HD 119130 b is not an “ultra-dense” sub-Neptune Facilities: HARPS, HARPS-N, Keck:I (HIRES).
Joseph M. Akana Murphy, Rafael Luque, Natalie M. Batalha, Ilaria Carleo, Enric Palle, Madison Brady, Benjamin Fulton, Luke B. Handley, Howard Isaacson, Gaia Lacedelli, Felipe Murgas, Grzegorz Nowak, J. Orell-Miquel, Hannah L. M. Osborne, Vincent Van Eylen, María Rosa Zapatero Osorio · 2024
Read HD 119130 b is not an “ultra-dense” sub-Neptune Facilities: HARPS, HARPS-N, Keck:I (HIRES). by Joseph M. Akana Murphy, Rafael Luque, Natalie M. Batalha, Ilaria Carleo, Enric Palle, Madison Brady, Benjamin Fulton, Luke B. Handley, Howard Isaacson, Gaia Lacedelli, Felipe Murgas, Grzegorz Nowak, J. Orell-Miquel, Hannah L. M. Osborne, Vincent Van Eylen, María Rosa Zapatero Osorio (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-02518.txt.
Description
Abstract We present a revised mass measurement for HD 119130 b (aka K2-292 b), a transiting planet ( P = 17 P=17 days, R p R_{\mathrm{p}} = = 2.63 − 0.10 + 0.11 2.63^{+0.11}_{-0.10} R ⊕ R_{\oplus} ) orbiting a chromospherically inactive G dwarf, previously thought to be one of the densest sub-Neptunes known.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph M. Akana Murphy, Rafael Luque, Natalie M. Batalha, Ilaria Carleo, Enric Palle, Madison Brady, Benjamin Fulton, Luke B. Handley, Howard Isaacson, Gaia Lacedelli, Felipe Murgas, Grzegorz Nowak, J. Orell-Miquel, Hannah L. M. Osborne, Vincent Van Eylen, María Rosa Zapatero Osorio |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-02518
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
HD 119130 b is not an “ultra-dense” sub-Neptune Facilities: HARPS, HARPS-N, Keck:I (HIRES). Joseph M. Akana Murphy, Rafael Luque, Natalie M. Batalha, Ilaria Carleo, Enric Palle, Madison Brady, Benjamin Fulton, Luke B. Handley, Howard Isaacson, Gaia Lacedelli, Felipe Murgas, Grzegorz Nowak, J. Orell-Miquel, Hannah L. M. Osborne, Vincent Van Eylen, María Rosa Zapatero Osorio Abstract We present a revised mass measurement for HD 119130 b (aka K2-292 b), a transiting planet ( P = 17 P=17 days, R p R_{\mathrm{p}} = = 2.63 − 0.10 + 0.11 2.63^{+0.11}_{-0.10} R ⊕ R_{\oplus} ) orbiting a chromospherically inactive G dwarf, previously thought to be one of the densest sub-Neptunes known. Our follow-up Doppler observations with HARPS, HARPS-N, and HIRES reveal that HD 119130 b is, in fact, nearly one-third as massive as originally suggested by its initial confirmation paper. Our revised analysis finds M p M_{\mathrm{p}} = = 8.8 ± 3.2 8.8\pm 3.2 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} ( M p M_{\mathrm{p}} < < 15.4 15.4 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} at 98% confidence) compared to the previously reported M p M_{\mathrm{p}} = = 24.5 ± 4.4 24.5\pm 4.4 M ⊕ M_{\oplus} . While the true cause of the original mass measurement’s inaccuracy remains uncertain, we present the plausible explanation that the planet’s radial velocity (RV) semi-amplitude was inflated due to constructive interference with a second, untreated sinusoidal signal in the data (possibly rotational modulation from the star). HD 119130 b illustrates the complexities of interpreting the RV orbits of small transiting planets. While RV mass measurements of such planets may be precise, they are not necessarily guaranteed to be accurate. This system serves as a cautionary tale as observers and theorists alike look to the exoplanet mass-radius diagram for insights into the physics of small planet formation. exoplanet [ 19 ] , matplotlib [ 36 ] , numpy [ 28 ] , pandas [ 63 ] , Python 3 [ 81 ] , RadVel [ 20 ] , RVSearch [ 71 ] . I Introduction Luque et al. [54, hereafter L19 ] reported the discovery and confirmation of the sub-Neptune-size planet HD 119130 b (aka K2-292 b). L19 detected the planet’s transits in K2 photometry [ 34 ] and subsequently conducted RV follow-up with the Calar Alto high-Resolution search for M dwarfs with Exoearths with Near-infrared and optical Échelle Spectrographs [ 65 , 66 , CARMENES;] . HD 119130 b orbits its G dwarf host every 17 days. Jointly modeling the four K2 transits and their 18 CARMENES RVs, the authors found R_{\mathrm{p}} = 2.63^{+0.11}_{-0.10} R_{\oplus} and M_{\mathrm{p}} = 24.5\pm 4.4 M_{\oplus} , making this planet unusually massive for its size. At the time of its publication, HD 119130 b was one of only two 1 1 1 According to the data from the TEPCat catalog [ 79 ] as shown in Figure 6 from L19. planets with M_{\mathrm{p}} \geq 20 M_{\oplus} and R_{\mathrm{p}} \leq 3 R_{\oplus} [ 77 , the other being K2-66 b, a planet in the photoevaporation desert orbiting a subgiant star;] . Given its curiously high bulk density of \rho_{\mathrm{p}} = 7.4^{+1.6}_{-1.5} g cm -3 , L19 dubbed HD 119130 b a rare “ultra-dense” sub-Neptune. The authors posited that the planet must have formed with high density since it is too weakly irradiated ( S_{\mathrm{p}}=67 S_{\mathrm{\oplus}} ) to have lost a massive primordial envelope via photoevaporation [ 62 , e.g.,] . Furthermore, the inner disk of the planet’s G dwarf host would not have contained sufficient material to form a 20 M_{\oplus} planet in situ at 0.1 au [ 75 ] , meaning HD 119130 b must have formed beyond the snow line and migrated inward over time—possibly in lockstep with the snow line itself [ 40 ] . L19 suggested that the migration could have been caused by Kozai-Lidov oscillations [ 15 , 58 ] , which may have been triggered by a potential long-period companion associated with their detection of a linear RV trend. In this context, ultra-dense sub-Neptunes may represent a valuable tracer of protoplanetary disk composition beyond the snow line, and their orbital architectures could lend insights into the physics of planet migration. Since the confirmation of HD 119130 b, other ultra-dense or “superdense” sub-Neptunes have appeared in the literature, including K2-182 b [ 4 ] and HD 21749 b [ 16 , 23 ] . To date, there are only eight planets (not including HD 119130 b) with M_{\mathrm{p}} \geq 20 M_{\oplus} and R_{\mathrm{p}} \leq 3 R_{\oplus} , whose masses were measured using RVs. 2 2 2 According to the NASA Exoplanet Archive’s Planetary Systems Table, as accessed on 2024 Sept 02 [ 59 ] , for planets with better than 33% and 15% fractional measurement precision in mass and radius, respectively. There are another three such planets with masses derived from transit timing variations [ 27 , TTVs; e.g.,] . As with any collection of seemingly unusual planets—for example, planets lying in the photoevaporation desert [ 80 , 52 , 5 , e.g.,] or the so-called “super-puffs” [ 47 , 38 , 48 , e.g.,] —it is natural to wonder if these objects truly represent a unique outcome of planet formation, or if the measurements (of the planet masses, in particular) are the product of some conspiracy between observational biases and model misspecification. [ 45 ] find that the majority of superdense sub-Neptunes with mass measurements from RV monitoring were confirmed using less than 30 observations. Superdense sub-Neptunes may be particularly vulnerable to publication bias because, for a given measurement uncertainty, a larger mass will lead to a higher-precision detection. This bias may, in turn, serve to influence our understanding of the small planet mass-radius relation [ 11 ] . To verify the accuracy of HD 119130 b’s mass measurement, we conducted follow-up Doppler observations as part of the THIRSTEE 3 3 3 Tracking Hydrates In Refined Sub-neptunes to Tackle their Emergence and Evolution. survey [ 44 ] . In total, we obtained 57 new RVs of HD 119130. Combined with the CARMENES data from L19, our observations reveal that HD 119130 b is not, in fact, an ultra-dense sub-Neptune. Instead, we find M_{\mathrm{p}} = 8.8\pm 3.2 M_{\oplus} ( M_{\mathrm{p}} < 15.4 M_{\oplus} at 98% confidence), which is much more typical for a planet of its size. We also find that the data prefer including a low-frequency signal, which can either be modeled as an outer planetary-mass companion with P\approx 200 days and K= 4.9\pm 1.2 m s -1 , or as a long-term linear trend. We explore possible explanations for the original mass measurement’s inaccuracy, including untreated stellar activity and imperfect time-sampling. The paper is organized as follows. In § II , we describe our observations. In § III , we present our RV analysis and revised mass measurement for HD 119130 b. In § IV , we explore possible explanations for the inaccuracy of the L19 mass measurement. In V , we discuss the planet’s possible composition and formation and evolution scenarios in the context of its revised mass estimate. We conclude in § VI . II Observations Here we summarize the RV observations of HD 119130. The data, including the archival CARMENES RVs from L19, can be found in Table 1 .