Harnessing the Potential of Spatial Statistics for Spatial Omics Data with pasta

Martin Emons, Samuel Gunz, Helena L. Crowell, Izaskun Mallona, Malte Kuehl, Reinhard Furrer, Mark D. Robinson · 2024

Read Harnessing the Potential of Spatial Statistics for Spatial Omics Data with pasta by Martin Emons, Samuel Gunz, Helena L. Crowell, Izaskun Mallona, Malte Kuehl, Reinhard Furrer, Mark D. Robinson (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01561.txt.

Introduction

Martin Emons and colleagues argue that classic spatial statistics is a ready toolkit for spatial omics. New assays map molecules inside tissue while keeping each cell's place. Two technology families produce two data shapes: point patterns from imaging, grids from sequencing. Spatial statistics has handled both shapes for decades.

The paper walks through what those tools offer biology, with honest notes on friction and nuance. A companion vignette, pasta, runs real examples through several R packages. It shows how clustering, spread, and neighborhood measures read out of tissue maps. The authors aim to save biologists from reinventing methods that already exist. Their message is simple: the spatial toolbox is deep, tested, and waiting. Using it well can sharpen what omics maps actually prove.

Catalog record

CREATORMartin Emons, Samuel Gunz, Helena L. Crowell, Izaskun Mallona, Malte Kuehl, Reinhard Furrer, Mark D. Robinson
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01561

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Harnessing the Potential of Spatial Statistics for Spatial Omics Data with pasta Martin Emons, Samuel Gunz, Helena L. Crowell, Izaskun Mallona, Malte Kuehl, Reinhard Furrer, Mark D. Robinson Abstract Spatial omics allow for the molecular characterization of cells in their spatial context. Notably, the two main technological streams, imaging-based and high-throughput sequencing-based, give rise to very different data modalities. The characteristics of the two data types are well known in spatial statistics as point patterns and lattice data . In this perspective, we show the versatility of spatial statistics to quantify biological phenomena from local gene expression to tissue organization. As an example, we describe how to use exploratory metrics to address scientific questions in breast cancer, including cellular co-localization and gene co-expression analysis. We discuss technical concepts like window sampling, homogeneity and weight matrix construction and show their importance. We also provide pasta ( https://robinsonlabuzh.github.io/pasta ), an extensive analysis vignette for spatial statistics both using R and Python packages with further biology-driven applications. Introduction Molecular profiling at spatial resolution Molecular profiling of cells in bulk or at the single-cell level can be accomplished by dissociating organs or tissues. Dissociation may select against certain cell types [ denisenkoSystematicAssessmentTissue2020 , dingSystematicComparisonSinglecell2020 ] and results in the loss of the spatial organization. This limitation is attenuated with spatial profiling techniques, which preserve the cellular spatial organization and range from spatial proteomics [ giesenHighlyMultiplexedImaging2014 , kerenMIBITOFMultiplexedImaging2019 , gutMultiplexedProteinMaps2018 , blackCODEXMultiplexedTissue2021 , tsujikawaQuantitativeMultiplexImmunohistochemistry2017 ] , to spatial transcriptomics based on fluorescent in situ hybridisation [ langer-saferImmunologicalMethodMapping1982 , chenSpatiallyResolvedHighly2015 , janesickHighResolutionMapping2023 ] or on sequencing [ stahlVisualizationAnalysisGene2016 , oliveiraCharacterizationImmuneCell2024 , rodriquesSlideseqScalableTechnology2019 , stickelsHighlySensitiveSpatial2021 , chenSpatiotemporalTranscriptomicAtlas2022 ] , to spatial epigenomics [ luSpatiallyResolvedEpigenomic2022 ] and spatial metabolomics [ angelMatrixAssistedLaserDesorption2013 , zhangMassSpectrometryImaging2023 ] , or multi-omics [ vandereykenMethodsApplicationsSinglecell2023 ] . The technologies and their application in biological research have been the topic of various detailed reviews [ aspSpatiallyResolvedTranscriptomes2020 , moffittEmergingLandscapeSpatial2022 , raoExploringTissueArchitecture2021 , mosesMuseumSpatialTranscriptomics2022 , pallaSpatialComponentsMolecular2022 , bressanDawnSpatialOmics2023 ] . Spatial data modalities have been present in other fields for decades. They originated in mining and forestry and have expanded to other fields such as geography or ecology, and have been approached by spatial statistics methods [ zuurAnalysingEcologicalData2007 , daleSpatialAnalysisGuide2014 , baddeleySpatialPointPatterns2015 , pebesmaSpatialDataScience2023 ] . In this work, we focus on the concepts and application of exploratory statistical approaches for molecular spatial data; our overview also centres on key differences between data modalities that result from current spatial profiling technologies and the different types of questions that can be answered with spatial statistics. In this regard, we complement the ongoing discussion on the challenges in applying spatial statistics to spatial (transcript)omics data [ zormpasMappingTranscriptomeRealizing2023 , mosesVoyagerExploratorySinglecell2023 , gonzalez2025analyzing ] . Data modality is relevant to spatial data analysis Most spatial omics assays can be classified as either high-throughput sequencing (HTS)-based or imaging-based. In HTS-based approaches, positional information is recorded by barcoding a predetermined array of spots or beads. Imaging-based approaches, however, either target the molecules of interest with fluorescent probes, ablate regions stained with a cocktail of antibodies via metal tag readouts, or amplify and sequence target sequences in situ . Several technologies are emerging, but the main trade-offs stem from the resolution, number of features, and sensitivity of the readout [ raoExploringTissueArchitecture2021 , parkSpatialOmicsTechnologies2022 ] . For example, HTS-based approaches aim to profile the entire transcriptome (i.e., untargeted), but come at a resolution determined by the spot size. On the other hand, imaging-based approaches typically describe a lower number of features (i.e., targeted) but show a higher resolution. Note also that the landscape of spatially-resolved molecular technologies is rapidly changing, mostly in the direction of higher resolution for HTS-based methods and higher-plex marker panels for imaging-based approaches (Figure 1 A; Supplementary Table S1 ) [ moffittEmergingLandscapeSpatial2022 , raoExploringTissueArchitecture2021 , rademacherComparisonSpatialTranscriptomics2024 ] . In terms of data analysis, HTS- and imaging-based outputs are quite distinct. HTS-based approaches collect data along regularly spaced spots or beads resulting in a so-called regular lattice . In contrast, imaging-based approaches measure features at exact locations that can be assumed to have originated from a random (stochastic)process known as a point process [ raoExploringTissueArchitecture2021 ] , leading to so-called point patterns. Although a random process might not be the correct assumption in biological development, the representation of point patterns can still be useful when correctly interpreted as we will show later. Thus, we will distinguish between lattice-based and point pattern-based spatial omics data. While the classification is often on the technology (c.f., imaging-based versus HTS-based), we argue that the distinction should lie at the data representation level [ raoExploringTissueArchitecture2021 ] . This is important, since there are technologies that can be represented as both point patterns and lattice data depending on the resolution and data processing. For example, imaging-based data can be processed to describe the location of single transcripts at subcellular resolution ( point pattern ) while also identifying individual cells as either an irregular lattice when using the cell segmentation as the lattice structure or as a point pattern when considering cell centroids. In general, if events of a point pattern are aggregated into specified regions (e.g., transcripts per cell from segmentation), we end up with lattice data (Figure 1 B) [ daleSpatialAnalysisGuide2014 , pebesmaSpatialDataScience2023 , cressieStatisticsSpatialData1993 ] . Lattice and point pattern analysis represent two overlapping streams of spatial statistics Since we can represent some spatial omics datasets as either lattice or point pattern, it is important to further understand the assumptions underlying common data analysis strategies. On the one hand, point pattern analysis assumes that the point locations were generated by a random process, where each point is an event itself, a so-called event-based view of the data; its goal is to study the data generating process [ baddeleySpatialPointPatterns2015 ] .For example, if we are interested in the distribution of one cell type in an image, we would use point pattern methods to quantify this arrangement. On the other hand, one could assume that the locations are fixed and known at the time of sampling and study the associated features at each location via an observation-based view of the data, while recognizing that the observations in the lattice are not independent measurements due to their spatial dependence [ anselinWhatSpecialSpatial1989 ] . For example, in spot-based technologies, locations are predefined. If we want to study a gene expression pattern in such an assay, we should account for the spatial dependence between spots (Figure 1 C). In addition, characterizing the marks (variable) of interest is also important. We consider two broad types of marks associated with spatial locations: categorical (qualitative, e.g. cell types or spatial domains) and numerical (quantitative, e.g. gene expression). In terms of dimensionality, marks can be analyzed one- ( univariate ), two- ( bivariate ) or three or more at a time ( multivariate analysis). Figure 1 C summarizes options to analyze each combination of the type of mark and its dimensionality. Defining characteristics of marks is relevant to choose appropriate metrics for the biological question in mind; e.g., infiltration of cell type A into a region dominated by cell type B is a question involving a categorical bivariate measure (two cell types involved) and can be analyzed as a type of co-localization analysis between type

Read the complete text