Intermittent turbulent gusts lift eagles
Dipendra Gupta, David Brandes, Michael J Lanzone, Tricia Miller, Gregory P Bewley · 2024
Read Intermittent turbulent gusts lift eagles by Dipendra Gupta, David Brandes, Michael J Lanzone, Tricia Miller, Gregory P Bewley (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-00231.txt.
Introduction
Gupta and co-authors show how gust bursts, not smooth winds, lift glide eagles. Rough air grounds craft and costs force to fight in flight. Wild fliers still ride rough days with seeming ease. How glide birds meet short gust bursts had stayed dim. Past work dwelt on big, smooth flows in heat or slope glide. Tags on gold eagles showed short up-push bursts in flight.
Those bursts hint the birds seek strong, rare up gusts by choice. Lift shifts in them hit 25 spreads past the mean mark. That tops three times the pull of the world in size. Such force breaks a tale of gust dodge or soft cure. Burst shapes mimic swirl moves in rough air flow. At short spans, bursts skew up more than stock rough flow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dipendra Gupta, David Brandes, Michael J Lanzone, Tricia Miller, Gregory P Bewley |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-00231
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Intermittent turbulent gusts lift eagles Dipendra Gupta, David Brandes, Michael J Lanzone, Tricia Miller, Gregory P Bewley Abstract Turbulence grounds aircraft and combating it in flight requires energy, yet volant wildlife fly effortlessly even on windy days. The nature of the interactions between soaring birds and transient turbulent gusts is not clear, especially when compared with our understanding of flight in larger and steadier airflows during thermal or dynamic soaring. We show that soaring golden eagles ( Aquila chrysaetos ) experienced short upward accelerations indicative of preferential engagement with strong and intermittent turbulent updrafts. The vertical accelerations reflect changes in lift that were as large as 25 standard deviations from the mean, or more than three times the acceleration of gravity, and so large as not to be consistent with gust mitigation or avoidance. These extreme events occurred in short bursts that mimic movement with turbulent vortices. The burst statistics and their symmetries approach those of turbulence toward longer timescales. On the shortest timescales, the bursts break the symmetry of small-scale turbulence in favor of upward accelerations that are more intermittent than turbulence. We introduce a simple nonlinear model that predicts the scale at which symmetry breaks and the stronger intermittency on the smaller scales. These findings suggest a ratcheting mechanism on turbulent gusts and constitute the first quantitative evidence in favor of turbulent gust harvesting by wildlife. An implication is that turbulence is so strong and pervasive as to make unsteady and nonlinear aerodynamics an intrinsic and beneficial aspect of both flapping and soaring flight in the atmospheric boundary layer – one that we need to incorporate in our understanding of the energetics of flight. keywords Eagle, Flight, Gust amplification, Intermittency, Turbulence Understanding the relationships between environmental turbulence, gusts, and flight is more important than ever due to the advent of small semi-autonomous as well as slow-moving aerial vehicles that are more susceptible to turbulence than their larger, heavier, and faster counterparts. The effort to understand how to fly in turbulence complements our broader work to understand the relationships between wildlife and movements of the atmosphere, which is driven in part by an increasing awareness of the impact of climate change and human development on wildlife, newton1998population ; jonzen2006rapid ; nourani2017effects ; hejazi2023honeybee and the opportunity to use wildlife motions to monitor the state of the atmosphere. laurent2021turbulence ; lempidakis2022estimating Turbulence is multiscale – it is composed of superimposed vortical motions on a continuous distribution of length and time scales. In the atmosphere, the timescales range from fractions of a second to hundreds of seconds. boettcher2003statistics Animal behavior, on the other hand, tends to concentrate on particular scales. Flapping, for instance, occurs at a frequency of about 2.5 Hz in golden eagles. laurent2021turbulence Turbulence and flapping are both intermittent. Golden eagles switch between flapping, gliding, and other flight modes in ways that are correlated with atmospheric conditions. lanzone2012flight ; duerr2012testing ; bohrer2012estimating Turbulence is intermittent in the sense that periods of intense activity are interspersed with periods of relative calm. batchelor1949nature While turbulence is more intricate than the black-and-white nature of switching between flight modes, the mark of turbulent intermittency is that strong fluctuations, or gusts, occur many orders of magnitude more often than Gaussian models predict, especially in the atmosphere. bottcher2007small A defining feature of turbulence is that intermittency is more pronounced toward smaller and shorter scales in specific and quantified ways. sreenivasan1997phenomenology In engineering practice, turbulence has usually been considered a disturbance, and one that needs to be mitigated or avoided. Flight vehicles are designed to operate efficiently under calm conditions with corrections added to account for turbulence and gusts. mohamed2014attitude ; jones2022physics Natural fliers, on the other hand, seem to be capable of flying effortlessly, even gracefully, in extremely turbulent conditions; as if they are surfing on the turbulence. This raises the fundamental question of whether there are conditions under which we may not need to suppress, mitigate, reject or avoid turbulence and gusts, and conditions under which we can exploit turbulence. To find out, it is useful, if not crucial, to understand the influence of turbulence intermittency on volant wildlife. Large birds soar, or fly without flapping, when they migrate over long distances or search for prey. To reduce their energy expenditure, they exploit naturally available energy within the boundary layer of the atmosphere. Energy is available in three forms in principle: (i) ascending vertical air currents such as those in thermal updrafts, pennycuick1998field ; reddy2016learning ; akos2010thermal ; kerlinger1989flight in orographic updrafts, kerlinger1989flight ; bohrer2012estimating or in mountain waves, bohrer2012estimating (ii) mean wind gradients such as those harnessed during dynamic soaring, rayleigh1883soaring ; richardson2015upwind and (iii) fluctuating gradients in turbulence and gusts. patel2009extracting ; mallon2016flight ; laurent2021turbulence ; bollt2021extract ; he2023energy The spatiotemporal scales at which these sources operate are different. Thermal updrafts and wind shear, for instance, are relatively stable large-scale structures that evolve slowly relative to the time it takes to fly through them, and are predictable enough to have been exploited by glider pilots, birds, and autonomous flight vehicles. akos2010thermal ; richardson2015upwind ; reddy2018glider Small-scale gusts and turbulence, on the other hand, are largely stochastic, bandak2024spontaneous and so far have generally been regarded by humans as being responsible for energetic costs, reynolds2014wing ; lempidakis2024turbulence rather than energetic reservoirs. langley1893internal ; mallon2016flight ; bollt2021extract Despite its stochastic nature, we know from computer simulations that turbulence can in principle be exploited to achieve energy-efficient flight even when only local information is available about the flow, and we know that these strategies are associated with increased accelerations. bollt2021extract Strategies to harness vortical flows have recently received computational attention for underwater navigation. biferale2019zermelo ; gunnarson2021learning ; monthiller2022surfing ; xu2023long Quantifying the energetics of animals in practice, however, is difficult. engel2005racing ; schmidt2007energy ; friman2024pays Turbulence appears to be stronger than any other contribution to the accelerations of soaring golden eagles on timescales between about 0.1 and 10 s. laurent2021turbulence In this interval, the response of the eagles to typical turbulent fluctuations can be explained with a linear model. Typical fluctuations in atmosphere are characterized by velocities on the order of 1 m/s. In this paper, we examine the response of eagles to extreme fluctuations, those characterized by much larger velocities, and we ask whether the approximate linearity persists. It appears not to persist in an interesting and nontrivial way. The relevance of intermittent gusts, or of extreme wind velocity fluctuations, to the aerodynamics of flight is still not clear. Gusts occur on timescales as short as fractions of a second and can generate velocities on the order of 10 m/s, large enough in principle to cause non-linear aerodynamic responses. mohamed2023gusts In steady state, aerodynamic stall causes the lift force to decrease if the angle of attack of a wing exceeds approximately 15 degrees (Fig. 1, inset ), anderson2011ebook a response that a sustained gust can elicit. biler2021experimental ; fukami2023grasping Eagles might take deliberate and nonlinear actions in response to gusts either to mitigate them, reynolds2014wing or potentially to exploit them and to increase the lift force transiently. Active responses, however, are not needed to generate transient lift increases. They have been observed to arise from passive unsteady aerodynamic effects such as the development of leading