A Bayesian Model of Underreporting for Sexual Assault on College Campuses

Casey Bradshaw, David M. Blei · 2024

Read A Bayesian Model of Underreporting for Sexual Assault on College Campuses by Casey Bradshaw, David M. Blei (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00823.txt.

Introduction

American colleges must publish how many sexual assaults are reported on campus each year, but the published number mixes two unknowns: how many assaults happened, and what share victims reported. Casey Bradshaw and David Blei untangle the two with a hierarchical Bayesian model in a 2024 paper.

National crime statistics supply prior beliefs that break the tie between a quiet campus and a silent one. A Hamiltonian Monte Carlo sampler then estimates, school by school, both the reporting rate and the true incidence behind the 2014 to 2019 disclosures. Reporting rates rose across the period for the overall college population, the authors find, but the depth of underreporting varies widely between schools. That spread, they warn, should change how each campus reads its own crime statistics.

Catalog record

CREATORCasey Bradshaw, David M. Blei
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00823

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Bayesian Model of Underreporting for Sexual Assault on College Campuses Casey Bradshaw, David M. Blei Abstract In an effort to quantify and combat sexual assault, US colleges and universities are required to disclose the number of reported sexual assaults on their campuses each year. However, many instances of sexual assault are never reported to authorities, and consequently the number of reported assaults does not fully reflect the true total number of assaults that occurred; the reported values could arise from many combinations of reporting rate and true incidence. In this paper we estimate these underlying quantities via a hierarchical Bayesian model of the reported number of assaults. We use informative priors, based on national crime statistics, to act as a tiebreaker to help distinguish between reporting rates and incidence. We outline a Hamiltonian Monte Carlo (HMC) sampling scheme for posterior inference regarding reporting rates and assault incidence at each school, and apply this method to campus sexual assault data from 2014-2019. Results suggest an increasing trend in reporting rates for the overall college population during this time. However, the extent of underreporting varies widely across schools. That variation has implications for how individual schools should interpret their reported crime statistics. and ?? Department of Statistics, Columbia University, ??, ?? 1 Introduction Sexual assault on college campuses is a pressing public health concern in the United States, prompting government action such as the 2014 formation of the White House Task Force to Protect Students from Sexual Assault ( Obama, 2014 ) and the "It’s on us" awareness campaign ( Somanader, 2014 ) . Per the Clery Act of 1990, US colleges and universities are required to report annual crime statistics for their campuses and adjacent areas. These crime statistics include the number of reported sexual assaults, but because sexual assault is widely believed to be underreported, these figures do not tell the whole story. The number of reported assaults in the Clery data could arise from many different combinations of reporting rates and true underlying numbers of assaults. Without further assumptions, it is equally plausible that a given school has a large number of assaults and a low reporting rate, or few assaults and a high reporting rate. To estimate the true incidence and reporting rates of sexual assault in the US college population, we construct a hierarchical Bayesian model of the reported data, together with a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling scheme for posterior inference. More generally, underreported count data arises in many disciplines, with applications including criminology ( Moreno and Giron, 1998 ; Fernández-Fontelo et al., 2019 ) as well as epidemiology ( Bailey et al., 2005 ; Bracher and Held, 2021 ) , traffic safety ( Kumara and Chin, 2005 ; Ma and Li, 2010 ) , and economics ( Winkelmann, 1996 ; Fader and Hardie, 2000 ) . The central challenge in such problems is to disentangle the per-school reporting rate from the true latent counts. This issue can be remedied either through the use of validation data not subject to underreporting, or by using domain knowledge to assign more informative prior distributions to latent variables. In the case of campus sexual assault, fully observed validation data is unavailable, and so we use national crime statistics as a source of external information. The absence of fully observed validation data also has implications for model assessment. Without knowledge of the true total number of assaults, we use predictive checks applied to held-out data to demonstrate the fitted model’s compatibility with the data. In general, we find that inference for the latent total number of assaults and reporting rate at a given school offer a clearer picture of the campus environment than the reported figures alone. In particular, these estimates can suggest the relative contributions of reporting rate and incidence to year-over-year changes in the reported number of assaults. This is a relevant line of inquiry, given that ex ante an increase in the reported number of assaults could equally be explained by an increase in the reporting rate (a positive outcome, indicating that students are aware of campus support resources) or an increase in the true total number of assaults (a bad outcome). The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 reviews related work, followed by an overview of the dataset in Section 3 . The proposed modeling methodology is outlined in Section 4 . Section 5 discusses modeling results and insights, and Section 6 offers concluding remarks and directions for future work. 2 Related Literature There are various perspectives on underreported count data. Some studies consider underreporting as a type of censoring. In this formulation, each observed value is possibly right-censored and has an accompanying latent censoring indicator. de Oliveira, Loschi and Assunção (2017) takes this view and assigns a covariate-dependent prior distribution to the latent censoring indicators, including the censoring indicators as a target for posterior inference. Underreporting also has conceptual overlap with positive-unlabeled (PU) learning. In PU learning, data consist of labeled positive cases and unlabeled cases which may be positive or negative ( Letouzey, Denis and Gilleron, 2000 ) . The recorded number of positive cases is thus a lower bound for the true number of positive cases, which can be viewed as an example of underreporting. The application of PU learning techniques to underreported data is explored in Shanmugam and Pierson (2021) and Wu et al. (2023) . Within the broader literature on underreported count data models, one particular line of work is most relevant to modeling reports of sexual assault. These modeling approaches begin with an assumption that the latent true number of events, z , follows a Poisson distribution with rate parameter \lambda . It is common to further suppose that each of these z -many events may or may not be reported, independently of all others, with reporting probability p . The number of reported events x , where x\leq z , is the data value we observe. Moreno and Giron (1998) articulates the identifiability issue in this setup: marginally, the observed data x_{1},\dots,x_{n} follow a \textrm{Poisson}(\lambda p) distribution, so without further constraints or assumptions, one cannot distinguish among the possible pairs (\lambda,p) with the same product. Moreno and Giron (1998) further demonstrate that placing uninformative prior distributions on \lambda and p is insufficient to produce useful inference. For instance, the choice of a uniform prior on p and a Jaynes ( Jaynes, 1968 ) or Jeffreys ( Jeffreys, 1946 ) prior on \lambda results in infinite posterior expectations for \lambda and z given the observed data. In some research applications this identifiability issue is remedied through the use of validation data not subject to underreporting ( Powers, Gerlach and Stamey, 2010 ; Dvorzak and Wagner, 2016 ) . An alternative approach is to use external information to assign informative prior distributions, as Schmertmann and Gonzaga (2018) and Stoner, Economou and Drummond Marques da Silva (2019) do for the reporting probability. Because external information is available regarding both the incidence and reporting rate of sexual assault, we take this latter approach, choosing informative priors for both components of the model. Earlier work on underreporting models explored the somewhat simpler case of i.i.d. observations governed by

Read the complete text