On the Quantum Theory of Molecules: Rigour, Idealization, and Uncertainty
Nick Huggett, James Ladyman, Karim P. Y. Thébault · 2024
Read On the Quantum Theory of Molecules: Rigour, Idealization, and Uncertainty by Nick Huggett, James Ladyman, Karim P. Y. Thébault (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01942.txt.
Description
A 2024 arXiv research paper by Nick Huggett, James Ladyman, Karim P. Y. Thébault. Philosophers have claimed that: (a) the Born-Oppenheimer approximation methods for solving molecular Schrödinger equations violate the Heisenberg uncertainty relations; therefore (b) so-called ‘quantum chemistry’ is not fully quantum; and so (c) chemistry does not reduce to physics. This paper analyses the reasoning behind Born-Oppenheimer methods and shows that they are internally consistent and fully quantum mechanical, contrary to (a)-(c).
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nick Huggett, James Ladyman, Karim P. Y. Thébault |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01942
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Quantum Theory of Molecules: Rigour, Idealization, and Uncertainty Nick Huggett, James Ladyman, Karim P. Y. Thébault Abstract . Philosophers have claimed that: (a) the Born-Oppenheimer approximation methods for solving molecular Schrödinger equations violate the Heisenberg uncertainty relations; therefore (b) so-called ‘quantum chemistry’ is not fully quantum; and so (c) chemistry does not reduce to physics. This paper analyses the reasoning behind Born-Oppenheimer methods and shows that they are internally consistent and fully quantum mechanical, contrary to (a)-(c). Our analysis addresses important issues of mathematical rigour, physical idealisation, reduction, and classicality in the quantum theory of molecules, and we propose an agenda for the philosophy of quantum chemistry more solidly grounded in scientific practice. 1. Introduction 1.1. Dethroning the Queen? Quantum chemistry is the use of quantum mechanics (and quantum field theory) to model molecules and their dynamics, to explain and predict their chemical properties and reactions. Its status is important to questions about the place of physics among the sciences: prima facie, quantum chemistry is an example of the success of reductionism, exemplifying the fundamentality of physics with respect to chemistry and other natural sciences. 1 1 1 There are of course different notions of both reduction and fundamentality, and at least both epistemic and ontic versions of each. However, the received view in the philosophy of quantum chemistry is that attention to models and scientific practice reveals not only that quantum chemistry does not reduce to quantum physics, but that the two are explicitly in conflict. A principal argument for this view is based upon alleged non-quantum features of the ‘Born-Oppenheimer approximation’ ( BO ), which is the most commonly used model of molecular dynamics in quantum chemistry, and involves approximations including wavefunction separability, adiabaticity, and ‘clamping’. It has been claimed in the philosophy literature that BO violates the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, and so is in conflict with quantum theory. This claim has been developed in most detail by Olimpia Lombardi and coauthors ( Lombardi and Castagnino 2010 ; González et al. 2019 ; Fortin and Lombardi 2021 ; Lombardi 2023 ) . 2 2 2 See Woolley and Sutcliffe 1977 ; Woolley 1978 ; Claverie and Diner 1980 for the original quantum chemistry discussion. Hendry ( Hendry 1998 ; Hendry 2006 ; Hendry 2010a ; Hendry 2010b ; Hendry 2017 ; Accorinti and González 2022 ) while taking an anti-reductionist stance, does not claim that BO violates the uncertainty relations. We do not address reduction in general, but our analysis is compatible with reduction, in the same spirit as Scerri 2012 ; Hettema 2017 ; Franklin and Seifert 2020 ; Seifert 2020 ; Seifert 2022 ; Scerri 2024b ; Scerri 2024a . A further influential analysis is due to Chang 2015 , who (citing a talk by Lombardi) asserts that: …the typical method of quantum-mechanical treatment of molecules begins with the Born–Oppenheimer approximation, which separates out the nuclear wavefunction from the electronic wavefunction […] Additionally, it is assumed that the nuclei have fixed positions in space. In this “clamping-down” approximation, the atomic nuclei are treated essentially as classical particles; as Olimpia Lombardi points out, this picture is non-quantum in a very fundamental way as the simultaneous assignment of fixed positions and fixed momenta (namely, zero) to them violates the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. But without such classical scene-setting, the quantum calculations are quite impossible ( Chang 2015 , p. 198) In our terms , Chang claims that BO involves both the separation of wavefunctions (which is what he calls ‘the Born-Oppenheimer approximation’) and a ‘clamping-down’ approximation, and that the latter violates the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, so the BO as a whole is not fully quantum. Lombardi 2023 puts the claim even more strongly. When endorsing Torretti’s ( Torretti 2000 ) view that bringing together theories without worrying about their incompatibility, seemingly ‘outrageously’ (p. 119), is nonetheless scientifically legitimate on pragmatic grounds, she notes: The [Born-Oppenheimer], as used in the context of quantum chemistry, is a vivid example of how scientists “outrageously” appeal to incompatible theories in their practice. In this case, quantum chemical models of molecules are obtained by combining classical mechanics to describe the nuclei and quantum mechanics to account for the motion of the electrons. (p. 115) The Lombardi and Chang idea that BO violates Heisenberg uncertainty is the basis for more general anti-reductionist claims ( Accorinti and González 2022 ; Cartwright 2022 ) . Cartwright argues that this alleged conflict between the quantum chemistry of molecules and Heisenberg uncertainty implies not only that chemistry fails to reduce to physics, but that the two are incompatible. This case is one of the main motivations for ‘dethroning the queen’ (i.e. not privileging physics among the sciences). After quoting the passage from Chang above (with no reference to Lombardi et al.), Cartwright says: This approximation treats the atomic nucleus as a classical particle. But this fundamentally violates quantum mechanics which, following the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, maintains that we cannot have a simultaneous assignment of fixed positions and fixed momenta. The approximations that provide the reduction violate the very theory that the chemistry is being reduced to […] the success of quantum chemistry relies fundamentally on assumptions that belong to classical chemistry ( Cartwright 2022 , pp. 106-7) To our knowledge, it has never been claimed in the scientific literature that BO violates the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. 3 3 3 This includes the notable discussions of Sutcliffe and Wooley cited earlier. The only scientific reference that we have found cited to support the violation claim is in Accorinti and González 2022 . These authors quote remarks in ( Villaveces C and Daza C 1990 , pp. 100-1) that make reference to a potential contradiction between identifying a quantum chemical structure with a single point in a nuclear configuration space and the uncertainty principle as part of a motivation for moving beyond such an approach. No argument is provided that such a step is taken in context of BO . So either philosophers of science have uncovered an important scientific fact that scientists themselves have somehow missed, or the arguments of the philosophers are incorrect. One main aim of this paper is show the latter to be the case: BO does not violate the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. 4 4 4 For related critical remarks see Scerri 2024b ; Scerri 2024a . We give a more thorough analysis, but the latter paper addresses related challenges beyond the scope of this paper. We show this by analysing a textbook-style presentation of BO . This analysis is of independent value since it identifies the idealizations that do and do not play a role in BO . The second aim of this paper is to address concerns about the rigour of the textbook presentation of BO : in particular, subtle issues regarding the justification of the mathematical idealizations involved in modern formalisations. Sutcliffe and Woolley 2012 argue that assumptions regarding the discrete spectra of electronic Hamiltonians used in BO are unjustified. Furthermore, they suggest that removing these unjustified mathematical idealizations requires making use of resources of classical physics and empirical data introduced ‘by hand’. We consider the response to Sutcliffe and Woolley 2012 in Jecko 2014 and examine the latter’s argument that the