Detecting entanglement and nonlocality with minimum observable length

Zhuo Chen, Fei Shi, Qi Zhao · 2024

Read Detecting entanglement and nonlocality with minimum observable length by Zhuo Chen, Fei Shi, Qi Zhao (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00795.txt.

Introduction

Zhuo Chen, Fei Shi, and Qi Zhao published a physics paper in 2024 on how global a measurement must be to prove entanglement or nonlocality. Their measure, detection length, counts how far the measurement reaches across a system. The team extends that frame to many kinds of entanglement and nonlocality. They build an analytic model for the needed length in set cases.

Using optimization tools, they craft witnesses and Bell tests tailored to a chosen minimal length. Those give upper bounds for given states. Noise checks show that shorter-length witnesses can outperform longer ones in some conditions. The work offers a sharper way to benchmark quantum devices.

Catalog record

CREATORZhuo Chen, Fei Shi, Qi Zhao
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00795

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Detecting entanglement and nonlocality with minimum observable length Zhuo Chen, Fei Shi, Qi Zhao Abstract Quantum entanglement and nonlocality are foundational to quantum technologies, driving quantum computation, communication, and cryptography innovations. To benchmark the capabilities of these quantum techniques, efficient detection and accurate quantification methods are indispensable. This paper focuses on the concept of “detection length”–—a metric that quantifies the extent of measurement globality required to verify entanglement or nonlocality. We extend the detection length framework to encompass various entanglement categories and nonlocality phenomena, providing a comprehensive analytical model to determine detection lengths for specified forms of entanglement. Furthermore, we exploit semidefinite programming techniques to construct entanglement witnesses and Bell’s inequalities tailored to specific minimal detection lengths, offering an upper bound for detection lengths in given states. By assessing the noise robustness of these witnesses,we demonstrate that witnesses with shorter detection lengths can exhibit superior performance under certain conditions. I Introduction Quantum entanglement and nonlocality are recognized as essential resources in various quantum technologies, including but not limited to the quantum computational speed-up [ 18 , 42 ] , quantum communication [ 41 , 38 ] , and quantum cryptography [ 36 , 45 , 37 ] . These phenomena are significant for the realization of a large-scale, functional quantum computer [ 40 ] . Various classes of entanglement together with nonlocality have attracted significant interest in recent research, particularly for multipartite systems [ 43 , 4 , 44 , 14 ] . For the practical application of quantum entanglement and nonlocality, it is crucial to efficiently detect and accurately quantify these quantum resources [ 39 , 66 , 61 , 65 , 67 ] . Consider a cryptography task involving a multi-party quantum system as an example model, where each party possesses a component of the system and does not trust the others. Assume that tasks, including decoding information from a quantum system [ 50 , 10 ] , sharing secret quantum information [ 9 , 48 ] , or verifying the structure of a shared quantum network [ 49 , 47 ] , requires detecting entanglement properties within the system. Then a natural question emerges: What is the minimum number of parties required to simultaneously participate in each measurement to detect entanglement of the whole system and detailed structure? The answer to this question depends on the characteristics of the entangled quantum system: some types of entanglement may need global measurements that engage the entire system simultaneously. In contrast, others may only require measurements that involve a small number of parties for detection [ 59 , 64 , 63 , 60 , 57 , 2 ] . There is substantial interest in characterizing entanglement or nonlocality with the minimal required parties. Previous literature has presented several case studies [ 62 , 3 , 58 , 56 , 16 , 51 ] . However, a general analytical framework remains to be proposed. In practice, during the experimental implementation of entanglement detection, the impact of environmental noise on the detection outcomes is ubiquitous, particularly within multipartite systems. In global measurements involving all the parties, an error in even a single party can result in a wrong outcome. On the contrary, we demonstrate that local measurements are generally more resistant to noise compared to the all-encompassing global measurements. While local measurements offer a more reliable method for assessing entanglement and nonlocality, local few-body measurements may fail to capture the global information of the underlying states and thus fail to detect them. A profound comprehension of the trade-off between detection capability and noise robustness is crucial for enhancing the efficiency of experimental protocols that involve entanglement and nonlocality. In this context, the concept of “detection length” emerges as a critical metric [ 2 ] , which represents the degree of “globality” of the measurements required to ascertain the presence of entanglement or nonlocality. Our paper extends the detection length framework to encompass diverse entanglement categories and nonlocality phenomena, clarifying the relationships among different detection lengths. Utilizing our analytical model, the detection length for any given form of entanglement can be determined, providing a straightforward metric for entanglement. Furthermore, we propose novel semidefinite programming (SDP) techniques to construct entanglement witnesses and Bell’s inequalities with specific minimal detection lengths, which is also capable of providing an upper bound of detection length for given states. Incorporating global depolarizing noise and bit-flip error models, we assess the noise robustness across various witnesses, finding that those with shorter detection lengths exhibit superior performance under certain conditions. Collectively, these contributions enhance our understanding of quantum entanglement and nonlocality by offering refined quantitative measures for assessing the presence and magnitude of these quantum properties. II Theoretical formulations We denote {\cal H}:=\otimes_{i=1}^{n}{\cal H}_{i} as the n -partite Hilbert space, and {\cal D} as the set of all density matrices on {\cal H} . Let S be a proper subset of [n]:=\{1,2,\ldots,n\} , then we denote {\cal H}_{S}:=\otimes_{j\in S}{\cal H}_{j} , and \rho_{S} as the marginal of \rho\in{\cal D} on S , i.e., \rho_{S}:=\mathop{\rm Tr}_{\overline{S}}\rho , where \overline{S}=[n]\setminus S . A pure state |\psi\rangle\in{\cal H} is product state if it can be written as |\psi\rangle=|\alpha\rangle_{1}\otimes|\beta\rangle_{2}\otimes\cdots\otimes|\gamma\rangle_{n} , where |*\rangle_{i}\in{\cal H}_{i} for 1\leq i\leq n . A pure state |\psi\rangle\in{\cal H} is biproduct state with respect to the bipartition S|\overline{S} , or biproduct state on S|\overline{S} for short, if it can be written as |\psi\rangle=|\phi\rangle_{S}\otimes|\varphi\rangle_{\overline{S}} , where |\phi\rangle_{S}\in{\cal H}_{S} , and |\varphi\rangle_{\overline{S}}\in{\cal H}_{\overline{S}} . A mixed state \rho\in{\cal D} is called fully separable ( biseparable on S|\overline{S} ) if it can be written as a mixture of product states (biproduct states on S|\overline{S} ), i.e., \rho=\sum_{i}p_{i}|\psi_{i}\rangle\!\langle\psi_{i}| , where each |\psi_{i}\rangle is a product state (biproduct state on S|\overline{S} ). A mixed state \rho\in{\cal D} is called biseparable if it can be written as a mixture of biproduct states, where each constituent may be biproduct with respect to different bipartitions. A state \rho\in{\cal D} is called entangled (entangled on S|\overline{S} ) if it is not fully separable (biseparable on S|\overline{S} ), and \rho is called genuinely entangled if it is not biseparable. We denote {\cal S}_{k} as the set of all k -subsets of [n] , i.e., |{\cal S}_{k}|=\binom{n}{k} , and |S|=k for every S\in{\cal S}_{k} . Given a state \rho\in{\cal D} and a set of subsets {\cal S}=\{S_{1},S_{2},\cdots,S_{k}\} with S_{i}\subset[n] , the compatibility set is defined as the collection of all density matrices \sigma\in\mathcal{D} that share the same marginals with \rho on every subset S_{i}\in{\cal S} : {\cal C}(\rho,{\cal S})=\{\sigma\in{\cal D}\mid\sigma_{S_{i}}=\rho_{S_{i}},\ \forall\ 1\leq i\leq k\}. (1) If certain constraints are imposed on the compatibility set, then the properties of \rho can be inferred from its marginals. For example, if {\cal C}(\rho,\mathcal{S}) contains only genuinely entangled states, then we say {\cal S} can detect \rho ’s GME, indicating that measurements on the subsystems in {\cal S} are sufficient to identify \rho ’s GME [ 2 ] . The GME detection length is defined as [ 2 ] : l_{GME}(\rho):=\mathop{\rm min}_{{\cal S}}\big\{\mathop{\rm max}({\cal S})~\big|~\text{${\cal S}$ detects $\rho$'s GME}\big\}\,, (2) where \mathop{\rm max}{({\cal S})}:=\mathop{\rm max}_{S\in{\cal S}}|S| is the maximum size of a subset in {\cal S} . In other words, the GME detection length of a genuinely entangled state quantifies the minimum observable length necessary to

Read the complete text