The Dog that Didn’t Bark: Non-Variable Field Stars in the RR Lyrae Instability Strip Facilities: Gaia, TESS, APOGEE
Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Cecilia Mateu, K. Z. Stanek · 2024
Read The Dog that Didn’t Bark: Non-Variable Field Stars in the RR Lyrae Instability Strip Facilities: Gaia, TESS, APOGEE by Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Cecilia Mateu, K. Z. Stanek (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-02514.txt.
Description
A 2024 arXiv research paper by Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Cecilia Mateu, K. Z. Stanek. RR Lyrae stars (RRLs) are easy to identify thanks to their large photometric variation and short periods. All stars in the RRL instability strip are pulsators is often a hidden assumption in most stellar population studies using RRLs. Non-variable stars in the instability strip have been discovered for Cepheids and δ \delta Scuti, and in this paper, we report the discovery of non-variable filed stars in the RRL instability strip.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Cecilia Mateu, K. Z. Stanek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-02514
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Dog that Didn’t Bark: Non-Variable Field Stars in the RR Lyrae Instability Strip Facilities: Gaia, TESS, APOGEE Yuxi(Lucy) Lu, Cecilia Mateu, K. Z. Stanek Abstract RR Lyrae stars (RRLs) are easy to identify thanks to their large photometric variation and short periods. All stars in the RRL instability strip are pulsators is often a hidden assumption in most stellar population studies using RRLs. Non-variable stars in the instability strip have been discovered for Cepheids and δ \delta Scuti, and in this paper, we report the discovery of non-variable filed stars in the RRL instability strip. Using a high-quality sample selected from Gaia DR3, we find at least 15% of the stars in the empirical instability strip where the variable fraction is > > 0.7 have near-zero photometric variations or variations that are significantly smaller than typical RRLs. The non-variable stars are mostly bright and close by, on cold orbits in the Galactic plane. Metallicity from Gaia BP/RP spectra suggests the non-variable stars have an average metallicity is ∼ \sim -0.5 dex, with a peak at 0. The discovery of these non-variable stars in the RRL instability strip challenges our understanding of stellar physics and further investigation is needed to understand the origin of these stars. Astropy [ 4 , 49 , 5 ] , lightkurve [ 34 ] , Matplotlib [ 30 ] , NumPy [ 26 ] , Pandas [ 38 ] , dustmaps [ 23 ] , unpopular [ 27 ] I Introduction RR Lyrae stars (RRLs) are helium-burning horizontal branch stars that sit in the instability strip. RRLs occupy a narrow range of absolute mean magnitudes and exhibit a period–luminosity–metallicity relation, making them useful for distance measurements [ 12 , 8 , 22 , e.g.,] . RR Lyrae instability is driven by He+ ionization [ 15 , 57 , 35 , e.g.,] , and can be mostly classified as fundamental-mode pulsators (RRab) and first-overtone pulsators (RRc), with periods in the range between about 0.2 day and 0.8 day. Another category of RRLs, RRd, which have two simultaneously excited pulsation modes, are relatively rare but also exist. RRab stars are easy to identify as they are bright, and have large photometric variations with distinct shapes. However, due to lower amplitude and the near sinusoidal light curve shapes, RRc stars are often misclassified as other variables, usually eclipsing contact binaries. That all stars in the instability strip should pulsate is oftentimes a hidden assumption that goes into pulsation models, not just of RRLs but of all kinds of pulsators within the strip. On his comprehensive book on RRLs, Smith [56] notes this notion dates back to Schwarzschild’s early studies about stellar pulsation: “Surmizing that something about this zone not only permitted the existence of RRLs but made it mandatory that stars within the zone pulsate, Schwarzschild concluded that ‘a star which can pulsate does pulsate’ ”. Understanding whether this conjecture holds has implications for correctly modeling the makeup of stellar populations and their variable star content, and therefore correctly predicting their observed properties via stellar populations via synthesis models, both for resolved and unresolved populations. Non-variable field stars in the instability strip have been discovered for the Cepheids [ 3 , 44 ] and \delta Scuti [ 42 , 43 , e.g.,] . Surprisingly, there are only a limited number of studies that mention non-variable stars in the RRL instability strip. [ 14 ] shows Population II RRLs and Cepheids with helium content, Y , less than 0.2 will not vary. They concluded Y must be greater than 0.22 for Population II stars as no non-variable RRLs were observed. However, [ 16 ] examined stars in the instability strip along the horizontal branch in globular clusters and found that 25% of the stars located in the observational instability strip do not exhibit variability. With large-scale photometric surveys such as Gaia [ 19 ] , Kepler [ 9 ] , TESS [ 52 ] , ASAS-SN [ 33 ] , and ZTF [ 6 ] , astronomers were able to construct large catalogs of field RRLs [ 32 , 28 , 40 , 13 , e.g.,] . These catalogs can be used to revisit the question of whether non-variable field stars exist in the RRL instability strip. In this paper, we answer this question by merging astrometric information from Gaia DR3 Gaia Collaboration et al. [21] with the three largest public RRL catalogs: Gaia SOS, ASAS-SN, and PS1 [ 13 , 32 , 55 ] . We find \sim 30% of the field stars in the center of the observational instability strip are not varying. The data selection is described in Section II , and exploratory investigations on the possibility of contamination, missed detection, and physical origin are done in Section III . II Data & Selection II.1 The RR Lyrae catalog We use a catalog comprising ¿300K stars that combines the three largest public surveys of RRL stars currently available: Gaia DR3 Specific Objects Study [ 13 ] , PanSTARRS-1 [ 55 ] and ASAS-SN [ 32 ] . As described in Mateu [36] , the combination of these three catalogs provides the best performance in terms of sky coverage, depth, and completeness, empirically determined by probabilistic arguments from the three catalogs themselves following Mateu et al. [37] . Details on how the three surveys were combined can be found in Mateu [36] and Cabrera-Gadea et al. [11] . II.2 Data selection for Gaia DR3 To find whether non-variable stars in the RRL instability strip exist, we first obtained a high-quality sample of stars in and near the RRL instability strip from Gaia DR3 [ 21 ] . Since we want to include stars that are undoubtedly in the empirical instability strip, we selected stars with low extinction and good parallax measurements. The quality cuts we did to obtain our sample from the full Gaia DR3 dataset and their purpose are shown below 1 1 1 For a list of Gaia DR3 column descriptions, see https://gea.esac.esa.int/archive/documentation/GDR3/Gaia_archive/chap_datamodel/sec_dm_main_source_catalogue/ssec_dm_gaia_source.html . : • Quality cut to ensure low extinction (cuts on ag_gspphot ), good parallax (cuts on parallax_over_err ), and accurate photometric solutions (cuts on ruwe ). – ag_gspphot < 0.2 – parallax_over_err > 20 – ruwe < 1.4 • The completeness of RRc is low as they have relatively low amplitudes and can be easily misclassified as eclipsing binaries [ 37 ] , this is especially true at low Galactic latitudes where crowding is significant. To ensure completeness for all RRLs and avoid possible extinction map failure modes in the Galactic plane, we also performed cuts on Galactic latitude: – | b | > 5 deg • Photometric quality flags suggestions by [ 20 ] – phot_BP_RP_excess_factor < 1.3+0.06*power( phot_BP_mean_mag - phot_RP_mean_mag ,2) – phot_BP_RP_excess_factor > 1.0+0.015*power( phot_BP_mean_mag - phot_RP_mean_mag ,2) – phot_G_mean_flux_over_err < 50 – phot_bp_mean_flux_over_err < 20 – phot_rp_mean_flux_over_err < 20 • Selecting the area of the Color–Magnitude–Diagram (CMD) close to the empirical RRLs instability strip. – -0.5 < M_{G} < 1.5 – 0 < (G_{\rm BP}-G) < 0.4 In which (G_{\rm BP}-G) is the Gaia color calculated by subtracting the G –band magnitude from the BP–band magnitude, and M_{G} stands for the absolute G magnitude and is calculated