Independence in Integrated Population Models

Frédéric Barraquand · 2024

Read Independence in Integrated Population Models by Frédéric Barraquand (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01877.txt.

Description

Abstract Integrated population models (IPMs) combine multiple ecological data types such as capture-mark-recapture histories, reproduction surveys, and population counts into a single statistical framework. In such models, each data type is generated by a probabilistic submodel, and an assumption of independence between the different data types is usually made.

Catalog record

CREATORFrédéric Barraquand
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01877

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Independence in Integrated Population Models Frédéric Barraquand Abstract Integrated population models (IPMs) combine multiple ecological data types such as capture-mark-recapture histories, reproduction surveys, and population counts into a single statistical framework. In such models, each data type is generated by a probabilistic submodel, and an assumption of independence between the different data types is usually made. The fact that the same biological individuals can contribute to multiple data types has been perceived as affecting their independence, and several studies have even investigated IPM robustness in this scenario. However, what matters from a statistical perspective is probabilistic independence: the joint probability of observing all data is equal to the product of the likelihoods of the various datasets. Contrary to a widespread perception, probabilistic non-independence does not automatically result from collecting data on the same physical individuals. Conversely, while there can be good reasons for non-independence of IPM submodels arising from sharing of individuals between data types, these relations do not seem to be included in IPMs whose robustness is being investigated. Furthermore, conditional rather than true independence is sometimes assumed. In this conceptual paper, I survey the various independence concepts used in IPMs, try to make sense of them by getting back to first principles in toy models, and show that it is possible to obtain probabilistic independence (or near-independence) despite two or three data types collected on the same set of biological individuals. I then revisit recommendations pertaining to component data collection and IPM robustness checks, and provide some suggestions to bridge the current gap between individual-level IPMs and their population-level approximations using composite likelihoods. Keywords : Integrated Population Model; independence; data fusion; reproduction; survival, Cormack-Jolly-Seber. 1 Introduction An integrated population model gathers several data streams into a single statistical framework for demographic parameter estimation. Typically, within population ecology at least, the datasets considered are counts of individual organisms (e.g., a population census), capture-mark-recapture or mark-recovery data, and sometimes fecundity data (e.g., a survey of nests). The likelihoods corresponding to each dataset are then usually multiplied to provide a single likelihood for the integrated population model, which is then maximized to find the parameter values; or the code for the various models is written sequentially inside a procedure for Bayesian Monte Carlo estimation, with similar assumptions and results. This statistical model construction assumes that it is sensible to multiply component likelihoods in the first place, which can be justified by an assumption of independence between datasets. In their seminal paper on integrated population models, Besbeas et al. (2002) made the remark that “The assumption of independence made here is not likely to be violated” . Later they more cautiously pointed out that “It is sometimes the case that census data and demographic data are not independent. This can occur, for instance, in studies involving mammals living on small islands [Soay sheep on St-Kilda, Tavecchia et al. (2009) ]” in Besbeas et al. (2009) . The small study area implies that data on specific sheep individuals can be collected in the form of capture and reproduction histories, while the same individuals are also being counted every year. They found that combining recovery information with dependent [their wording] census data, then “RMSEs are mostly increased compared to the case of combining with independent census data.” Dependence referred in that case to the overlap in the sets of individuals that contribute to each dataset. This dependence-through-overlapping-individuals could appear even more worrying when combining capture-mark-recapture and fecundity data, e.g., in birds, since ecologists usually ring and measure fecundity at the nest on the very same individuals. Thus there is potential for massively overlapping sets of individuals contributing to the different datasets. Numerous IPM studies—original work and reviews—have since then equated sharing of individuals between datasets with the independence assumption, and logically warned that the assumption might not be met ( Schaub and Abadi, 2011 ; Gamelon et al., 2016 ; Zipkin and Saunders, 2018 ; Gould et al., 2024 , e.g.,) . Due to this perceived violation of IPM assumptions by most available ecological data, simulation-based studies have attempted to check the extent of the issues generated by the sharing of individuals between the datasets on which IPMs are built. They found overall a rather marked robustness. Abadi et al. (2010) noted that “the violation of the assumption of independence had only minor consequences on the precision and accuracy of the parameter estimates” . Attempts to compare exact individual-based modelling of the likelihood to multiplication of component likelihoods by Béliveau (2016) also yielded similar results, with only small effects on parameter precision. More recently, Weegman et al. (2021) stated that “Contrary to previous investigators, we found no substantive bias or uncertainty in any demographic rate from IPMs derived from data sets with complete overlap [of individuals, between data sources].” They concluded that the violation of the independence assumption should not dissuade researchers from the application of IPMs in ecological research—see also Schaub and Kéry 2021 , chap. 7 p. 287, for a detailed summary of the literature on robustness checks of the independence assumption. In this paper, I attempt to make sense of these apparently contradictory findings and disambiguate the various meanings of the word independence in statistical ecology. I start by asking whether the statistical independence assumption can indeed be violated by simply having the same individuals contributing to different datasets. First in really simple toy models, then slightly more complex ones, and eventually in a very basic integrated population model. I then outline practical recommendations and suggestions for further statistical/theoretical work. 2 Probabilistic independence in simple models 2.1 Definitions Let us start by a couple of definitions of independence concepts. Probabilistic or statistical independence between two events A and B is equivalent to \mathbb{P}(A\cap B)=\mathbb{P}(A)\mathbb{P}(B) . The concept is easily extended to any pair of random variables, e.g., \mathbb{P}(X=1,Y=6)=\mathbb{P}(X=1)\mathbb{P}(Y=6) for two discrete-valued independent random variables X and Y . This can be extended to absolutely continuous random variables X and Y using probability densities, i.e., f_{X,Y}(x,y)=f_{X}(x)f_{Y}(y) . The above concept can be constrasted from physical independence , a concept constructed for the occasion of this paper, by which we mean that the physical entities on which the biometric measurements or counts are performed are not the same in the various datasets. We shall also assume that dependence is the logical complement of independence for the two abovementioned concepts. We consider a number of datasets \mathbf{D}_{k} , k\in\{1,...,K\} (typically K=2 to 4 ), each \mathbf{D}_{k} with values taken in \mathbb{N}^{d_{k}}\subset\mathbb{R}^{d_{k}} , with d_{k}=\dim(\mathbf{D}_{k}) , and produced by a model \mathcal{M}_{k} . Each model \mathcal{M}_{k} has an associated parameter set \boldsymbol{\theta}_{k}\in\mathbb{R}^{m_{k}} , m_{k} being the number of parameters in the k^{\text{th}} submodel, possibly with \boldsymbol{\theta}_{k}\cap\boldsymbol{\theta}_{l}\neq\emptyset for k\neq l . An Integrated Population Model (IPM) is constituted of the various submodels \mathcal{M}_{k} , has parameter set \boldsymbol{\theta}=\boldsymbol{\theta}_{1}\cup\boldsymbol{\theta}_{2}\cup...\cup\boldsymbol{\theta}_{K} and can be specified at the individual level with the full likelihood \mathcal{L}(\boldsymbol{\theta};\mathbf{D}_{1},...,\mathbf{D}_{K})=\mathbb{P}(\mathbf{D}_{1},...,\mathbf{D}_{K}|\boldsymbol{\theta}) , with a slight abuse of notation as I omit for simplicity the random variables generating the observed datasets. This likelihood is a particular case of joint likelihood in the terminology of Frost et al. 2023 . This full likelihood could be very complex if defined through an individual-level stochastic process, and fitted through MCMC.

Read the complete text