Origins of rings in the solar system
B. Sicardy 1, M. El Moutamid 2, S. Renner 1, R. Sfair 3,4,5 and D. Souami 5,6 · 2024
Read Origins of rings in the solar system by B. Sicardy 1, M. El Moutamid 2, S. Renner 1, R. Sfair 3,4,5 and D. Souami 5,6 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00853.txt.
Introduction
Bruno Sicardy and co-workers reviewed the surprising rings of small solar system bodies in a paper printed in 2024. Rings were once thought exclusive to the four giant planets, each with a distinctive system. The last decade broke that rule: dense rings turned up around the Centaur Chariklo, possibly around its cousin Chiron, around the dwarf planet Haumea. Around the distant object Quaoar, whose rings shockingly orbit beyond the Roche limit where loose stuff should clump into moons instead of staying a ring.
The review weighs formation stories and evolutionary paths for each system, from hits and comet-like outbursts to tidal disruption of a former moon. Small-body rings have become a natural laboratory for disk physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | B. Sicardy 1, M. El Moutamid 2, S. Renner 1, R. Sfair 3,4,5 and D. Souami 5,6 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00853
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Origins of rings in the solar system B. Sicardy 1, M. El Moutamid 2, S. Renner 1, R. Sfair 3,4,5 and D. Souami 5,6 Abstract Until about a decade ago, ring systems were only known to exist around giant planets. Each one of the four giant planets harbours its own distinctive and unique system of rings and inner satellites. The past decade has been marked by the unexpected discoveries of dense rings around small objects of the outer solar system: the Centaur object Chariklo (and possibly Chiron), the dwarf planet Haumea and the trans-Neptunian object Quaoar. In the latter case, an additional surprise came from the fact that Quaoar’s rings orbit well beyond the Roche limit of the body. Here, we address the possible origins and evolution of these ring systems. \titlehead Research \subject Astrophysics \corres Bruno Sicardy {fmtext} keywords Rings, Origins, Roche limit 1 Introduction Until the mid-1970s, planetary rings were only known to exist only around Saturn, these have been known since the 17 th century. It is only in the mid-1970s and early 1980s that, using ground-based stellar occultations, rings were discovered in 1977 around Uranus [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] and in 1984 around Neptune [ 4 ] . In the meantime, Jupiter’s tenuous rings were discovered on images taken during the Voyager-1 flyby in 1979 [ 5 ] . Over the last decade, ground-based stellar occultations have revealed the unexpected presence of narrow and dense rings around small bodies of the outer solar system. Firstly, a ring around the Centaur Chariklo, which orbits between Saturn and Uranus, was discovered in 2013 [ 6 ] . This was followed by the discovery in 2017 of a ring around the dwarf planet Haumea [ 7 ] , which orbits at an average heliocentric distance of about 43 au. Most recently, a series of occultations observed between 2018 and 2022 revealed the presence of two rings around Quaoar, a large trans-Neptunian object that also orbits at an average heliocentric distance of \sim 43 AU [ 8 , 9 ] . All the rings discussed here differ by several orders of magnitude in terms of radii and one order of magnitude in terms of heliocentric distances, while encircling very different objects. Moreover, dense and narrow structures embedded in a more diffuse halo have been detected around Chiron, yet another Centaur [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . The nature of this material is still debated. The sharp, time-varying features observed during occultations could indicate a ring system in formation, but no definitive answer to this hypothesis has yet been given. Nearly thirty small solar system bodies have been probed, thus far, using stellar occultations, with sufficient signal-to-noise-ratios to detect ring systems down to an optical depth limit of \tau\sim 1% and width of a few kilometers or more. While the statistical set of bodies is small, the ratio of three confirmed (possibly four) ring systems out of some 30 candidates [ 14 ] 1 1 1 See also https://occultations.ct.utfpr.edu.br/results/ augurs the discovery of many more rings around small bodies in the near future [ 15 ] . This paper examines various scenarios that may explain the origin and evolution of these diverse ring systems. Its scope is to better understand whether rings form by following the same fundamental physical processes, or on the contrary, have very diverse origins. 2 General considerations For each of the aforementioned objects, Table 1 summarizes the main parameters for the bodies and their ring systems (radii, masses, and Roche limits), while Figs. 1 and 2 provide schematic overviews of these systems. Table 1: Physical parameters of the bodies and their ring systems Central object Principal rings Name /ref. Mass Radius Rotational Ring mass ratio Radius Roche limit Maximum (kg) (km) period (h) \mu (Eq. 1 ) (km) (km) (Eq. 4 ) optical depth \tau Jupiter [ 16 ] 1.9\times 10^{27} 71,500 9.92 (0.05 - 5) \times 10^{-21} 122,000 - 129,000 210,000 8\times 10^{-6} Saturn [ 17 ] 5.7\times 10^{26} 60,300 10.7 3\times 10^{-8} 74,500 - 137,000 140,000 >4 Uranus [ 18 , 19 ] 8.7\times 10^{25} 25,600 17.2 2\times 10^{-10} 42,000 - 51,000 74,000 8 Neptune [ 20 ] 1.0\times 10^{26} 24,800 16.1 <10^{-10} Adams/arcs: 62,900 78,000 0.003/0.1 Le Verrier: 53,200 0.003 Chariklo [ 21 , 22 ] 7.0\times 10^{18} 125 7.00 10^{-6} C1R: 386 320 0.4 C2R: 400 >0.1 Chiron [ 12 , 23 , 13 ] 4.8\times 10^{18} 98 5.92 10^{-6} 325, 425 290 0.4 Haumea [ 7 ] 4\times 10^{21} 800 3.92 2\times 10^{-7} H1R: 2287 2660 0.1 Quaoar [ 8 , 9 ] 1.2\times 10^{21} 545 17.7 <2\times 10^{-8} Q1R: 4057 1780 0.25 Q2R: 2520 0.01 Notes. For the giant planets, the radii are equatorial, for the small objects, they are volumetric equivalent. Only the principal rings of the giant planets are considered here. Except for Saturn and Uranus, the estimation of the mass ratio \mu is very uncertain. The parameters of Chiron’s system are very uncertain due to the lack of information on the nature of the detected material. 2.1 Ring mass The rings considered here represent a very small fractional mass \mu of the central body, \mu=\frac{m_{\rm r}}{M}\ll 1\,, (1) where m_{\rm r} is the mass of the rings and M is the mass of the central body. For instance, Saturn’s ring mass is estimated to be 1.5~\times~10^{19} kg, i.e. \mu\sim 3\times~10^{-8} [ 24 ] . If accreted, and assuming a density of \rho~=~400 kg m -3 (typical of the small inner satellites of Saturn [ 25 ] ), this would create an icy satellite of radius \sim 200 km only. The mass of Uranus’ rings is estimated to 2\times 10^{16} kg, or \mu\sim 2\times 10^{-10} [ 26 , 27 ] , corresponding to an icy satellite of radius \sim 20 km. As for Neptune’s ring mass, no rough estimates, not even to an order of magnitude can be given. Nonetheless, data suggest that it is significantly smaller than that of Uranus’ rings [ 20 ] . An extreme case is that of Jupiter’s rings, as this dusty tenuous feature might have a ring to planet mass-ratio value as small as \mu\sim(0.05-5)\times 10^{-21} (see Section 3 ). In regards to the newly discovered rings around small bodies, for which most questions remain open, mass estimates are difficult because detailed observations or robust modellings of their dynamics are not yet available. Nonetheless, a rough estimate of 10 13 kg is given for Chariklo’s rings [ 28 , 29 ] , yielding \mu\sim 10^{-6} , corresponding to an icy satellite of radius \sim 2 km. For the other rings, we assume that their dense parts have all comparable surface densities, in order of magnitude. Thus, we apply a simple rule where the ring mass is proportional to the surface area of these dense parts. Considering that Chariklo’s and Haumea’s rings have widths of 6 km and 70 km, respectively [ 22 , 7 ] , and using the radii given in Table 1 , Haumea’s ring mass can be estimated to roughly \sim 10^{15} kg. This corresponds to \mu\sim 2\times 10^{-7} and an icy satellite of about 5 km in radius. As for Quaoar’s rings,