Mixing angle of K 1 ( 1270 / 1400 ) K_{1}(1270/1400) and the K K ¯ 1 ( 1400 ) K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecular interpretation of η 1 ( 1855 ) \eta_{1}(1855)
Zheng-Shu Liu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Ding-Kun Lian 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 · 2024
Read Mixing angle of K 1 ( 1270 / 1400 ) K_{1}(1270/1400) and the K K ¯ 1 ( 1400 ) K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecular interpretation of η 1 ( 1855 ) \eta_{1}(1855) by Zheng-Shu Liu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Ding-Kun Lian 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01867.txt.
Description
Abstract Due to the SU(3) symmetry breaking effect, the axial-vector kaons K 1 ( 1270 ) K_{1}(1270) and K 1 ( 1400 ) K_{1}(1400) are established to be mixtures of two P-wave K 1 A ( P 1 3 ) K_{1A}\left({{}^{3}{P_{1}}}\right) and K 1 B ( P 1 1 ) K_{1B}\left({{}^{1}{P_{1}}}\right) states.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zheng-Shu Liu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Ding-Kun Lian 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01867
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mixing angle of K 1 ( 1270 / 1400 ) K_{1}(1270/1400) and the K K ¯ 1 ( 1400 ) K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecular interpretation of η 1 ( 1855 ) \eta_{1}(1855) Zheng-Shu Liu 1, Xu-Liang Chen 1, Ding-Kun Lian 1, Ning Li 1, Wei Chen 1, 2 Abstract Due to the SU(3) symmetry breaking effect, the axial-vector kaons K 1 ( 1270 ) K_{1}(1270) and K 1 ( 1400 ) K_{1}(1400) are established to be mixtures of two P-wave K 1 A ( P 1 3 ) K_{1A}\left({{}^{3}{P_{1}}}\right) and K 1 B ( P 1 1 ) K_{1B}\left({{}^{1}{P_{1}}}\right) states. In QCD sum rules, we propose a new construction of the K 1 K_{1} current operators and calculate the two-point correlation functions by including the next-to-leading order four-quark condensates. The mixing angle is determined as θ = ( 46.95 − 0.23 + 0.25 ) ∘ \theta=\left({46.95_{-0.23}^{+0.25}}\right)^{\circ} by reproducing the masses of K 1 ( 1270 ) K_{1}(1270) and K 1 ( 1400 ) K_{1}(1400) . We further compose the K K ¯ 1 ( 1270 ) K\bar{K}_{1}\left({1270}\right) and K K ¯ 1 ( 1400 ) K\bar{K}_{1}\left({1400}\right) interpolating currents with exotic quantum numbers J P C = 1 − + J^{PC}=1^{-+} to investigate the possible molecular interpretation of the recently observed η 1 ( 1855 ) {\eta_{1}}(1855) state. We calculate the correlation functions and perform the QCD sum rule analyses for these two molecular systems. However, the spectral functions are found to be negative in physical regions so that they are not able to provide reliable investigations of the K K ¯ 1 K\bar{K}_{1} molecular states. pacs 12.39.Mk, 12.38.Lg, 14.40.Ev, 14.40.Rt I Introduction Quantum chromodynamics (QCD) is the fundamental theory to study the hadron structure and hadron spectroscopy. In QCD, there exist various exotic hadron configurations beyond the conventional q\bar{q} mesons and qqq baryons [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , such as the multiquark states, hybrid mesons, glueballs and so on [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Recently, the BESIII Collaboration reported the existence of an isoscalar state \eta_{1}(1855) in the J/\psi\to\gamma\eta_{1}(1855)\to\gamma\eta\eta^{\prime} process with a statistical significance of more than 19\sigma [ 9 , 10 ] . The quantum numbers of \eta_{1}(1855) have been determined as I^{G}J^{PC}=0^{+}1^{-+} , while its mass and decay width were measured as M=1855\pm 9_{-1}^{+6}\;{\rm{MeV}} and \Gamma=188\pm 18_{-8}^{+3}\;{\rm{MeV}} , respectively [ 9 , 10 ] . Combined with the isovector state \pi_{1}(1600) , the observation of \eta_{1}(1855) has been extensively considered to provide critical information about the 1^{-+} hybrid nonet [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . On the other hand, the molecular interpretation of \eta_{1}(1855) is also possible since its mass is just about 40 MeV below the K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) threshold [ 19 , 20 ] . Using the one boson exchange model, the authors of Ref. [ 19 ] investigated the attractive interaction and decay properties of K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecule with J^{PC}=1^{-+} , which supported the molecular explanation of \eta_{1}(1855) . In Ref. [ 20 ] , the radiative and strong decays of the S-wave K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecular state were studied within the effective Lagrangian approach, and the result was confronted with the experimental data. Using the chiral unitary approach, the interactions between pseudoscalar and axial-vector mesons were studied to describe \eta_{1}(1855) as a dynamically generated state [ 21 ] . Other different interpretations of \eta_{1}(1855) can be found in Refs. [ 22 , 23 ] . Accordingly, the authors of Ref. [ 24 ] suggested detecting \eta_{1}(1855) via photoproduction in order to distinguish its various interpretations. In PDG [ 1 ] , there are two physical axial-vector kaons K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) with quantum numbers J^{P}=1^{+} . Due to the SU(3) symmetry breaking, they are established to be mixtures of two P-wave states K_{1A}\left({{}^{3}{P_{1}}}\right) and K_{1B}\left({{}^{1}{P_{1}}}\right) \displaystyle\begin{gathered}\left|{K_{1}(1270)}\right\rangle=\sin\theta\left|{K_{1A}}\right\rangle+\cos\theta\left|K_{1B}\right\rangle,\hfill\\ \left|{K_{1}(1400)}\right\rangle=\cos\theta\left|{K_{1A}}\right\rangle-\sin\theta\left|K_{1B}\right\rangle,\hfill\end{gathered} where \theta is the mixing angle. There are numerous studies of the value of \theta in the literature. In Ref. [ 25 ] , the mixing angle was determined to be \theta={33^{\circ}} or 57^{\circ} by using the early experimental information on the masses and partial decay rates of K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) . In Ref. [ 26 ] , the authors estimated the mixing angle from the weak decays \tau\to K_{1}(1270/1400){\nu_{\tau}} , concluding that -{30^{\circ}}\leqslant\theta\leqslant{50^{\circ}} . Their further analysis indicated that the most favored value is \theta\approx{45^{\circ}} . A nonrelativistic constituent quark model calculation provided a constraint on the mixing angle {35^{\circ}}<\theta<{55^{\circ}} [ 27 ] , which is consistent with the value \theta={39^{\circ}}\pm{4^{\circ}} obtained in the framework of QCD sum rules by assuming the orthogonality of the mass eigenstates [ 28 ] . The studies of the charmed meson decays gave the preferred solution \theta\approx{-58^{\circ}} [ 29 ] . In Ref. [ 30 ] , the authors found that \theta={-(34\pm 13)^{\circ}} by comparing the light-cone sum rule calculation and the experimental data for B\to K_{1}\gamma and \tau\to K_{1}(1270){\nu_{\tau}} decays. However, it is found to be \theta\sim{33^{\circ}} by studying the relations between \theta and the mixing angle of f_{1}(1285)-f_{1}(1420) (h_{1}(1170)-h_{1}(1380)) [ 31 , 32 ] . Recently, the mixing angle is determined to be \theta={22^{\circ}}\pm{7^{\circ}} or \theta={68^{\circ}}\pm{7^{\circ}} by calculating a K_{1A}\to K_{1B} matrix element in the three-point QCD sum rules [ 33 ] . It is obviously that there is no consensus on the value of the mixing angle and the results from various approaches are still quite controversial. In this work, we shall present a different QCD sum rule calculation from that in Ref. [ 28 ] . We propose a new construction for the current operators of two axial-vector physical kaons and calculate the two-point correlation functions to extract the hadron masses. The mixing angle can be determined by reproducing the masses of K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) . The construction of the K_{1} operators is essential for studying the K\bar{K}_{1}(1400) molecular interpretation of \eta_{1}(1855) . This work is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we introduce a new method to construct the current operators of K_{1}(1270/1400) as the mixture of K_{1A}\left({{}^{3}{P_{1}}}\right) and K_{1B}\left({{}^{1}{P_{1}}}\right) . We then determine the mixing angle by reproducing the masses of K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) . In Sec. III, we construct the four-quark interpolating currents of K\bar{K}_{1}(1270/1400) and investigate the possibility of the molecular interpretation of {\eta_{1}}(1855) . A brief summary is given in the last section. II QCD sum rules for the axial-vector K_{1} mesons II.1 Construction of the K_{1} operators In general, the two P-wave states K_{1A}\left({{}^{3}{P_{1}}}\right) and K_{1B}\left({{}^{1}{P_{1}}}\right) can be coupled by the axial-vector and tensor currents respectively \displaystyle J_{A}^{\mu}(x)={\bar{s}}(x){\gamma^{\mu}}{\gamma_{5}}q(x),\;J_{B}^{\mu\nu}(x)={\bar{s}}(x){\sigma^{\mu\nu}}{\gamma_{5}}q(x)\,,\; (4) in which s is the strange quark field and q=u/d represents up or down quark field. Considering the mixing scheme in Eq. ( I ), we construct the interpolating currents for the mass eigenstates K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) as \displaystyle\begin{gathered}J_{1270}^{\mu}(x)=J_{A}^{\mu}(x)\sin\theta+J_{B}^{\mu}(x)\cos\theta,\;\hfill\\ J_{1400}^{\mu}(x)=J_{A}^{\mu}(x)\cos\theta-J_{B}^{\mu}(x)\sin\theta,\;\hfill\end{gathered} where J_{B}^{\mu}(x) is defined from the current J_{B}^{\mu\nu}(x) in Eq. ( 4 ) and we shall give its specific form and discuss the detail later. Using the above interpolating currents, one can reproduce the masses of K_{1}(1270) and K_{1}(1400) within the QCD sum rules by calculating the two-point correlation function \displaystyle\Pi_{X}^{\mu\nu}\left({{p^{2}}}\right)={\rm{i}}\int{{{\rm{d}}^{d}}x}\;{{\rm{e}}^{{\rm{i}}p\cdot x}}\left\langle\Omega\right|{\mathsf{T}}\left[{J_{X}^{\mu}(x)J_{X}^{\nu{\dagger}}(0)}\right]\left|\Omega\right\rangle. (8) According to Eq. (