Intermediate Outputs Are More Sensitive Than You Think

Tao Huang Qingyu Huang Jiayang Meng · 2024

Read Intermediate Outputs Are More Sensitive Than You Think by Tao Huang Qingyu Huang Jiayang Meng (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00696.txt.

Introduction

Tao Huang, Qingyu Huang, and Jiayang Meng measure privacy risk inside vision models in a paper from two thousand twenty-four. Deep vision models process sensitive images, and their hidden layer outputs can leak information. Standard risk checks focus on final outputs or run costly attack simulations.

Their framework uses degrees of freedom to gauge how much information each layer retains. It pairs that with the rank of a sensitivity matrix to measure how strongly a layer reacts to input changes. Together these give a layer-by-layer privacy risk profile with no attacks needed. Experiments on real data sets confirmed the approach. The authors say it reveals risks that output-only checks miss.

Catalog record

CREATORTao Huang Qingyu Huang Jiayang Meng
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00696

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Intermediate Outputs Are More Sensitive Than You Think Tao Huang Qingyu Huang Jiayang Meng Abstract The increasing reliance on deep computer vision models that process sensitive data has raised significant privacy concerns, particularly regarding the exposure of intermediate results in hidden layers. While traditional privacy risk assessment techniques focus on protecting overall model outputs, they often overlook vulnerabilities within these intermediate representations. Current privacy risk assessment techniques typically rely on specific attack simulations to assess risk, which can be computationally expensive and incomplete. This paper introduces a novel approach to measuring privacy risks in deep computer vision models based on the Degrees of Freedom (DoF) and sensitivity of intermediate outputs, without requiring adversarial attack simulations. We propose a framework that leverages DoF to evaluate the amount of information retained in each layer and combines this with the rank of the Jacobian matrix to assess sensitivity to input variations. This dual analysis enables systematic measurement of privacy risks at various model layers. Our experimental validation on real-world datasets demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach in providing deeper insights into privacy risks associated with intermediate representations. 1 Introduction Data-driven technologies have seen rapid growth, leading to increased attention on the privacy implications of deep computer vision models Voulodimos et al. (2018) ; Chai et al. (2021) ; Brunetti et al. (2018) ; Gopalakrishnan et al. (2017) that often process large, sensitive datasets. Although these models excel at extracting meaningful patterns from visual data, they may inadvertently expose sensitive information from the underlying training data, thereby posing significant privacy risks Yeom et al. (2018) ; Orekondy et al. (2017) ; Papernot et al. (2018) . This issue becomes particularly relevant in scenarios involving gradient inversion Huang et al. (2021) ; Jeon et al. (2021) ; Hatamizadeh et al. (2022) ; Zhang et al. (2022) or membership inference attacks Hu et al. (2022) ; Shokri et al. (2017) ; Carlini et al. (2022) ; Truex et al. (2019) ; Ye et al. (2022) , where adversaries aim to reconstruct or infer sensitive data from the model’s intermediate outputs. A substantial body of research has proposed various methods for measuring privacy risks and enhancing data protection, such as differential privacy Dwork (2006) ; Dwork (2008) ; Abadi et al. (2016) ; Wei et al. (2020) , k-anonymity Mahanan et al. (2021) ; Saxena (2022) ; Slijepčević et al. (2021) , and l-diversity Parameshwarappa et al. (2021) ; Ashkouti et al. (2021) ; Mehta and Rao (2022) ; Gangarde et al. (2021) . However, these approaches primarily focus on the overall model outputs and often overlook the privacy vulnerabilities within the intermediate layers of deep learning models. Intermediate representations are essential for capturing and processing information, yet they may retain substantial details about the input data, increasing the risk of privacy leakage Sun et al. (2021) ; Mireshghallah et al. (2020) . Many privacy assessment methods rely on attack simulations UcedaVelez and Morana (2015) ; Johnson et al. (2018) , such as model inversion, gradient inversion, and membership inference attacks (MIA), to evaluate whether an adversary could exploit intermediate results. However, these attack-based methods face significant limitations. First, they require additional attack simulations, which are often computationally expensive, particularly in large-scale computer vision systems. Second, these methods are inherently incomplete; exhaustively testing for all potential attacks is impractical, limiting their reliability for comprehensive privacy risk assessment. To address these limitations, there is a need for more systematic and computationally efficient privacy risk assessment methods for deep computer vision models. In this paper, we propose a method for classifying the sensitivity levels of intermediate outputs without relying on adversarial simulations. Our approach assesses sensitivity levels during the model’s training phase, allowing model developers to identify and evaluate the sensitivity of intermediate results in real-time, thereby enabling systematic privacy risk assessment. We introduce the concept of Degrees of Freedom (DoF) Campbell (1975) ; Toraldo di Francia (1969) ; Pal and Vaidyanathan (2010) , commonly used in statistical modeling to quantify model complexity, as a novel metric for privacy risk classification. Layers with lower DoF may retain more specific details about the input data, potentially posing a greater privacy risk. To fully capture the privacy risks, we also analyze the sensitivity of intermediate results to input perturbations, which we quantify using the rank of the Jacobian matrix. This combined analysis provides a comprehensive framework for assessing the privacy risks of intermediate outputs without the need for attack simulations. The primary research question we address in this study is: How can data privacy levels be classified based on the Degrees of Freedom and sensitivity of intermediate outputs in a deep learning model? We develop a framework that leverages both DoF of intermediate layer outputs and the Jacobian rank with respect to input data to classify privacy sensitivity across layers. This approach offers a deeper understanding of the risks associated with intermediate layers, often neglected in conventional privacy assessment methodologies, and serves as an efficient alternative to attack-based classifications. Our contributions are threefold: • Introduction of Degrees of Freedom as a Metric for Privacy Risk Assessment: We propose using the Degrees of Freedom (DoF) of intermediate layer outputs as a novel means to quantify information retention about input data, thereby offering a new perspective on privacy leakage risks at various stages in deep computer vision models. • Development of a Privacy Classification Framework Based on DoF and Jacobian Rank: We present a privacy classification framework that combines DoF analysis with the sensitivity of intermediate outputs, measured via Jacobian rank. This dual approach provides a more detailed and accurate privacy risk assessment than current methods. • Experimental Validation on Real-World Datasets: We validate the effectiveness of our framework through empirical testing on real-world datasets. Our results illustrate how the combination of DoF and Jacobian rank offers deeper insights into privacy risks associated with intermediate layers in deep computer vision models. 2 Related Work 2.1 Overview of Data Privacy Metrics A significant body of research has focused on developing privacy-measuring and privacy-preserving techniques to mitigate the risks of sensitive data exposure in deep learning models. Differential privacy (DP) Dwork (2006) ; Dwork (2008) ; Abadi et al. (2016) ; Wei et al. (2020) is one of the most widely adopted frameworks, ensuring that individual records within a dataset do not significantly affect the model’s output. The primary strength of differential privacy is its mathematical rigor. DP provides formal guarantees about the privacy of individual data points. K-anonymity Mahanan et al. (2021) ; Saxena (2022) ; Slijepčević et al. (2021) ensures that an individual’s data cannot be distinguished from at least k-1 other individuals in the dataset, while l-diversity Parameshwarappa et al. (2021) ; Ashkouti et al. (2021) ; Mehta and Rao (2022) ; Gangarde et al. (2021) ensures that sensitive information within these groups maintains diversity. These methods are relatively simple to implement and can be effective in structured datasets. However, they are often less applicable to unstructured data commonly used in computer vision tasks and may be susceptible to attacks such as attribute inference or background knowledge attacks. While these methods offer useful privacy measurements, they primarily focus on the final outputs of a model or the data used during training. They

Read the complete text