Higher Willmore Energies from tractor coupled GJMS operators

Ben F. Allen and Rod Gover · 2024

Read Higher Willmore Energies from tractor coupled GJMS operators by Ben F. Allen and Rod Gover (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2411-01835.txt.

Description

Abstract . We define and construct a conformally invariant energy for closed smoothly immersed submanifolds of even dimension, but of arbitrary codimension, in conformally flat Riemannian manifolds. This is a higher dimensional analogue of the Willmore energy for immersed surfaces and is given directly via a coupling of the tractor connection to the (submanifold critical) GJMS operators.

Catalog record

CREATORBen F. Allen and Rod Gover
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2411-01835

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Higher Willmore Energies from tractor coupled GJMS operators Thanks: B.A. & A.R.G. gratefully acknowledges support from the Royal Society of New Zealand via Marsden Grant 19-UOA-008. A.R.G.’s contribution to this work was also partially supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation and EPSRC Grant Number EP/RO14604/1 during a visit to the Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences Ben F. Allen and Rod Gover Abstract . We define and construct a conformally invariant energy for closed smoothly immersed submanifolds of even dimension, but of arbitrary codimension, in conformally flat Riemannian manifolds. This is a higher dimensional analogue of the Willmore energy for immersed surfaces and is given directly via a coupling of the tractor connection to the (submanifold critical) GJMS operators. In the case where the submanifold is of dimension 4 we compare this to other energies, including one found using a second simple construction that uses Q Q -operators. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification primary: 53C18, 53B25; secondary: 53B15; 53A31; 53A55 1. Introduction The Willmore energy of a closed immersed surface \Sigma in Euclidean n -space is given by (1) \int_{\Sigma}|H|^{2}~dv^{\Sigma}_{\bar{\boldsymbol{g}}} where H^{a} is the mean curvature vector field. As the integrand is quadratic in H the Euler-Lagrange equation (from variations of embedding) has a linear leading term, and this is \Delta H^{a} , up to a non-zero constant factor, where \Delta is this normal-bundle-coupled submanifold Laplacian. A significant part of the interest in the energy ( 1 ) stems from the fact that it is conformally invariant [ 3 , 36 , 35 , 32 ] , which means that so also is the Willmore equation. The functional gradient of ( 1 ) is an interesting conformal invariant of surfaces, in particular because of the linear leading term. There has been considerable interest in finding analogues of this energy and equation for submanifolds of higher dimension. For hypersurfaces (meaning submanifolds of codimension 1) in Euclidean 5-space [ 29 ] Guven attacked the problem by setting up an explict undetermined coefficient problem to search among basic objects to find a combination that is invariant under conformal motions. More recently some constructions of higher Willmore equations and energies have used holographic approaches, meaning that each submanifold is linked to solutions of an appropriate geometric partial differential on the ambient (or host) manifold. To the extent that the solution is uniquely determined by the submanifold, the jets of the solution capture the data of the submanifold. For hypersurfaces in conformal manifolds, of any dimension, this was initiated in [ 23 ] (online as [ 19 ] ) based on a singular Yamabe problem, inspired by [ 1 , 13 ] , and then followed up in detail in a series developing also surrounding theory [ 28 , 25 , 20 , 17 , 21 , 22 , 18 ] ; see also [ 30 ] . For higher codimension embeddings, Graham-Reichert and Zhang have found higher Willmore energy analogues [ 27 , 37 ] by exploiting what might be called a 2-step holography that involves a minimal submanifold problem in Poincaré-Einstein manifolds, as studied in the Graham-Witten work [ 28 ] where already a link to the Willmore energy was noted. Each of these constructions mentioned provide higher analogues of the Willmore equation, as the equations involved are conformally invariant geometric PDEs that are fully determined by the conformal submanifold embedding data, and have a linear leading term. For hypersurfaces this is discussed in detail in [ 18 ] . We will refer to invariant submanifold action integrals as being of Willmore-type if their variations with respect to embeddings have such an appropriate leading term. The holographic constructions of Willmore energies and related invariants are interesting because the energies and their Euler-Lagrange equations are determined indirectly as geometric invariants of the formal asymtotics of a geometric PDE problem in the ambient (or host) manifold in which the submanifold is embedded. This is conceptually powerful as it means these quantities arise as data in an application that is independently interesting. On the other hand these holographic constructions do not directly provide a formula in terms of the underlying conformal embedding. One needs to extract such formulae from the jets of an asymptotic solution, and that can be complicated. This fact provides good motivation to seek simpler direct constructions of the Willmore-type energies, and that is what we take up in the current article. Apart from their direct interest for PDE problems (such as understanding their extrema) the resulting formulae can inform the holographic programme. In the 2013 work [ 34 ] , Vyatkin used the tractor calculus and a result from [ 8 ] to construct a curvature quantity Q , for four dimensional hypersurfaces embedded in conformally flat spaces, that is somewhat of a hypersurface analogue of Branson’s Q -curvature; see Lemma 5.2.7 of [ 34 ] . For closed hypersurfaces \Sigma , the associated conformally invariant integral is \int_{\Sigma}\left(\frac{4}{9}D^{k}I\!I^{\circ~}_{~jk}D_{l}I\!I^{\circ jl}-4p_{j}^{~l}I\!I^{\circ}_{~lk}I\!I^{\circ jk}+2\jmath I\!I^{\circ}_{~jk}I\!I^{\circ jk}\right)dv^{\Sigma}_{\bar{\boldsymbol{g}}}, where I\!I^{\circ}{}_{jk}:=I\!I^{\circ}{}_{jk}{}^{a}N_{a} is the tracefree second fundamental form for hypersurfaces, p_{jk} the intrinsic Schouten tensor of the submanifold, and \jmath is its metric trace. Here dv^{\Sigma}_{\bar{\boldsymbol{g}}} is the volume form density for the submanifold that is determined by the conformal structure. Vyatkin shows that (up to a non-zero constant factor) the variation of this action has leading term \Delta^{2}H , where H is the mean curvature of the submanifold. So it provides a higher Willmore energy that is explicit, direct, and conformally invariant by construction. A main focus of this paper is the construction of a generalising analogue of this Vyatkin energy to arbitrary codimension, by using the tractor calculus for submanifolds developed in [ 12 ] and the Q -operators of [ 7 , 8 ] , and this is done in Section 3.1 . A second focus is the construction of energies of Willmore-type for closed submanifolds of any even dimension embedded in conformally flat spaces of arbitrary codimension by using a coupling of the conformal Laplacian operators of [ 26 ] (the GJMS operators ), and this can be found in Section 3.2 . A comparison between the GJMS and Q -operator energies is given in Section 3.3 , and a proof that these energies are of Willmore-type is given in Section 3.5 . An introduction to the tractor calculus of conformal submanifolds is given in Section 2 . The following two theorems summarise the results of this paper. Theorem 1.1 . Let \Sigma^{m}\rightarrow M be a closed submanifold of even dimension m immersed in a conformally flat Riemannian manifold M of arbitrary codimension. There is a conformally invariant energy \tilde{\mathcal{E}} on \Sigma of Willmore-type defined by (2) \tilde{\mathcal{E}}:=\int_{\Sigma}N^{A}_{B}P^{\nabla}_{m}N^{B}_{A}dv^{\Sigma}_{\bar{\boldsymbol{g}}}\,, where N^{A}_{B} is the normal tractor projector and P^{\nabla}_{m} is the intrinsic critical GJMS operator coupled to the ambient tractor connection. The idea behind the construction of the above energy is as follows. On a conformal manifold of even dimension m there exist the GJMS operators [ 26 ] , and more specifically the critical GJMS operator, which has leading term \Delta^{m/2} . A conformal submanifold embedded in a conformally flat manifold M is equipped with a conformally invariant flat connection on the ambient tractor bundle – this is simply the pullback to \Sigma of the

Read the complete text