Characterizing the Effects of Environmental Exposures on Social Mobility: Bayesian Semi-parametrics for Principal Stratification

Dafne Zorzetto, Paolo Dalla Torre ∗, Sonia Petrone, Francesca Dominici, Falco J. Bargagli-Stoffi · 2024

Read Characterizing the Effects of Environmental Exposures on Social Mobility: Bayesian Semi-parametrics for Principal Stratification by Dafne Zorzetto, Paolo Dalla Torre ∗, Sonia Petrone, Francesca Dominici, Falco J. Bargagli-Stoffi (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00311.txt.

Introduction

Dafne Zorzetto and four co-authors build a statistical method for asking how air pollution shapes social mobility, in this 2024 paper. Education is the tricky middle step: pollution may cut schooling, and schooling drives later mobility, so a simple comparison mixes the two paths. Their approach sorts people into hidden groups defined by how their schooling would respond to exposure.

The new Bayesian method models outcomes with flexible mixtures, which sharpens guesses for the unseen alternative world that causal work depends on. Simulations show it beats existing options. Applied to data from more than three thousand United States counties, the method finds mobility falls about five percent where pollution also cuts schooling. A smaller drop appears even where schooling is untouched, hinting at other paths from dirty air to stalled lives.

Catalog record

CREATORDafne Zorzetto, Paolo Dalla Torre ∗, Sonia Petrone, Francesca Dominici, Falco J. Bargagli-Stoffi
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00311

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Characterizing the Effects of Environmental Exposures on Social Mobility: Bayesian Semi-parametrics for Principal Stratification Dafne Zorzetto, Paolo Dalla Torre ∗, Sonia Petrone, Francesca Dominici, Falco J. Bargagli-Stoffi Abstract Principal stratification provides a robust causal inference framework for the adjustment of post-treatment variables when comparing the effects of a treatment in health and social sciences. In this paper, we introduce a novel Bayesian nonparametric model for principal stratification, leveraging the dependent Dirichlet process to flexibly model the distribution of potential outcomes. By incorporating confounders and potential outcomes for the post-treatment variable in the Bayesian mixture model for the final outcome, our approach improves the accuracy of missing data imputation and allows for the characterization of treatment effects across strata defined based on the values of the post-treatment variable. We assess the performance of our method through a Monte Carlo simulation study where we compare the proposed method with state-of-the-art Bayesian method in principal stratification. Finally, we leverage the proposed method to evaluate the principal causal effects of exposure to air pollution on social mobility in the US on strata defined by educational attainment. , , , and ?? Data Science Institute, Brown University , ?? ?? Department of Decision Sciences, Bocconi University , ?? ?? Department of Decision Sciences, Bocconi University, ?? ?? Department of Biostatistics, Harvard University, ?? ?? Department of Biostatistics, University of California Los Angeles , ?? 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivation Principal stratification provides a robust causal inference framework for the adjustment of post-treatment variables when comparing the effects of a treatment ( Frangakis and Rubin 2002 ) . The post-treatment variables act as intermediate variables between treatment and outcome, providing valuable insights into causal mechanisms. This framework focuses on classifying subjects into principal strata based on the joint values of the potential outcome for the post-treatment variable at different treatment levels ( Antonelli et al. 2023 ) . These strata represent inherent latent characteristics that remain unaffected by treatment, enabling causal analysis through the definition of principal causal effects ( Rubin 1974a ) . The literature distinguishes between the dissociative effect —representing the treatment effect for the stratum composed of subjects with the post-treatment variable that is not affected by the treatment—and the associative effects , which captures the treatment effect for strata where the post-treatment variable exhibits significant changes between the different treatment levels ( Frangakis and Rubin 2002 ; Mealli and Mattei 2012 ) . Most studies focus on binary treatments and post-treatment variables, simplifying analyses to four combinations ( Angrist, Imbens and Rubin 1996 ) . The extension to continuous post-treatment variables poses interpretational and inferential challenges due to infinite possible strata. Solutions include dichotomizing post-treatment variables ( Sjölander et al. 2009 ; Jiang, Yang and Ding 2022 ) , parametric or semiparametric modeling ( Jin and Rubin 2008 ; Conlon, Taylor and Elliott 2014 ; Lu, Jiang and Ding 2023 ) , and nonparametric approaches ( Schwartz, Li and Mealli 2011 ; Zorzetto et al. 2024a ; Kim and Zigler 2024 ) . Recently, Antonelli et al. 2023 introduced a Bayesian methodology to tackle the continuous treatment issue, advancing nonparametric modeling in this domain. 1.2 Contributions In this paper, we define a novel Bayesian approach for principal stratification that leverages the flexibility of the Dirichlet process ( Ferguson 1973 ) as prior. Specifically, we exploit the dependent Dirichlet process (DDP) ( Quintana et al. 2022 ) to define a highly adaptable distribution for the potential outcome for the final outcome, that depends on the confounders, the potential outcome for the post-treatment variable, and the treatment variable. The current state-of-the-art for Bayesian nonparametric (BNP) in the context of principal stratification with a binary treatment can be found in the works by Schwartz, Li and Mealli 2011 and Zorzetto et al. 2024a . These models, as well as the one we propose in this paper, are all designed for a principal stratification framework where the post-treatment variable and the outcome are continuous, and the treatment is a binary random variable, however they differ in the definition of the nonparametric priors. First, our proposed model introduces the DDP as prior for the parameters in the potential outcome for final outcome model distribution, while the Schwartz, Li and Mealli 2011 and Zorzetto et al. 2024a ’s models have a DDP prior for the parameters in the post-treatment variable model distribution. Second, the dependency on the covariates in the DDP differs in the three models: in the Schwartz, Li and Mealli 2011 ’s model the dependence involves only the atoms, on the model proposed by Zorzetto et al. 2024a the confounders are included in the weights of the mixture to improve the imputation of missing data. In our proposed model the dependence on the confounders is both on the atoms and on the weights. The double dependence on confounders in our proposed model is motivated by several key reasons: (i) the dependence in the weights enables fair and informed imputation of missing data, as demonstrated by Zorzetto et al. 2024b and Zorzetto et al. 2024a in various causal inference settings; (ii) incorporating confounders and the potential outcomes of the post-treatment variable within the mixture regression enhances the model’s adaptability; and (iii) the flexible structure of the mixture model for the potential outcomes for the final outcome relaxes the rigid assumptions previously imposed on the distribution of the post-treatment variable’s potential outcomes—e.g., the linear regression model—, that induces a mixture distribution for the predictive distribution used in imputing missing data for post-treatment variable. 1.3 Organization of the article Following this introduction, Section 2 introduces the motivating application and the causal real-data questions that we aim to address. In Section 3 , we introduce the notation, assumptions that we employ throughout the paper, and the principal causal effects. We conduct a simulation study to assess the performance of our proposed model in different scenarios in Section 5 . The description of the dataset and the results of the application of are reported in Section 6 . Section 7 concludes the paper with a discussion of the proposed model and further research. 2 Motivating application 2.1 Searching for the determinants of the decline in social mobility Recent empirical evidence suggests a concerning trend in US social mobility, with studies documenting stagnation or decline in intergenerational economic mobility ( Piketty, Saez and Zucman 2018 ; Song et al. 2019 ) . In a very influential work, Chetty et al. 2017 found that the fraction of children who earn more than their parents has fallen from approximately 90% for children born in 1940 to 50% for children born in the 1980s. The decline in intergenerational mobility raises significant societal concerns, as reduced economic mobility can weaken social cohesion. In fact, as argued by Stiglitz 2012 , the growing inequality often equates to diminishing equality of opportunity and exacerbating economic and social inequalities. Recent literature has focused on searching for the root causes of the decline in economic mobility. While multiple factors—such as cultural ( Platt 2019 ) , demographic ( Van Bavel et al. 2011 ; Salvanes 2023 ) , geographical ( Connor and Storper 2020 ; Salvanes 2023 ) , labor market ( Choi, Kim and Kim 2023 ) , welfare state

Read the complete text