Sketch of the resolution of the axial U(1) problem without chiral anomaly

Nodoka Yamanaka 1 · 2024

Read Sketch of the resolution of the axial U(1) problem without chiral anomaly by Nodoka Yamanaka 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-02792.txt.

Description

A 2024 arXiv research paper by Nodoka Yamanaka 1. We propose a mechanism which explains the masses of η \eta and η ′ \eta^{\prime} mesons without invoking the explicit violation of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry by the chiral anomaly.

Catalog record

CREATORNodoka Yamanaka 1
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-02792

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sketch of the resolution of the axial U(1) problem without chiral anomaly Nodoka Yamanaka 1 Abstract We propose a mechanism which explains the masses of η \eta and η ′ \eta^{\prime} mesons without invoking the explicit violation of U ​ ( 1 ) A U(1)_{A} symmetry by the chiral anomaly. It is shown that the U(1) problem, the problem for which the prediction of η \eta and η ′ \eta^{\prime} masses in the simple chiral perturbation theory largely deviates from the experimental values, is actually resolved by considering the first order contribution of the disconnected meson correlator with respect to the quark mass. The bound of Weinberg m η 2 ≤ 3 ​ m π 2 m_{\eta}^{2}\leq 3m_{\pi}^{2} is fulfilled by considering the negative squared mass of η \eta or η ′ \eta^{\prime} which is just the saddle point of the QCD effective potential, and 20% level agreements with experimental data are obtained by just fitting one low energy constant. We provide the leading chiral Lagrangian due to the disconnected contribution in 3-flavor QCD, and also discuss the 2- and 4-flavor cases as well as the consistency of our mechanism with the chiral restoration at high temperature found in lattice calculations. It is believed that the chiral symmetry of quarks is dynamically broken in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), and that massless Nambu-Goldstone (NG) bosons appear in the spectrum Nambu:1961tp ; Nambu:1961fr ; Goldstone:1961eq ; Goldstone:1962es . In reality, the quarks are massive due to explicit violation at the level of the Lagrangian so that NG particle masses are not exactly zero, but the small “current quark masses” nevertheless allow us to control the masses and interactions of the NG bosons in the linear approximation, which we nowadays call chiral perturbation theory Gasser:1983yg ; Gasser:1984gg ; Scherer:2002tk ; Meissner:2024ona . If we consider 3-flavor QCD, one would naively expect the appearance of nine NG bosons. However, the ninth one, \eta^{\prime} with its mass m_{\eta^{\prime}}=960 MeV, was found to be heavier than the simple prediction from chiral perturbation theory. Moreover, this approach also predicts the existence of a light meson, \eta , with a mass very close to that of the pion, m_{\pi}=135 MeV. Even by radically changing the decay constants, the mass of \eta is bounded by an inequality Weinberg:1975ui ; Crewther:1978kq ; Christos:1984tu m_{\eta}^{2}\leq 3m_{\pi}^{2}, (1) while the observed value is m_{\eta}=550 MeV, which seems to oppose to the simple chiral perturbation. This is the well-known “U(1) problem” of Weinberg. It is currently widely admitted that the axial U(1) symmetry [ U(1)_{A} ] is not conserved, as can be seen in the chiral Ward-Takahashi identity Bardeen:1969md \sum_{q}^{N_{f}}\Bigl[\partial^{\mu}(\bar{q}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}q)+2m_{q}\bar{q}i\gamma_{5}q\Bigr]=-\frac{N_{f}\alpha_{s}}{8\pi}F_{\mu\nu,a}\tilde{F}^{\mu\nu}_{a}, (2) where the quarks q are summed over N_{f} active flavors. The right-hand side contains the chiral anomaly F\tilde{F}\equiv\frac{\alpha_{s}}{8\pi}F_{\mu\nu,a}\tilde{F}^{\mu\nu}_{a} which does not cancel even in the chiral limit Adler:1969gk ; Bell:1969ts ; Fujikawa:1979ay ; Fujikawa:1980eg . A resolution to the U(1) problem was proposed by ’t Hooft who claimed that the topological instanton Belavin:1975fg ; Callan:1977gz ; Crewther:1977ce ; Schafer:1996wv , a nonperturbative realization of the above chiral anomaly, lifts the mass of the singlet NG boson channel tHooft:1976rip ; tHooft:1976snw ; tHooft:1986ooh . It was argued that the instantons generate the U(1)_{A} breaking 6-quark Kobayashi-Maskawa-’t Hooft (KMT) interaction Kobayashi:1970ji ; Kobayashi:1971qz ; Hatsuda:1994pi ; Koll:2000ke {\cal L}_{\rm KMT}\propto\bar{u}_{R}u_{L}\bar{d}_{R}d_{L}\bar{s}_{R}s_{L}+{\rm h.c.}. (3) As another important contribution which may shift the singlet NG boson mass, Witten and Veneziano suggested the topological susceptibility Witten:1979vv ; Veneziano:1979ec ; Veneziano:1980xs ; Shore:2007yn ; Alkofer:2008et \displaystyle U(k) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{2iN_{f}}{f_{\pi}^{2}}\int d^{4}x\,e^{ik\cdot x}\langle 0|F\tilde{F}(x)F\tilde{F}(0)|0\rangle, (4) which resulted in a nontrivial dependence of \eta^{\prime} mass on the number of color N_{c} . Other interesting resolutions based on the gauge variance of the flavor-singlet current were also proposed Kogut:1973ab ; Kugo:1978nc . The masses of \eta and \eta^{\prime} were also calculated in lattice QCD, and recent results are showing good agreement with experimental data Kuramashi:1994aj ; Christ:2010dd ; Fukaya:2015ara ; Bali:2021qem ; CSSMQCDSFUKQCD:2021rvs ; Verplanke:2024msi , but it is still difficult to determine the responsible mechanism. Until today, many subjects of QCD and hadron physics were investigated assuming the chiral anomaly, such as the hadron spectroscopy Schafer:1996wv ; Oka:1989ud ; Oka:2000wj ; Gan:2020aco , QCD at finite temperature and density Nagahiro:2006dr ; Hatsuda:2006ps ; Abuki:2010jq ; Fukushima:2010bq ; Jido:2011pq ; Baym:2017whm ; Bass:2018xmz ; Suenaga:2022uqn , and the chiral magnetic effect in accelerator experiments Kharzeev:2007jp ; Fukushima:2008xe ; Kharzeev:2015znc ; STAR:2021pwb . Under the assumption of the anomalous U(1)_{A} breaking, the resolution of the U(1) problem leads to a large CP violation due to the topological instanton effect which is in conflict with experiments, nowadays called the strong CP problem Shifman:1979if . However, there is recently a surge of trend that this problem is absent in QCD Ai:2020ptm ; Nakamura:2021meh ; Ai:2024vfa ; Schierholz:2024var , so that the U(1) problem is also getting more unstable. In particular, the present Author recently showed that the topological charge is not observable, which immediately leads to the absence of the KMT interaction ( 3 ) generated by the chiral Dirac zero-modes as well as the topological susceptibility ( 4 ) in the zero momentum limit k\to 0 , and eventually to the irrelevance of the anomalous violation of global U(1)_{A} Yamanaka:2022vdt ; Yamanaka:2022bfj . What is then the mechanism resolving the U(1) problem? If there is no explicit U(1)_{A} violation by the chiral anomaly, the only source of explicit chiral symmetry breaking is then the current quark mass. In this work, we elaborate such a mechanism and show its consistency with selected, but the most important related facts including experiments. The conventional understanding of the structure of the NG bosons is as follows. The quarks get a large mass of the order of \Lambda_{\rm QCD}\sim 200 MeV (the so-called “constituent quark mass”) through the dynamics of QCD Bowman:2005vx . It is believed that the strong attraction due to the gluon exchange destabilizes the vacuum and forms the vacuum condensate \langle 0|\bar{q}q|0\rangle Nambu:1961tp ; Nambu:1961fr ; Miransky:1983vj ; Higashijima:1983gx ; Higashijima:1991de ; Vogl:1991qt ; Klevansky:1992qe ; Roberts:1994dr ; Hatsuda:1994pi ; Eichmann:2008ae ; Gubler:2018ctz . The zero mass of the NG bosons within massless QCD is interpreted as the exact cancellation between the dynamically generated quark mass M_{\rm dyn} and the binding energy of the quark-antiquark system. The masses of pions and kaons are due to the small current quark mass terms which disrupt the above exact cancellation. The meson squared mass receives the leading contribution from the mass insertions M_{\rm dyn}+m_{q} to the quark propagators of the connected meson correlator depicted in Fig. 1 . To respect the chiral symmetry, we have to take an even number of mass insertions, so the leading contribution starts from (M_{\rm dyn}+m_{q})^{2} , but we also have to subtract the M_{\rm dyn}^{2} term due to the NG boson binding. This then yields a formula where the NG boson mass squared is linear in the current quark mass, as expected. Figure 1: Connected diagram contribution to the NG boson propagator. The solid and dashed lines denote the quark and the interpolating field of the NG boson, respectively. The wiggle lines with the dots mean that we took the resummed diagrams with all possible gluon exchanges. The crosses indicate the mass insertions. We now

Read the complete text