This is mainly due to the non-linear nature of the gravitational interaction. In four spacetime dimensions, this problem has been studied for a long time. It is well-known that the matter source of the Schwarzschild metric is a point-like mass located at the origin (which coincides with the singularity of the Schwarzschild spacetime). Furthermore, due to Birkoff’s theorem, any spherically symmetric distribution with compact support smaller than the BH horizon would equally source the Schwarzschild solution and might avoid singularities or other pathologies. In the spinning case, the situation is more complex. The Kerr metric can be interpreted as that arising from a material disk that is rotating about its axis of symmetry, rather than from a spinning particle [ 2 ] . Indeed, in 1970 Israel explicitly computed a source distribution for the Kerr(-Newman [ 2 ] ) metric, in terms of a layer of mass (and charge) distributed over the equatorial disk spanning the ring singularity [ 3 ] . Later, making use of the Kerr-Schild gauge, such result has been proved to be mathematically rigorous by using distribution theory to properly deal with the singular source [ 4 ] . In the uncharged case, this interpretation automatically excises the noncausal parts of the manifold, so that one obtains the source of the causally maximal extension of the vacuum metric. However, such matter distribution is not physical since the disk rotates at superluminal speed and violates the weak energy condition [ 3 ] . There have been various attempts to find non-pathological matter distributions sourcing exactly the Kerr spacetime [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Recently, Ref. [ 9 ] considered a perfect fluid confined inside the horizon that induces a BH geometry which is indistinguishable from the one generated by the Israel matter configuration. However such configurations allow for negative energies violating energy conditions. To the best of our knowledge, a matter distribution sourcing the Kerr spacetime and which is free of singularities or pathologies is currently unknown. In a related context, working in a post-Newtonian approximation, it was recently shown that the infinite tower of multipole moments of the Kerr spacetime do not uniquely characterize the source: there exist several physically motivated matter configurations with multipole moments identical to those of Kerr [ 10 ] . This leaves open the possibility of: i) finding a regular matter distribution that sources the Kerr spacetime and, ii) characterizing BH mimickers [ 11 ] ( i.e. , solutions that resemble the BH spacetime at large distance but might be different at the horizon scale) in terms of their multipolar structure. Inspired by a quantum field theory approach to General Relativity (GR), in this work we take a new route to the problem of finding the matter source of rotating BHs. We work in momentum space and perturbatively in the gravitational coupling, recasting GR as a quantum field theory for a massless spin-2 field. We construct a general class of the energy-momentum tensors (EMTs) describing a spinning point particle in momentum space, to all orders in the particle angular momentum 1 1 1 Our formalism is general and can be extended to multipole moments that are not induced by angular momentum, possibly breaking equatorial or axial symmetry [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . For example, it can account for an intrinsic current quadrupole, mass and stress octupoles, or generic moment tensors. . Since we work at leading order in post-Minkowskian approximation, such construction is fully relativistic and not limited to the description of Newtonian matter configurations. After separating the physical terms from the gauge-dependent ones, we find a one-to-one mapping between the angular momentum expansion of the EMT and the (infinite tower of the) spacetime’s multipole moments, thus providing a recipe for the class of (momentum-space) EMTs associated with a given multipolar structure. Such direct relation between the source properties and the induced gravitational multipoles is in complete analogy to what one is easily able to do in Newtonian gravity, giving for the first time a simple recipe to read the multipole moments without computing the metric as an intermediate step. Such approach leads to an unambiguous definition of source multipole moments in a relativistic context, generalizing the work in [ 10 ] . As we will discuss, this approach has several advantages. First, the framework can be naturally developed in arbitrary dimensions, which allows us to discuss both the Kerr case and its higher-dimensional generalization, the Myers-Perry solution [ 19 ] , and to connect with the new stress multipole moments that exist in spacetime dimensions higher than four [ 20 , 21 ] . Second, working in momentum space allows us to clearly distinguish between local and non-local contributions (to be rigorously defined later), with only the latter affecting the multipole moments. This identification is crucial to obtain a tractable angular-momentum expansion. Remarkably, for Myers-Perry BHs in generic spacetime dimensions (including Kerr in four dimensions), such an expansion of the EMT can be resummed in