Emergent vorticity asymmetry of one and two-layer shallow water system captured by a next-order balanced model
Ryan Shìjié Dù 1, K. Shafer Smith 1 · 2024
Read Emergent vorticity asymmetry of one and two-layer shallow water system captured by a next-order balanced model by Ryan Shìjié Dù 1, K. Shafer Smith 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-02291.txt.
Description
Abstract The turbulent evolution of the shallow water system exhibits asymmetry in vorticity. This emergent phenomenon can be classified as “balanced”, that is, it is not due to the inertial-gravity wave modes. The Quasi-Geostrophic (QG) system, the canonical model for balanced motion, has a symmetric evolution of vorticity, thus misses this phenomenon.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryan Shìjié Dù 1, K. Shafer Smith 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-02291
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Emergent vorticity asymmetry of one and two-layer shallow water system captured by a next-order balanced model Ryan Shìjié Dù 1, K. Shafer Smith 1 Abstract The turbulent evolution of the shallow water system exhibits asymmetry in vorticity. This emergent phenomenon can be classified as “balanced”, that is, it is not due to the inertial-gravity wave modes. The Quasi-Geostrophic (QG) system, the canonical model for balanced motion, has a symmetric evolution of vorticity, thus misses this phenomenon. Here we present a next-order-in-Rossby extension of QG, QG +1 , in the shallow water context. We recapitulate the derivation of the model in one-layer shallow water grounded in physical principles and provide a new formulation using “potentials”. Then, the multi-layer extension of the SWQG +1 model is formulated for the first time. The SWQG +1 system is still balanced in the sense that there is only one prognostic variable, potential vorticity (PV), and all other variables are diagnosed from PV. It filters out inertial gravity waves by design. This feature is attractive for modeling the dynamics of balanced motions that dominate transport in geophysical systems. The diagnostic relations connect ageostrophic physical variables and extend the massively useful geostrophic balance. Simulations of these systems in classical set-ups provide evidence that SWQG +1 captures the vorticity asymmetry in the shallow water system. Simulations of freely decaying turbulence in one-layer show that SWQG +1 can capture the negatively skewed vorticity, and simulations of the nonlinear evolution of a baroclinically unstable jet show that it can capture vorticity asymmetry and finite divergence of strain-driven fronts. keywords † † affiliation: 1 Center for Atmosphere Ocean Science, Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York University, New York, NY 10012, USA 1 Introduction The shallow water system has been a crucial workhorse model for our understanding of geophysical fluid dynamics (GFD) ( Zeitlin, 2018 , e.g.) . It simplifies the more complex GFD equations (e.g., the Boussinesq system) by assuming that one can represent the vertical variation using only one (or a few) stacked stratified layers. This simplification allows for easier numerical and theoretical investigations of its properties, and in many cases shallow water captures the realistic properties of geophysical phenomena in the atmosphere and ocean of Earth and other planets (e.g. Dowling and Ingersoll, 1989 ; Polvani et al., 1994 ; Cho and Polvani, 1996 ; Lambaerts et al., 2012 ; Bembenek et al., 2020 , for just a few) . A further simplification of the shallow water system is the Shallow Water Quasi-Geostrophic equation (SWQG) ( Vallis, 2017 ; Zeitlin, 2018 ) . It assumes rotation dominates and thus the geostrophic balance approximation is valid and the Rossby number is small. SWQG is then an asymptotic approximation of the shallow water model in the limit of vanishing Rossby number. It is a prototypical example of a balanced model, in that it can be written with only a single prognostic variable, potential vorticity (PV), from which all other physical variables can be diagnosed. This has the consequence that inertial-gravity waves are not permitted in its dynamics. SWQG (and its special case, the two-dimensional Euler equations) can capture the dynamics of shallow water in surprisingly wide parameter regime ( Sugimoto et al., 2007 ) , and it has rich turbulence phenomena that closely resemble the balanced dynamics of rotationally dominated atmospheres and oceans ( Gill et al., 1974 ; Salmon, 1980 ; Maltrud and Vallis, 1991 ; Smith et al., 2002 ; Dritschel and McIntyre, 2008 ; Early et al., 2011 , e.g.) . The study of SWQG has led to progress in many practical geophysical applications, including the parametrization of eddies ( Held and Larichev, 1996 ; Thompson and Young, 2007 ; Srinivasan and Young, 2014 ; Gallet and Ferrari, 2020 ; Gallet and Ferrari, 2021 ) , the interpolation and interpretation of satellite altimetry measurement of sea surface height ( Stammer, 1997 ; Chelton et al., 2007 ; Ubelmann et al., 2015 ) , the analysis of ocean coherent vortices over topography features ( Bretherton and Haidvogel, 1976 ; Carnevale and Frederiksen, 1987 ; Siegelman and Young, 2023 ; LaCasce et al., 2024 ) , the statistics of atmospheric blocking ( Marshall and Molteni, 1993 ; Lucarini and Gritsun, 2020 ) , and the mechanics of jets and spots on gas giants ( Turkington et al., 2001 ; Majda and Wang, 2006 ; Siegelman et al., 2022 ; Pizzo and Salmon, 2024 ) , to name but a few. Despite the range of phenomenology SWQG captures, it still misses many features of the full shallow water model, even those that might be categorized as “balanced”. SWQG misses the asymmetry between cyclonic and anticyclonic vortices. Polvani et al. (1994) note that the vorticity skews negative in a freely decaying simulation of the shallow water system. Arai and Yamagata (1994) ; Graves et al. (2006) further analyze the detailed free evolution of vortices in the shallow water model and conclude that anticyclones are more robust to small-scale perturbation and to the influence of other vortices, providing a plausible mechanics of the negative skewness of vorticity. For an ocean gyre forced by wind, Thiry et al. (2024) found the shallow water model version exhibits asymmetric drift of the strong eastward jet, while the SWQG version lacks this asymmetry. For multi-layer shallow water, Lambaerts et al. (2012) find that the evolution of baroclinically unstable jets in two-layer shallow water exhibits complex vorticity asymmetry evolution, further complicated by their inclusion of moisture. In this paper, we aim at a balanced model of the shallow water system that could capture the evolution of asymmetry between cyclonic and anticyclonic vortices. We focus on the parameter space where SWQG is formally valid but lacking in captured phenomena. As a by-product, we also wish to capture the finite divergence of shallow water flows, missed by SWQG. Some balanced models already exist in the literature. One line of models includes the frontal geostrophic model by Cushman-Roisin (1986) and the generalized geostrophic equation by Cushman-Roisin and Tang (1989) ; Cushman-Roisin and Tang (1990) . These models capture a more extended parameter space of the shallow water model by allowing for large height deviation and can capture vorticity asymmetry. However, they are not higher order in Rossby number than SWQG, and they all insist that the velocities are in geostrophic balance with the height field and thus do not allow for divergent flow. Another model is the Balance Equation ( Allen et al., 1990 ; Spall and Mcwilliams, 1992 ) . It is a capable model of shallow water in the QG regime that includes higher-order effects and is useful as a way to initialize a shallow water simulation with minimal generation of gravity waves. We use it to generate the initial conditions for our freely decaying simulation. However, evolving the Balance Equation is challenging. The system has two time derivatives but is still a balanced model in the sense that there is only one prognostic variable. This is because the two time evolution equations are not independent from each other but coupled in complex nonlinear ways. The time evolution usually needs iterative solvers per timestep ( Barth et al., 1990 ) . This poses challenges when using it to