Defect Positioning in Combinatorial Metamaterials

Chaviva Sirote-Katz, Yotam M. Y. Feldman, Guy Cohen, Tamás Kálmán, Yair Shokef · 2024

Read Defect Positioning in Combinatorial Metamaterials by Chaviva Sirote-Katz, Yotam M. Y. Feldman, Guy Cohen, Tamás Kálmán, Yair Shokef (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-01227.txt.

Introduction

Chaviva Sirote-Katz and co-authors study in a 2024 math and materials study where stiff defects can be placed in block-built metamaterials. Such materials are grids of bendy blocks, and a loop of blocks that cannot all bend their soft way forms a defect that stiffens the whole. Designers want defects at will, to steer stress.

For some block kinds any defect pattern can be built. In others, rules bind: in three dimensions defect lines must close into loops. Even then, lines of any knotted shape can be made, they show. The map of what is possible guides the design of smart materials.

Catalog record

CREATORChaviva Sirote-Katz, Yotam M. Y. Feldman, Guy Cohen, Tamás Kálmán, Yair Shokef
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-01227

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Defect Positioning in Combinatorial Metamaterials Chaviva Sirote-Katz, Yotam M. Y. Feldman, Guy Cohen, Tamás Kálmán, Yair Shokef Abstract Combinatorial mechanical metamaterials are made of anisotropic, flexible blocks, such that multiple metamaterials may be constructed using a single block type, and the system’s response depends on the frustration (or its absence) due to the mutual orientations of the blocks within the lattice. Specifically, any minimal loop of blocks that may not simultaneously deform in their softest mode defines a mechanical defect at the vertex (in two dimensions) or edge (in three dimensions) that the loop encircles. Defects stiffen the metamaterial, and allow to design the spatial patterns of stress and deformation as the system is externally loaded. We study the ability to place defects at arbitrary positions in metamaterials made of a family of block types that we recently introduced for the square, honeycomb, and cubic lattices. Alongside blocks for which we show that any defect configuration is possible, we identify situations in which not all sets are realizable as defects. One of the restrictions is that in three dimensions, defected edges form closed curves. Even in cases when not all geometries of defect lines are possible, we show how to produce defect lines of arbitrary knottedness. I Introduction In mechanical metamaterials structures repeat in a lattice, such that the geometric deformation of each building block and the resultant interaction between neighboring blocks lead to non-trivial cooperative mechanical responses at the system level Bertoldi et al. 2017 ; Jang et al. 2015 ; Czajkowski et al. 2022 ; Guo et al. 2023 ; Sirote-Katz et al. 2024a ; Kwakernaak and van Hecke 2023 . Conventionally, and inspired by natural crystalline materials, most metamaterials are spatially periodic. However, since metamaterials are artificially designed and then fabricated at the macroscopic scale, one can construct not only any crystal- or quasi-crystal structure, but also arbitrary non-periodic structures. An approach to systematically consider such complex structures is based on anisotropic building blocks positioned on a regular lattice, where each repeating block may be independently oriented along any one of the principal directions of the lattice. The resulting class of metamaterials is referred to as combinatorial metamaterials Coulais et al. 2016 , since the different possible structures are defined by the discrete orientations of all blocks in the lattice, with the total number of possible metamaterials growing exponentially with the number of blocks in the lattice. In a combinatorial metamaterial each building block typically has one soft mode of deformation, and the mutual orientations of neighboring blocks determine if they can all simultaneously deform according to their soft modes, thus forming a mechanically compatible structure with a spatially extended soft mode of deformation. Alternatively, if neighboring blocks frustrate each other’s ability to easily deform, the metamaterial lacks such a global soft mode and is thus more rigid and harder to deform. Frustration may be studied by considering minimal loops of blocks within the lattice; if the blocks surrounding a vertex (in two dimensions) or an edge (in three dimensions) may not deform in harmony, then that vertex or edge constitutes a mechanical defect . Geometric frustration occurs when the symmetry of the lattice is incompatible with the symmetry of the variables defined on it Moessner and Ramirez 2006 , with the classical example being the two-state antiferromagnetic Ising model on the three-fold rotationally symmetric triangular lattice Wannier 1950 . Geometric frustration was classically studied in magnetic materials Bramwell and Gingras 2001 , but more recently also in artificially fabricated metamaterials, such as artificial spin ice Morrison et al. 2013 ; Nisoli et al. 2017 , buckled colloidal monolayers Han et al. 2008 ; Shokef et al. 2011 ; Leoni and Shokef 2017 , colloidal ice Libál et al. 2006 ; Ortiz-Ambriz and Tierno 2016 ; Oğuz et al. 2020 , mechanical metamaterials Kang et al. 2014 ; Udani and Arrieta 2022 and arrays of rotors Mellado et al. 2012 ; Teixeira et al. 2024 . In geometrically frustrated systems all minimal loops are frustrated, and the lattice is defected everywhere within it. However, frustration appears in non-periodic systems as well, most notably in spin glasses Toulouse 1977 ; Anderson 1978 ; Binder and Young 1986 , in which disorder causes some loops to be frustrated, while others are compatible. Combinatorial metamaterials allow to design which loops will be compatible and which frustrated. Thus they are useful for exploring the effects of frustration and defects in physical systems in general Alexander et al. 2012 . Mechanical compatibility leads to combinatorial matching rules between neighboring units, with similar concepts employed in origami Dieleman et al. 2020 . Manipulating the discrete orientations of the building blocks allows to design metamaterials with textured response Coulais et al. 2016 or to use topological defects for spatially steering stress fields Meeussen et al. 2020 ; Pisanty et al. 2021 . Computational methods have been employed to obtain multiple desired responses of a given metamaterial when there are two soft modes per building block Bossart et al. 2021 ; van Mastrigt et al. 2022 ; van Mastrigt et al. 2023 . In this paper we continue the investigation of a unified framework for generating combinatorial metamaterials in two and three dimensions, in which we consider all possible building blocks for the two-dimensional (2D) square and honeycomb lattices, as well as for the three-dimensional (3D) cubic lattice. An accompanying paper Sirote-Katz et al. 2024b introduced this family of block types and studied the compatible metamaterials that may be constructed from them. Specifically, we examined the rate at which the number of compatible metamaterials grows with system size, and the ability to design the deformation texture on the boundary of the lattice. The present paper focuses on incompatible situations and explores whether one can design a metamaterial with an arbitrary spatial distribution of defects within it, meaning any assignment of which vertices or edges are defected and which are not. In Sec. II we systematically present all possible blocks. We refer interested readers to the accompanying paper Sirote-Katz et al. 2024b for experimental realizations of all block types, as well as for a study of how the symmetries of some of them induce holographic order in compatible metamaterials. In the present work, for the square and honeycomb lattices, we introduce a duality relation that sorts the block types into pairs, such that the ability (or inability) to arbitrarily position defects in one block type implies the same for its dual pair, thus cutting by half the number of cases that need to be analyzed. In Sec. III we theoretically identify the conditions for mechanical (in)compatibility. We show that in 2D, defects are singular points, or vertices in the lattice, while in 3D, they are edges in the lattice that connect to form lines that cannot branch or terminate in the bulk, even though they can cross each other. In Sec. IV we investigate the global structure of mechanical incompatibilities, or defects, where there is frustration between the desired deformations of neighboring blocks. We study the possible spatial distributions of point defects for the different 2D blocks, and the possible topological knotted or linked structures that defect lines can form for the various 3D blocks. Both

Read the complete text